Truth

"Truth," you reply.

Amie smiles when she looks at you then at Loretta. "Did you take Loretta's virginity?"

You hesitate, waiting to see the blonde farm girl's reaction. Loretta gives you a barely noticeable nod. "Yes I did," you answer, hoping that your confessions of deflowering Connie and Loretta won't leave these walls. The other girls gasp. Val grins at you with clearly lust in her eyes.

"Truth or Dare?" you ask Val after taking a gulp of beer.

"Truth," she says.

"Are you a virgin?" you ask, suspecting she hasn't been one for years.

"No!" the young mechanic snorts and laughs. "Sorry, I haven't been mistaken for a virgin for a while!"

"Truth or Dare?" Val asks Ellie.

"Truth," the older sister responds.

"Did you fuck John?" Val asks, smiling at you.

Ellie looks at her sister and then to you. "Yes," she answers. You expect Connie to be upset but instead she hugs her sister, making you wonder how close the two girls are.

The young bartender turns to Amie. "Truth or Dare?

"Dare," the young Chinese girl replies.

"I dare you to lose your virginity," the Ellie suggests, winking at you. Amie's eyes widen like a doe in incoming headlights while her girlfriends let out gasps of shock and surprise at Ellie's suggestion. The Asian girl looks at Ellie then to you and then back at Ellie. She nods with a smile and the other girls hugs her.

When your car broke down in this small town you would have never suspected to have the chance to have sex with so many beautiful, young women, let alone deflower two of them. Now you are now offered to pop a third girl's cherry. Connie and Loretta, who you now consider your girlfriends, look back at you and give an approving smile and nod.

"Shall we go upstairs to one of the bedrooms? you ask.

"No, the rules of the game says all dares have to be in front of everyone," Amie says with determination in her high-pitched voice. "Besides, I want to lose my virginity with my best friends."

Everybody knows that it took a lot of courage for the otherwise meek Amie to make such a bold request. "Honey, the rest of us will get undressed too and make out so you won't feel so stressed out for your first time," Ellie suggests.

"Thank you," Amie whispers with a smile.

You volunteer to take your clothes off first -- the girls intently watch you remove your shirt and then your pants. Standing with your massive erection confined by your underwear you kick off your shoes and socks. "I should have dared you to have sex with me," Val jokes when you finally remove your underwear to reveal your long, thick cock. It's quite clear that the girls have seen each other nude as they show no signs of modesty or embarrassment when they strip off their clothes.

You take Amie's hand and lead her to the large sheepskin rug in front of the fireplace and help her lie down on it. She looks up at you and smiles nervously as she unconsciously tries to cover her small A-cup breasts while spreading her slender legs wide apart in anticipation for you. The other girls circle around the rug and hold each other as they are about to share a special unique moment of their close friend.

"It'll be great, honey," Connie whispers. "John took my virginity last night."

"And he popped my cherry too," Loretta adds with a warm smile. "The sex was amazing!"

"I can vouch for that!" Ellie pipes up.

"I feel left out," Val mumbles.

"Should I get a condom?" you ask Amie.

"No, I want to feel my first cock," she replies. Encouraged by her friends, Amie stares at you with lust in her big, brown doe eyes. "Please fuck me."

You kneel between her thighs and grab your cock and rub it up and down her wet, bald snatch, causing her moan softly. Amie bites her lower lip as your cockhead slips between her pussy lips and stop. "Ready?" you ask in a caring, fatherly voice.

She nods.

You push your hips forward and her pussy slowly engulfs its first cock. Loretta and Connie comforts Amie as her pain slowly subsides and she gets used to having a thick cock inside her impossibly tight cunt.

"Thank you for being my first," Amie whispers as she holds out her arms up to pull you down on top of her. Making sure you don't crush her small frame, you press your chest against hers as she wraps her legs around your thighs. "Fuck me like you fucked them," she whispers in your ear.

With those words you lose track of time and forget about the other girls making out in the basement. Every time Amie cums, you pull out of her and move her into a different position -- from on her back to on her hands and knees to her doing a shoulder stand -- to be deeply penetrated. Being the smallest of the five girls, you have no problem lifting Amie up and spearing her with your cock. She wraps her arms around your neck as you lift her ass up and down the length of your thick shaft. After a minute or two she lets out another orgasmic cry, signalling for you to change positions again. You shuffle over to the armchair and lower the petite Asian down. Throwing her legs over your shoulders, you go for broke and pound away at her hapless cunt.

"Fuck her!" you hear Ellie yell out.

"OhGod!OhGod!OhGod!OhGod!OhGod!" Amie mutters as her pussy muscles squeezes your invading cock.

"Fuck her hard!" Val encourages you.

You grunt and growl like a frothing animal in heat as your balls loudly slap Amie's upturn ass. Then with one last thrust, you let out a roar and coat her womb with thick jets of semen. Amie pulls your face down to hers and kisses you. "Thank you," she whispers.

"I guess we're not playing Truth or Dare? any more?" you say, looking around to see Connie, Loretta, and Val kissing and fingering each other on the couch. Ellie is lying on a bean bag chair with her thighs spread wide apart and rubbing her snatch.