Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 27 by Cross C Cross C

What happens next?

They begin the job.

(These next scenes gloss over the events in the anime and manga. So for more detail see Fairy Tail anime episode 6 or Fairy Tail manga chapter 11)

I found Lucy at the train station already waiting at our platform thirty minutes before it was scheduled to go. Gray was there too. I didn't know him too well. He sort of had a dickish air to him but that was probably because I saw him through the prism of Natsu's often vocalized hatred. In any event, he was fully clothed, so that was something. Guy could use my earrings if he was going to insist on going nude all the time.

My girl Lucy was wearing a cute little orange tank top that showed a nice amount of creamy cleavage, though a lot less than usual. I asked her about it as I sat down and she smiled and said, “I was totally unprepared for a trip and laundry wasn't done. All those mega deep cleavagy tops we got were wrinkled. It doesn't look bad, does it?” she suddenly looked distressed and I leaned over and kissed her and helped myself to a gentle caress of her breast.

Pulling back, I grinned, “You look so good that even after a night of having sex with four ladies including Mira, I still can't keep my hands off of you!”

Lucy was obviously pleased as she always loved having her sex appeal appreciated but after a second she caught up with everything I'd said and her mouth dropped open and her eyes flashed with intense interest, “Four?! Who?!”

We spent the next five minutes or so talking about last night's escapades. Gray who'd been standing off to one side got slowly closer while trying not to look like he was listening in with avid interest. Mira really did do a number on me because my cock didn't so much as twitch all throughout the retelling and even with the way my hands wandered wherever they pleased on my girlfriend's body. Eventually our conversation moved on.

“So... Sasha arrived last night.” commented Lucy.

I looked up from the big tit I currently had out of her top, “Oh yea... I'd completely forgotten about that. How is she?”

Lucy bit her lip at the sensation I was causing by pulling at her nipple so far that her boob was practically a cone, but eventually she replied, “She's fine... I guess. It was a bit uncomfortable. I've never dealt with indentures before but I got her started cleaning our place and laundry.”

“I'm sorry. So... it was weird?”

“I don't know. I think she was expecting you were going to be there..”

“Oh? What did she do?”

“Nothing interesting. Just asked about you and looked disappointed when I said you'd be out all night.”

Huh. I guess I'd really made an impression with that little bit of sexual activity I'd done with her. Honestly, once I'd cooled down I'd felt sort of bad about my little **** I'd inflicted on Kaby and I'd worked hard to put the whole incident out of my mind. Oh wait. I suddenly remembered that I'd used a Normal command back then, something about enjoying what was happening. Okaay, well it would make sense why Sasha would be looking forward to seeing me even if the situation wasn't the best. No double wait. I lightly pinched Lucy's nipple, “Wait. How'd you know I was going to be out all night?”

Lucy reached out and pinched my nipple through my shirt in gentle retaliation, “She had Warren let me know with his mind magic. She's so thoughtful!” Her face took on a grumpy cast, “Though she didn't say anything about a full fledged orgy!”

“Okay.” I nodded and moved my exploration south as Lucy helpfully spread her legs for me, “So did you have some fun with her?”

“Uhh... You know that didn't even occur to me. Plus... would that even work without you being there?”

“Why not? She's your indentured servant too, have at it!” I punctuated my statement by sliding her panties aside and plunging two fingers into her slit.

Lucy squirmed around my digits and whimpered slightly, “Ungh...ah! I don't think I could. Demanding sexual favors from an indenture is definitely wrong.”

My fingers froze inside of her even though there wasn't the slightest bit of reproach towards me in her voice, “What about when I demand sex from my indenture?”

Lucy rocked her hips forward to drive my fingers back into action as she responded lightly, “Well, that's different, of course. And I hardly think Sasha is going to complain about sleeping with you. In fact based on the way she was acting last night, I'm pretty sure that is exactly what she has in mind.”

I really was a bastard to so enjoy the way Lucy bent over backwards to excuse my behavior. Well, I deserved this and steeled myself for the disgusting images my next question conjured up, “Okay. Well, how about this then. What if I demand that my other indentured servant, Kaby, bend over for me?”

