Try and get Emma to admit her immoral tryst with Sabrina

It might be fun to get one over on Sabrina’s little sister. Sabrina has been more than happy to do just that whenever the opportunity presents itself. She might even play along. You don’t know Emma’s true boundaries though, and admitting that she had a lesbian affair with her own sister might be something that she wouldn’t willingly admit after all.

Sabrina isn’t being helpful in that department either. She is happy to return the conversation back to mundane topics like job prospects and household chores. This spurs a miffed response from the younger sister, not liking the feeling of being nagged at by her elder. You have to direct their attention to their orders so that this doesn’t **** into a bickering contest between the siblings.

The conversation dies down once the food arrives. You all enjoy your meal and drinks as you think over ways to tease out a confession from Emma.

“Would you be willing to do nudes?” you ask Emma after finishing a bite of your burger.

“Why? Are you interested?” Emma replies with a perked eyebrow. She really is quick to flirt. It’s unclear whether she’s like this to all the guys or just you. Sabrina is paying close attention to your response.

“I meant for your potential modeling career,” you clarify.

“Oh… maybe,” she decides. “I guess, it would depend on who is there with me…” she grins at you with fluttering eyes. Sabrina’s eyes narrow and she gingerly masticates her pasta. This might not be the best approach.

“So, what’s the wildest thing you’ve done with the ‘right’ person?” you counter.

Emma’s pupils sharpen as she thinks back, eyes darting to her left for a second, catching a glimpse of Sabrina. Sabrina pauses, mid bite, waiting for her response.

“Well…” Emma starts slowly, eyeing her sister again. “There was this one time, me and Sabrina were all alone together… we were in her room with nothing on…”

You stifle your grin and perk your eyebrow. This is sounding promising.

Sabrina puts her fork down and watches her sister, eyes bulging. Emma can see this and it only urges her to go on.

“You know how hot it gets at night…” Emma smirks, eyeing you intently for your response.

“Well, after we all got naked that night, this isn’t sounding that wild…” you reply, feigning unimpressed.

“We did share a bed…” Emma reveals, biting her lower lip.

Sabrina looks at you and you raise an eyebrow at her. She looks away with a huff. She isn’t overtly opposed to her sister exposing their activities, but isn’t about to egg her on either.

“Did you… do anything on the bed?” you continue to pry.

Emma turns to Sabrina who is looking visibly uncomfortable about this whole interview. Emma holds her gaze, as if provoking her sister to react to this scandalous story about to be revealed. Sabrina turns her head and looks back at Emma. They have a staredown, seeing who between them has the courage to admit what they really did together. They grin nervously at each other as the tension mounts. You start to get an uneasy feeling waiting for the other shoe to drop.

Finally, Sabrina turns to you and says, “Emma and I fucked on my bed last weekend.”

Emma’s jaw drops as fast as the salacious news! Her face goes pale, mortified by what her sister just revealed about them. She looks at you with horror as their dark secret has come to light.