Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 13 by Cross C Cross C

What happens next?

Time passes and he has sex with Lucy.

It was late in the evening of the following day and the four of us were turning in for bed in my crappy one room apartment. Natsu was a weird and sometimes frightening guy but he was generally nice enough. He'd agreed to not just help Lucy get into Fairy Tail but me as well!

It turned out that with the rings I'd taken from Bora he assumed I was a Mage as well. I was enthusiastic beyond all reason because this gave me the perfect excuse to ditch Hargeon and accompany Lucy to Magnolia. That wonderful girl, who was for all intents and purposes now my girlfriend, had even helped me take care of everything I needed to do to make the move and Natsu and Happy had been kind enough to put off returning to their guild until we were ready.

They'd also pretty much assumed that they could shack up with me without even asking, but I seriously wasn't going to complain, not when Lucy needed somewhere to stay too!

Natsu and Happy were content with the rather uncomfortable couch. Lucy was taking my bed, obviously, and here I was now wringing my hands about whether or not to share it with her. We were definitely something of a couple, though the effect of the earrings made the particulars of our relationship rather murky. Thanks to them we'd already had a kind of sex but I also knew that she was physically attracted to me apart from them given her seemingly great appreciation for my penis. Then there was the saving her from the slavers, that had seriously gotten me some serious brownie points. Ugh... and lets not forget whatever lingering effects there were from my accidental charm spell upon her.

“What are you thinking about, Najato?” I jumped in surprise as she called out from the bed.

I didn't to talk about what I'd really been thinking so instead I blurted out the first thing that came to mind, “I- uh...er. Normally, sleep without uh....clothes...so-” Wait. Where was I going with this? It was true. Morning wood in underwear of any kind was a rather painful way to wake up, so I slept naked but WHY WAS I BRINGING THIS UP? After a moment I relaxed remembering that the earrings saved me from any and all awkwardness.

“Well yea of course, silly. Go ahead and take off your boxers. It's not like I haven't seen it before.” smiled Lucy as she reached down to pull off her white t-shirt. I watched her bra-encased boobs bounce a bit and then I watched them bounce and jiggle a lot more as she removed her bra. I stared in wonder once again at her amazingly large tits, sitting so high and full on her chest despite their size. Oh those cute pink nipples... I watched her reach under the covers and her legs shifted around and soon she was retrieving a small bit of white cotton. Oh god. She was completely naked... in my bed!

Team Arousal beat Team Modesty especially when I could do whatever I wanted consequence free and I pushed down my underwear. I loved the way Lucy watched me closely as I did so nor did I miss her tongue slipping out to moisten her lips as she eyed my crotch in particular.

The moment was somewhat marred when Natsu (Yea, I'd forgotten about the rest of my house guests) on the couch nearby opened his eyes to exclaim, “What the- Am I a reverse Gray now? Hmph... can't sleep like this-” And he started taking off all of his clothes, even though he'd been perfectly content to go to bed fully clothed earlier. What the hell? I looked on in confusion and more than a little discomfort as the guy stripped completely nude like it was a perfectly normal thing to do in a stranger's home. Seriously? What the hell? I'd thought Lucy was just being sexy and playing along with her boyfriend... Why was Natsu taking off all his clothes?

My thought processes were derailed when I noticed Lucy looking directly at the mage's penis. I felt a pulse of jealousy and possessiveness but I pushed such emotions aside. I had the distinct impression this situation was somehow my own fault and I couldn't find it in myself act on those ill feelings given that I owed so much to both of these individuals. Lucy for the world and Natsu for giving me the opportunity to save her from the slavers. So instead, I used the opportunity to quash my indecision and I joined Lucy on my bed.

I pressed my nude body up against hers and reveled in her smooth warm curves, the bulk of my hardening member fitting perfectly into the cleft of her very full yielding bottom.

“Mmmm... That feels nice...” she murmured as I breathed in the scent of her hair. I threw one arm around her and one of her large pliant breasts soon filled my hand. I resolved to simply settle down and sleep but more and more my awareness focused on two things: the exquisite sensation of my fingers sinking into such abundant warm tit-flesh and my now rock hard member filling her generous butt cleavage. It was utterly impossible to sleep with this perfect lovely person with her perfectly built body cradled against mine. As my hand started to squeeze and fondle and my hips started to rock, driving my cock back and forth against her, I felt a driving need for more... more...

And the hell of it was... there was nothing stopping me from taking it!

I fought a ruthless battle in my mind against my own mind and my better nature had just started to win when Lucy started to move. She breathed in and pushed her breast against my hand even as her bottom started to slowly wiggle and squirm, my aching member caught between her cheeks.

“Oh god.” I groaned and I heard her make a sound of approval. A hand snaked back and I felt her velvety touch upon my shaft once more.

