This Is Fucked

You sat on the floor, while Katherine was sitting on the couch and Sabrina was perched on the edge of the coffee table.

Sabrina had taken the towel from her hair and draped it over her naked chest. Katherine had pulled her panties up, and you’d pulled up your pants.

“I should have said something,” Katherine cut the silent tension. “I just- I should have said something when he hugged me good morning like that, but after last night I just thought we were comfortable like that, and then all of a sudden my panties were down and he was eating me, and God Sabrina he’s good at that, and my brain was like short-circuiting and I kept telling myself I needed to say something because obviously he thought I was you. And just as I was trying to figure out what to say he was sticking it in and fuck I think I almost came just from that.”

“No, I- I should have realized,” you said. “This isn’t your fault. Fuck, I practically sexually assaulted you. I didn’t ask, I just sort of did, because I know that’s what Sabrina likes, but I should-”

“OK, oh my God, both of you shut up,” Sabrina sighed heavily with an aggravated grunt. “Let me think.” She massaged her temple for a moment, breathing deeply, before opening her eyes. “OK. Sis, you weren’t trying to seduce him or anything, right?”

“No, you know I wouldn’t do that to you,” Katherine said.

“And John, you weren’t planning to try and have sex with my twin sister, right? No kinky fantasies or anything?”

“No. I thought she was you,” you said.

“Then it was an honest mistake,” Sabrina said. Then she scratched her chin for a moment and bit the inside of her cheek before glancing at her sister. “He is really good, right? Like freakishly good.”

Katherine chuckled nervously for a moment and then nodded, glancing over at you shyly. “Yeah. And the way he just sort of was taking what he wanted, but his soft touch? You’re lucky as fuck.”

Sabrina twisted her lips into a smirk. ‘You didn’t even get one orgasm, did you?” she asked.

Katherine rolled her eyes, blushing deeply. “No, I didn’t.”

“Hah!” Sabrina laughed. “You are so fucking horny right now! That’s so funny.”

“No, it’s not!” Katherine said, reaching over and shoving Sabrina’s arm.

“You can finish if you want,” Sabrina said.

“What?” you and Katherine both asked.

“You can finish,” Sabrina shrugged. “I mean, you already started. And you clearly find each other attractive considering Katherine and I are identical and you couldn’t bring yourself to stop it, Katherine. So you can finish if you want.”

Katherine looked over at you, her face showing as much shock as yours did, but with just a little bit of consideration. A small amount of ‘could that really happen?’

You swallowed. “Um, Sabrina,” you said. “Not that I wouldn’t, ah, love to, but…”

“Oh, fuck,” Sabrina sighed. “Yeah, we should probably ask her.”

“Ask who what?” Katherine asked.

“I don’t even know how to start explaining this,” you said.

“I’ll talk to her,” Sabrina said, reaching for her phone.

“No, we’ll talk to her,” you said. “I can’t just sit out, it’s my fault.”

“Who is ‘her’?” Katherine asked again.

“Gemma,” Sabrina told Katherine, and then turned back to you. “It’ll be fine. Trust me.”

“I do, but this isn’t just a sweep-under-the-rug kind of thing,” you said. “I don’t want to hurt her.”

“Who is Gemma?” Katherine asked.

“Gemma is his girlfriend,” Sabrina said loudly, answering her sister who got a very shocked look on her face. Sabrina grunted another sigh. “Or our girlfriend? It’s complicated and we’re still figuring it out. But we’re supposed to be exclusive between the three of us, so I guess it’s not just my call of whether you two can finish what you started or not.”

Katherine open her mouth, fishing for the words to express herself, and then just shook her head.

“It’s a whole thing,” you muttered and vaguely gestured, not sure how else to put it in the moment.

“Sabrina, what the actual fuck?” Katherine finally exhaled.

Gemma, after being flustered, started to giggle. That seemed to put the twins at ease, but you were worried it sounded a little manic.

“Gem, I’m so fucking sorry,” you said. “It was a horrible mistake, and I never wanted to ever make you feel like I would cheat on you.”

“Love, I-” she laughed again. “I don’t know how I feel, I’m just picturing the look on Sabrina’s face when she walked in on you.”

You were on speakerphone. Katherine had gone into the bedroom to give you and Sabrina some privacy for the call.

“Probably not as funny as John’s when he realized he had the wrong girl pinned against the glass window,” Sabrina smirked.

“She wasn’t pinned,” you mumbled as if that made a difference.

“OK, so it happened,” Gemma sighed from the other end of the call. “I- Thank you for calling to tell me right away, first of all. And second, the story is so fucking you two that I don’t even think I feel like it was cheating. Honestly, I feel like I should have seen this coming considering how fast the three of us have been moving. Of course John practically tripped and fell dick first into your identical twin sister.”

Sabrina smirked and laughed at that, reaching over to pat your knee. “He’s not convinced yet, babe,” Sabrina said to Gemma.

“John, I promise I’m not mad,” Gemma said. “And to prove it, I’m telling you to show Katherine a good time, OK? You got her engine started, you need to take her for a drive.”

“Really?” you asked. “Gem-”

“I love you, baby,” Gemma said. “This isn’t a test. I trust you. This phone call sucks in some ways, but makes me feel more secure in others because you’re not trying to hide anything or lie or make excuses for a weird situation. So go rock her world, and then come rock mine this afternoon to show me you love me.”

You sighed and nodded. “OK,” you said. “I do love you.”

“And I love you too,” Gemma said. “Sabrina, make sure he does his best.”

“Will do, babe,” she said, then hung up the call.

You took a long breath.

Sabrina looked at you with a smirk. “So, ready to fuck?” she asked.

Breakthebar erotica is powered by Patreon, where OFG chapters are now releasing 5+ chapters ahead. PM if interested in making a Commission.