The semi-solid blob of cum started to move.

“W-What the…!?” Leonard gasped, as the trash bag of his ejaculate began to undulate, moving in a way that reminded him of an earthworm. “I… what’s it doing…!?”

Jenny’s eyes widened, and she slowly opened a sidetable drawer before pulling out a handheld taser. “Y-You don’t fucking know…!?” she asked, as she checked the device’s charge level. Sadly, it wasn’t plugged in recently.

Cheryl was stunned, unable to speak as she fell to her knees. This must have been the wrong choice, as the trash bag’s movements were now directed towards her. Not very quickly, but still more than a pile of cum was supposed to.

Erica acted quick, dashing over and picking up the bag by its drawstrings. But interestingly, once she got near it the blob began to move towards her instead. Even held aloft, it started to swing back and forth, as if the weight inside was shifting on its own to propel itself through a midair path to eventually reach her. Eyes wide, she asked “Is it… attracted to whoever’s closest…?”

Lenny grabbed the bag from her, and stepped to a corner of the room far from the others. He set it down, still holding onto the bag itself. “… it’s still going towards you guys. Maybe… is it seeking out women…?”

“What, you think the cum’s still trying to do its job…?” Jenny asked, bewildered. But then her eyes widened in realization. “Holy shit, it’s trying to knock us up…! Cheryl’s coochie was near the floor when it went for her, so it woulda been closest!”

Leonard thought “That’s… feasible. B-But, how…!?” Then his mind went back to the events of that day’s morning, and the one before that. “The cauldrons…! When I recovered over my normal maximum for Life Points, I got a boosted sexual stamina…! Enough that I tired out Erica, Ann, and Cheryl…! That was from gaining 6000 points, so a 7500 boost added to the yesterday’s dregs would be…!”

“… it’s still alive. And still trying to be born.” he gulped. “J-Jenny…? D-Do you have, uh… any p-pregnancy tests…?”

She did not, which was relatively irresponsible of her though not inconsistent with her usual behavior. Luckily there was a local pharmacy about five minutes away that was open 24-hours. Erica ran over, being the fastest of the group, and came back with a box of multiple tests.

“Why have tests…? I-I’m on the pill, and these need a few weeks to be effective… it’s barely been a day since…” Cheryl pointed out, shakily.

Lenny sighed “Please just try it. It might be nothing, but I wanted to make sure.” After, the three women cycled in and out of the apartment’s bathroom to pee on their respective sticks.

Jenny went first, and ended up with a pair of lines that made her nod in recognition. “… you know, in hindsight it was gonna happen sooner or later. Ain’t got nobody to blame but myself.” she concluded, amazingly unbothered by this development.

Erica was next in the rotation, but she had just a single line on her test. “Wait, how does that work…? You’ve been having sex with me the longest.” she noted, raising a very good point.

That gave Cheryl hope, though those hopes would be dashed when her own result came up positive. “I… I have no idea how that can be, it makes no sense…!” she gasped, astonished as she began sweating.

Leonard held up another test, saying “… I-I’m gonna give this to Ms. Prift when I go into work tomorrow. Though, I have a feeling I know what’ll come up…” as the life started to leave his eyes.

“H-Hey, cheer up. I-I’ll be fine, you don’t gotta worry about me.” Jenny laughed uneasily. “My daughter can still visit if I’m pregnant, t-the courts won’t take my visitation rights if I’m the one gettin’ knocked up.”

Cheryl sighed “That’s not what’s worrying him you buffoon.” as she started massaging her brow from a developing migraine “I mean, I have always meant to have kids eventually. D-Didn’t exactly plan it to be now, but…”

Lenny stammered “I-I’m sorry, this is m-my fault, I…” before slumping over, his head in his hands. “… I d-dunno what to do…”

Cheryl stared at him, until sighing “Ann’s always been the one to talk about proposing, between the two of us. Always thought she was too clingy.” Sitting next to her apparent baby daddy on the bed, she continued “One of the relatively less important reasons we drifted apart after college was that I was bi whereas she was a lesbian. Occasions like the other night only happen when she thinks she can win me back, and most of the time she only has sex with a man if I encourage her to.”

Leonard squinted, asking “… what? W-Why are you telling me this?”

“It’s interesting, right? I always thought so. In any case, if I ask her to get back together then she’ll probably do it. That woman hangs off my every word, it’ll be a comfortable union for us.” she explained, before rubbing her midsection. “The both of us, I mean. The both of them too, I bet.”

Jenny scoffed “Oh, like gettin’ hitched outta wedlock’s a healthy decision? Sheryl and I thought we were rock fucking solid, but then Hannah ballooned her gut out so I had to get a job…” before backtracking, as she caught on to what Cheryl was trying to do. “… but I loved that girl the moment she popped out. We both did. Not a day goes by I wish I didn’t fuck it up… I’m sure this one’ll go good.”

“… really, her name’s also ‘Cheryl’?”

“I mean, it’s ‘Sheryl’ with an ‘S’ on the front.”

“Ah, I see. I’m ‘Cheryl’ with a ‘C’.”

“That’ll be easier on my contact list. We should probably make a group chat, right? Call it ‘Lenny’s Baby Mamas’?” Jenny suggested, picking up her phone from a charging dock that had miraculously missed the earlier cumshots.

Erica muttered “I mean, I’m not technically a baby mama right now, but sure…?” before whispering “Again, how’d that happen? The others had a lot less sex than us, but I’m the only one not preggers…?” to Leonard.

He nodded, whispering back “Servants are basically infertile, unless they’re incarnated. That’s when they have a physical body beyond their spiritual presence. But you’re definitely the equivalent to that, so…” with a hand on his chin. “Maybe it’s succubus rules?”

“Succubus rules?”

While Cheryl and Jenny shared contact info, he explained “Succubi consume semen for energy, even when they’re creampied. Since we’re doing Mana Transfers, maybe your body’s taking all its reproductive abilities along with the Mana?” Nearby, the cluster of ball-juice inched out of the corner it was left in, making uncomfortable sloshing noises as it made the most minuscule of movements. “Oh, that reminds me. I thought about it, and I think those old man cauldrons made me extra-virile by way of pumping-up my sperm. And that also translated to, uh… my cum doing that if there’s enough of it in one spot.”

She blinked. “Well, I can’t say it doesn’t make sense. Still kind of convoluted…” she muttered. “But, guess I already figured overusing those things would’ve had its consequences. Didn’t expect this though.”