I gasped, could barely breath as my heart thundered in my chest. There was barely any conscious thought in my head as I asked, “Are we- are we going to.... have sex?”

“Do you want to?” she asked lightly.

“Oh god yes!”

She giggled and used her hand upon my shaft to push me onto my back as she rolled over to lay against me, one of her very sizable boobs collapsing across my chest as the other compressed it heavily. “Then yes, Najato. I'll be your first. And I think this-” I gasped again as she threw back the covers to expose our nude bodies to the open air as well as her hand stroking up and down the full length of my towering erection, “-will make me feel like its my first.”

I was uncomfortably aware of Natsu and Happy sleeping nearby, particularly the similarly nude mage who had eschewed all covering of any kind. But it was hard to be too discomforted with the most beautiful woman in the world currently pressed against me as she gave me a slow easy hand job.

I heard Lucy giggle and I asked her what it was and she pointed. I flinched as I followed her finger and saw that the pink haired mage had a very prominent boner. She whispered, “I don't think Natsu's really sleeping.”

Yea, I could see that and I wondered how my earrings were influencing the situation. Making Lucy think sex with me in the room with a another very naked apparently very aroused man was normal. And doing the same for Natsu, so that he wasn't annoyed or angry by our lewd act right in front of him. Despite my initial dismay, I couldn't help but feel a thrill of arousal at the thought of having an audience and I found myself relaxing.

Freed from the fear of social stigma I briefly eyed Natsu's dick and couldn't help but mentally compare his to mine. If his was the normal size then my cock really was enormous so I asked Lucy, feeling a thrill at being able to ignore common courtesy and talk about a guy right in front of him, “I see that. So uh... is that the average size?”

She never stopped guiding her hand up and down my cock so I wasn't too bothered by the long considering look she gave Natsu's member before she finally decreed, “No, his is pretty big I think. Eight inches maybe? Yours is longer but its how wide around yours is that makes it so huge.” Well, that was nice to know and I found myself really wondering if she'd be talking about this so casually without the earrings on.

In any event, I had an absurdly busty and beautiful girl against me so all further thoughts about Natsu faded as I asked, “So...how do we start?”

She giggled and threw a leg over my stomach as she pulled herself atop me and I groaned as my shaft found its way back between the cheeks of her ass and her wonderfully huge breasts spilled across my chest, “Let's start with kissing. Lots and lots of kissing. I need to be really ready before we do it.”

Lucy's perfect face descended and she pressed her lush lips to mine and I spent the next ten minutes simply enjoying the experience of lazily kissing her and dueling with her tongue even as my hands explored every inch of her divine flesh. At one point she caught my wandering hand and pressed it down between our bodies. She guided my fingers right into her warm wet folds and I groaned into her mouth when I plunged my finger inside of her. She moaned back and squirmed around the digit I enthusiastically explored her inner channel with.

I couldn't help but feel a thrill of unrestrained happiness at my current situation even as I felt a strong need for something more and I shifted my hips, driving my aching cock back and forth across her ass.

Lucy's face pulled back and she giggled, “Hee... Someone's getting impatient. Heh. That's okay. He's not the only one.” She sat back to sit fully on my pelvis, my prick coming even in closer contact with the cleft of her butt. I feasted my eyes on her perfection, her beautiful face, and those incredibly full jugs in particular. She lifted herself from her knees to her feet, squatting over me as she raised her full hips to overtake my erection's full height. She chuckled slightly, “Jeez, this thing is ridiculous.”

After a moment she looked into my eyes, “Okay. We're going to go real REAL slow. Just lay back and let me do it. Please don't try and shove it all in. Please. Your definitely bigger than I am down there.”

I nodded firmly while returning her gaze but I couldn't help but make a joke with the way my unusual size kept coming up, “Heh. And here I thought it was normal for women to love getting over stuffed with massive cocks like mine...”


Lucy pursed her lips and ignored his comment for the moment, her cheeks hot and red. What would it be like to be stretched to or past the absolute limit? The thought of throwing all caution to the way side and spearing herself fully around Najato's enormous tool was thrilling and deeply arousing. She shuddered in anticipation of the type of stinging pain having him so throbbingly deep would elicit, pain that would be so close to pleasure...

“Lucy?” he asked and she looked at him once more, “Are you sure you want to do this? You don't have to, you know?”

She felt a warmth of renewed affection for him given how very badly he clearly wanted this. But honestly, she couldn't think of a single reason why she shouldn't have sex with him right here and right now. She liked him. A lot. She was very attracted to him even if he wasn't as handsome as the boys she'd been with before. He'd stood by her side against those slavers and even threw her into the ocean to protect her while he stayed behind to face them alone save a motion-sick Natsu and Happy. Plus he'd gotten in bed with her and started to rub that big erection against her butt while fondling her breast, that sort of thing seemed to naturally lead to sex. Nothing odd about that.