Lucy's cheeks reddened and a hand shot up to cover her mouth. After a second, her eyes briefly fell on Gray and I shuddered as I followed her thought process. Finally after carefully regaining her composure despite my lightly wiggling fingers inside of her she replied with disdain, “Well, it would be the least he could do after that crap he pulled, almost getting you killed! And then not even having the money to pay! I still can't believe he thought he'd get away with it!” She leaned in to me and her hand slid down to cup my crotch, as she spoke a little huskily, “I'm so glad you ignored Natsu and pressed for indenture.”

I enjoyed her soft teasing touch upon my flaccid tool for a moment silently. Her hand paused as she continued in a more normal tone, “Though I can't say I'm super excited about acquiring their book selling business. Sasha brought along their ledgers and let me tell you, they are not going to be paying us back any time soon and even selling their store isn't worth it and would be pretty mean anyway considering its their home too...”

I let Lucy's voice wash over me. The minutia of accounting and business practices was beyond me but I was happy to listen and nod appropriately. I was also relieved that Lucy had gotten sidetracked from sexy time because I knew my poor overused member was still unable to rise to the occasion. It wasn't all that long before Natsu and Happy showed up. The friendly blue cat joining us on the bench while his companion waited about two and a half minutes before getting into a shouting match with Gray.

And Erza arrived not much longer after that, the armored redhead pulling a literal mountain of luggage like it weighed nothing.


We were on the train and on our way.

Erza made me nervous. Really nervous. I mean, she just matter of factly punched Natsu so hard he passed out. That was normal for her. A friendly act. Sure, I could see how it was a solution to the fire mage's travel sickness but it made me wonder what other problems she'd see fit to “solve” for her companions. Would my earrings protect me from someone who seemed to have her own definition as to what was normal? I sure hoped so as I didn't think my body would take Erza's armored gauntlet at all well.

“Erza. I think its about time you started filling us in. I mean what kind of mission are we going on here?” asked Gray from his seat on the same bench as me but on the other side of Lucy. Erza and a passed out in her lap Natsu sat across from us. That was a really good question. I wish I'd thought to ask Mira about it at some point between all of the fucking last night.

Erza nodded and answered him, “Of course. We're going up against the dark guild Eisenwald. They are planning to use a magic called Lullaby for some fell intent, something big.”

At this point Gray and Lucy referenced the time they'd been attacked by some mage's outside of Shirotsume town after the Everlue job. This was a sore point for me because I hadn't been there. Thanks to the power of the earrings, Lucy and Natsu had been just fine with leaving me behind as I dealt with Kaby. Getting back on my own had been an adventure to say the least and I'd been pissed at Lucy before I finally realized it wasn't her fault.

A very pretty slender woman who was nonetheless very pregnant took a seat across the aisle from us and I found myself instantly enamored with her. I stared at the captivating shape of her baby bump through her sun dress and astonishingly I felt blood start to pump into my member. Several carnal fantasies flitted through my head and it was long minutes before I reallized I'd missed part of the conversation going on around me.

Gray was speaking, “So this thing is so bad it even scares dark mages?” Okay. That didn't sound good. What had Mira gotten us into? My hand slipped into Lucy's.

“I'm only hypothesizing mind you, but whoever you saw dragging off Happy's kidnappers that day must have been from Eisenwald. It's obvious they didn't want their plans getting out.” explained Erza, her face deadly serious. It was fine. It was fine. I had my earrings and my shield magic. Plus Erza freakin Scarlet, Titania herself was along. No problem at all. I was kind of feeling a lot of fear all of a sudden and by the way Lucy was squeezing my hand, she was in a similar boat. Though her voice was pretty calm as she asked, “What do you think they are going to try?”

Erza closed her eyes and rather than answer that question, chose to explain how she'd found this all out, that she'd overheard some mages talking about it in a tavern in Onibus and how one in particular was leaving to go break the seal around Lullaby.

Lucy spoke up, “Lullaby...that's like a song you sing k1ds to sleep...”

“Yes.” agreed Erza, “The fact that it has been sealed away means that it is most likely very powerful magic.”

“Uh...excuse me...uh Lady T-titania...” All of us turned our attention to a very nervous looking middle aged man with round glasses standing beside our booth, “Um..Could you... I mean...er- It's my birthday and I was- Uh- I mean if it wouldn't be too much trouble-ah!”

