Up the Ass

Before you can answer, the door opens and an upperclassman walks in. Smiling broadly, he introduces himself as Noah.

"So, what've you guys decided on?"

You glance at Doe. She meets your gaze and shrugs. So, now it's all on you. With a feeble smile, you point to the picture of the man giving the woman anal sex.

"That one," you answer.

Noah's smile widens.

"Alrighty then! If you follow me, I'll show you to your judges."

Silently, you and Doe follow Noah out the door and onto the theater's stage. Out in the house, in the front row, two more upperclassmen sit apprehensively. Noah stops you and Doe center stage.

"Hey, Lacey, Tim, we've got us some anal lovers, here!" Noah laughs, dropping down next to the other judges.

"Ooh!" Lacey coos, leaning forward.

"Alright, guys, you've got two minutes to accurately recreate the anal scene," Tim smiles. "If you can't do it in that time, you'll be docked 30 points. The time starts now."

Doe looks at you solemnly as you both deposit your clothes on the floor.

"Be gentle," she murmurs. As the judges hoot appreciatively, she turns around and bends over. Taking a deep breath, you gently part her soft ass cheeks. Her wrinkled sphincter winks invitingly at you, beckoning you forward. You place your hard cock in front of her hole.

Nearby, Lacey coughs. You jump back, startled. You have no idea when she had climbed onto the stage with you, but she is now less than three feet away.

"You should probably lube yourself up first," Lacey smiles, taking off her beret.

"Amateur," Noah laughs.

Lacey kneels down in front of you, taking hold of your cock in her soft hands. Pushing back her shoulder-length blond hair, she gently kisses the tip of your cock before taking in the head.

"It's been a minute!" Tim calls out.

Lacey gently bobs her head, taking more of your shaft in every time.

"John!" Doe cries out, glaring at you from between her legs.

"Um, I really need to...ass," you say, trying to pull away.

With a wry grin, Lacey places her hands on your ass and pulls you forward, taking all of you into her mouth. Your eyes widen in surprise as your cock touches the back of her throat, then goes even further. She holds you there a moment and you can only groan as her throat muscles massage your shaft.

"Thirty seconds!" Tim declares.

Lacey finally pulls back, leaving your dick slathered in spit.

"Go fuck some ass," she grins, pushing you towards Doe.

"Finally!" Doe sighs as you reposition yourself.

Placing yourself at her asshole, you take hold of her waist and slowly push yourself in. First of all, you notice that it's a lot harder than it looks in the movies. Doe whimpers softly as you finally get your head through the opening. Her ass is tight; the muscles squeeze you so hard it almost hurts. The only reason you're able to go any further at all is because of Lacey's spit. You groan softly, inching further into her. Once you reach the halfway point, Doe suddenly convulses, her eyes rolling up in her head as her ass tightens even further.

"Ten seconds!" Tim calls out.

Hoping that Doe understands the severity of the situation, you thrust forward with all your might, burying yourself completely. You both cry out as your hips slap together. As Tim counts down, you place your hands on Doe's hips and she slightly arches her back, imitating the lovers in the painting.