With a smile just for him, she said, “How's this for an answer?”

With one hand wrapped around the base of his cock, she directed the large head to line up with her pussy. She held her breath and so did he as she carefully lowered herself. His cockhead nudged against her lips and amazingly easily punctured her thanks to her wetness. She gasped from the feeling of her pussy spreading around just the tip, the sensation completely unlike her previous experiences already. She stopped for a moment to catch her breath before going on.

Below her Najato had an expression of open wonder on his face before he looked slightly concerned and asked, “Are you alright? Is it- Is it too big? I- I don't want to hurt you.”

She shushed him with one finger to his lips and she lowered herself in one, long smooth motion until he bumped against her cervix. She let out a small cry of surprise at the slight twinge of pain that accompanied the overwhelming pleasure of his thick shaft's passage into her. Lucy rocked a bit side to side, feeling his large knob rub against her deep inside and she felt an intense desire to drive him even deeper, the pain somehow intoxicating rather than offputting. She'd never experienced this before with even her biggest lover bottoming out at a lesser seven inches. She couldn't quite understand it but she was suddenly hell-bent on using Najato's huge prick to stretch the boundaries of what she could tolerate. She winced slightly and pushed down. It was a deep throbbing ache when she finally did urge his girthy member past the small passage of her cervix to embed his cockhead in her womb. Lucy seethed as she pressed both of her hands into his chest. “Oh my god,” she squealed. Her body convulsed as pain and new found pleasure swirled together in an indiscernible mix. “It's so big, Najato!”

Please log in to view the image

He smiled shyly at her and she couldn't wait any longer. She surged downward, causing a bit more hurt as she recklessly drove him deeper into her **** womb. She felt like she was over stuffed with his massive cock and she....she loved it! His excessive girth meant she felt completely stretched around him. She thought she could feel his cock's every throbbing vein her pussy was drawn do tightly around it. The passage of her womb’s neck was a vice that held him firmly within her, making it a little difficult when she tried to ride him. With a rather forceful tug that made them both hiss, he popped out of her uterus, his emerging cock coated in a heavy dose of her vaginal mucus that made the return journey into her even easier. She looked down and marveled at the sight of his huge cock burying back into her petals, spreading her folds incredibly wide.

It took a few minutes for the them to build up a rhythm, but after having her tunnel accommodating his rod, Lucy started to really put her hips into action. She held onto Najato’s shoulders for leverage and began bouncing up and down on his lap, sometimes grinding to create a variety of pleasures for them both to share. Her womb was occasionally assaulted when Najato’s blunt tip popped through her forcibly-stretched cervix, sending jolts through her that she could not help but announce with cries of pleasure that soon had the two other occupants of the room blinking awake and watching.

It was several minutes later when she happened to wipe her sweat soaked brow and look to the side that she noticed that Natsu and Happy were both looking at her as she fucked Najato. She felt humiliation and outrage as well as arousal though the outrage won out when she saw the motion of Natsu's hand as he lazily stroked his dick. She froze with Najato's cock fully buried inside, the pain-pleasure of it causing her to stumble over her words, “Wha- What are you doing!?”

The pink haired mage had the audacity to look slightly annoyed by her outburst but he didn't stop stroking as his eyes lingered on her shaking breast. Lucy felt a little thrill despite herself, a feeling similar to the way she'd particularly enjoyed giving Najato his Birthday Blowjob right in front of that Salamander imposter.

Beneath her Najato made a sound of confusion, clearly having been lost to the pleasure of being with her. He turned his head to look now and said, “Huh? Oh. Oh! Well, we can't really blame him, can we? We did just start doing it right in front of him.”

As usual, Najato made a lot of sense. If it was perfectly fine to have sex in full view of two sleeping people, could she really be justified in getting upset when they looked and even touched themselves because of how hot it was? From that point of view, Lucy realized it was actually a natural result of her undeniable sex appeal (Take that stupid shop keeper!) And honestly, it wasn't like she couldn't relate. Watching Aquarius suck off Najato yesterday, Lucy had only just managed not to touch herself it had been so arousing and that was to say nothing of when she'd gotten five ladies to blow him. A warm bubbling sensation built in her navel completely separate from the presence of his thick prick inside.

Lucy suddenly couldn't resist the alluring urge, her inhibitions vanquished by the pleasure she'd experienced so far.

She felt sexy and confident as she lifted herself off of Najato and quietly guided him into the new position she wanted to try...

Facing Natsu and Happy with Najato's huge prick slamming into her quivering cunt over and over again, Lucy had the most overwhelmingly powerful orgasm of her entire life and she was so lost to the pleasure that when her boyfriend started to groan and unleash load after load of hot cum directly into her womb, she didn't do anything but continue to hump him frantically as her orgasms kept coming.

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)