Erza's hand whipped out to seize the man's wrist and she jerked, pulling him down to eye level with her as she forcefully intoned, “Are you telling the truth? A ruse, you will surely regret, I swear to you.”

He was positively shaking in terror as he stared with wide eyes into Erza's. He barely managed to nod his head yes and she instantly relaxed, a small smile appearing on her face as she sat back, “Very well then. I will be glad to provide this service. However! I must warn you, this will be no long luxuriant pleasure as is deserved. I am on a mission of the utmost importance and I do not have the time to spare to such matters. I'll have your climax in less than two minutes, I assure you.”

His face fell at that and he gazed longingly at Erza's beauty for several moments, clearly conflicted before he finally said, “Oh....Uh...that's o-okay then. Thank you for your time, Lady Titania...”

“You are most welcome.” she replied courteously, “Perhaps next year you can come visit Fairy Tail on this special day and you'll experience the time you deserve with Erza Scarlet kneeling between your thighs.”

He mumbled something and stepped away.

Erza was once again all business, “Now then. Where were we? Questions?”

Gray asked, “Yea. Are you sure these guys you saw at the pub were even with Eisenwald?”

“Yes. I can't believe I was such a fool that day. I didn't recognize the name they mentioned then. Erigor. Erigor is Eisenwald's ace. He only accepts **** jobs for which he has earned the title, “Erigor the Reaper”

Lucy expressed my own trepidation perfectly, her voice quavering slightly with her fear, “He kills for money?!”

Erza continued, “The council outlawed **** requests but Eisenwald decided money was more important than the council's rules. As a result, it was kicked out of their guild league six years ago. However, they have refused to disband and remain active as a dark guild to this day.”

“Okay! I should be heading back now!” her voice high and I added my own agreement, “Yep! Hey Gray don't fight with Natsu! There! Mission complete! We'll see you guys when you get back! Good luck!”

Happy made an unkind comment about my girlfriend's perspiration but Erza kept talking like we hadn't said anything, hitting Natsu's temple with her fist as she grimaced, “How could I have been so careless! If I only I had recognized his name that day, I could have pulverized them! I could have **** them to reveal their scheme to me!”

It was at this point that I remembered my duty as a man and a boyfriend and I pushed aside my own fear to wrap my arms around Lucy and did my best to sooth her, promising her that I'd protect her, that that was my only goal in life-to keep her safe and that I had my special earrings to make sure I could do just that. I'm not sure how successful I was and I was vaguely aware of both Gray and Erza talking. I stopped my efforts just in time to hear Erza declare this with feeling:

“We're going to storm the Eisenwald guild!”

I felt my stomach drop, really worrying about my ability to deal with a really dangerous group of people led by a super deadly assassin. Could I really handle this? I was distracted from my self-doubt by the sounds of slurping. I looked to my right and saw the man from before getting a blow job from the pretty pregnant lady. He had his hands on her head and a ridiculous silly grin on his face as she sucked him, her cheeks going concave from the suction. The passengers around them were watching passively and I blinked to see her holding the hand of the handsome man sitting next to her.

Lucy had also noticed and giggled slightly clearly just as desirous to get her mind off of Erza's words as I, “That brings back memories, doesn't it Najato?”

Before I could reply, Erza interjected her eyes alive with interest, “Oh? Do tell?”

Lucy blushed and stammered under the full **** of Erza's attention, “I...I mean we... I was the one that gave Najato his birthday blowjob this year and uh... that's kind of how we got together...”

Now Erza's eyes moved like twin cannons to me and I felt more than saw them zero in upon my crotch with unerring accuracy, “Yes. Najato. Laki tells me you are quite the cocksman...”

I had no idea how to respond to that and I was suddenly very aware of how much of the night I'd spent fucking a woman with a body and face exactly like Erza's. Blood was flowing into my member and I felt the bulge in my pants grow larger and I could see her notice this as her eyebrows slowly rose. This was it. This was the moment Mirajane had prepared me for. Come on, Najato. Do your duty. Don't do it. Don't do it.

“Uh.... did you want to see it?” Damn it, Najato!

Erza smirked and shook her head. “Now is not the time for skinship.”

I sighed with relief. Crisis averted.

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)