Unrequited

You were out on the town with your friend-with-benefits Esther, enjoying the surprisingly warm fall weather on café terrace when someone came up to the two of you.

"Hey! Noelle" Esther said, smiling broadly. She got up and hugged the other woman.

"Hey Esther" the blonde hugging your FWB said. "Who's this?"

"Oh, right. Noelle, meet John. John, this is Noelle. We went to high school together" Esther explained. You shook hands with Noelle.

"And what are you to Esther?" Noelle asked you.

"John is a friend" Esther said.

"Oh, right" the blonde replied in a tone that told you that she knew very well what kind of friend you were. She gave you a look then almost visibly inwardly shrugged. The two women talked for a while with you feeling like a little bit of a third wheel until Noelle said she had to go. When she'd gone you gave Esther a look.

"What is it?" she asked.

"Did your FWB network just intersect?" you asked.

"Yeah, it did" Esther replied.

"And?" you wanted to know.

"And what? Oh, let me guess. You want to know who's the better friend?" she told you.

"I mean.." you started, trailing off meaningfully.

"The two of you scratch different itches" the redhead said, smirking. She leaned in and licked at your ear before whispering: "Sure, Noelle has a nice strap on, but nothing beats the feeling of a thick, hot, honest to God hard cock." She laughed when she noticed you shiver at her words, giving your knee a pat. "I imagine you'll be wanting some help with that?" she asked, gesturing at your groin.

"How do you know I'm hard?" you asked.

"If you weren't already, you are now. Imagining me and Noelle making out, no doubt" Esther said, moving her hand to your groin. When she found signs of life there, she squeezed and smiled. "I expect you'll want us to go to my place?" she said.

"Yeah, that's it" you told Esther as she sat on her knees in front of you. You had gotten as far as her hallway before her teasing had gotten the best of you and you'd pulled your cock out. Pushing the redhead to her knees even before she'd shut the door, you had put your dick in her mouth in record time. As the beauty bobbed her head along your length, moaning happily, you thrust against her face. She looked up at you and grinned, pulling away to jerk you off while talking dirty to you.

"What's gotten into you?" she asked.

"Can't I just want to fuck my friend-with-benefit's face?" you replied.

"Were you thinking of indecent lesbian sex?" Esther teased. "Fantasising watching me eating Noelle's pussy?"

"Mm, fuck" you moaned, "yeah, that sounds good."

"Oh yeah? Is that what you want, huh? You want to see that? Or better yet, watch it while you fuck me?" she continued. Your cock throbbed in her grasp as she talked to you while jerking you off. "So you do" she said as your cock answered for you.

"Shut up" you said, taking her hand off your cock, grabbing your length to slap it on her face. She giggled and opened her mouth, sticking out her tongue. Taking your cue from her you began to slap it on her tongue. She moaned and played with your balls while you used her for your own pleasure.

"Are you punishing me for teasing you?" Esther asked, grinning. "Because if you are, it's not working. I love getting cockslapped, baby."

"Shut up" you said with a laugh. "Actually, no, don't. Come here." You pulled the beautiful redhead to her feet and kissed her hard. Although you weren't in a romantic relationship with Esther, the two of you were good enough to occasionally kiss, especially when you were caught up in lust or passion, like you were now. She replied to you in kind, slipping you tongue while working on your belt.

"Just get naked, John" the redhead said in between breaks of kissing.

"Only if you do the same" you told her, taking her shirt off. Underneath were her big, soft breasts, hidden away behind a man's greatest enemy: a bra. Instead of unhooking it, you just yanked it down, making those big tits jiggle.

"Impatient, aren't we?" Esther asked.

"God, yes" you said, groping those full tits of hers to your heart's content. "I love those big tits of yours." To prove this you leaned in to suck on her pierced nipples one at a time while squeezing them. While you did this Esther stroked your hair, moaning happily.

"Mm, save some for later, John" she said. "You can play with them later. Right now I need to get fucked."

"Yeah? Where would you like to get fucked?" you asked as you stood up straight, eager to get started.

"As for location, why not right here? As for hole, how about my ass, stud? It's an anal kind of day" she said.

"Yeah, that's what I like to see" you said as you looked over Esther. Her gorgeous body was on full display to you, the parts that mattered anyway, and you were stroking yourself while looking at her. The redhead's fingers dipped in and out of her pussy, making her moan lustily.

"I bet" she said, "watching your sexy friend play with herself turns you on a lot."

"For sure" you replied, gesturing at your cock. "You always get me hard."

"That's so flattering" Esther said, biting her lip. "To be the reason that big fat cock is hard."

"Well, it's not entirely your fault alone" you said.

"Noelle, huh?" the redhead asked with a big grin on her face. "I don't blame you, but she's gay as fuck, baby. I know you'd love defiling that pussy with that massive fuckstick, to be the first guy inside of there, but that's not in your cards. So why not fuck me instead, huh? Wet your cock in this pretty cunt first" she said while spreading her lips wide, revealing her perfect pink insides to you. "Then once your big dick is nice and slippery, put it up my ass. I love getting my shitpipe fucked, you know that. It'll make you forget all about Noelle. She won't let you anywhere near her pussy, let alone her ass."

"You fucking bitch" you said with a grin. "You know just what to say to get my attention."

"Of course I do. You're my main squeeze, baby. I know what makes your cock hard. Every little trick to get you horny is in my arsenal" Esther said as she finished taking her panties off. "Now come here. Give it to me."

You joined Esther on the couch and took your cock in hand, putting it against her cunt before pushing your hips forward. Her wetness enveloped you and before long you were pounding away at the red twat in front of you, the couch moving a tiny bit with every thrust forward. As you nailed her, Esther closed her legs around you and put her hands on your shoulders, looking up at you with a big grin.

"Yes!" she exclaimed, "yes! Make me your bitch, John! Make me forget my name while my pussy makes you forget about Noelle!"

"Jesus Christ, Esther" you said, thrusting into her. "You really do know what to say."

"Absolutely" she replied. "I told you I know just what makes your engine rev, baby. You don't need to fantasise about a lesbian girl, no matter how hot she is. You got me right here and, as if I need to remind you, I've got nice big and bouncy tits and love anal. I take facials and love swallowing your cum too. What need would you have of her?"

"I know, I know" you said, grinning, leaning in to kiss her. "But a man can look, can't he?"

"A woman can do, too" Esther replied after kissing you back. "This one does so a lot, in fact."

"Yeah, I bet you do" you said, thrusting into Esther's red muff. "I don't blame you."

"Nor should you" she said after a few moans. "Now stop trying to distract me and fuck me like you mean it!"

After a while Esther had insisted she take control, so you were sitting on her couch while she was riding you. Her ample tits bounced in your face and you were enjoying the sights and sounds enormously.

"Yeah, you like that, don't you?" she asked, grinning.

"Duh" you said, watching her move. Those big tits kept drawing your attention and when she noticed she laughed.

"Drink 'em in, John" she said, "they're all yours."

"Oh yeah? What about a nice wet titfuck later, then?" you suggested.

"For sure" she said, "but right now, you owe me something" Esther told you.

"What's that?" you asked, rather predictably.

"Anal" she said, raising herself up off your cock and smiling. While she reached below and took a hold of your cock she grinned. "I bet you want to fuck Noelle's ass too, but that's not going to happen. Just be happy with me, huh? I love that huge fucking elephant dick and plan to make use of it as much as I can." She lowered herself onto your cock slowly, agonisingly so, moaning happily as her greedy ass swallowed your rod inch by inch.