The mystery girl is Mearna

As we are standing there, I notice the environment around us become easier to see. I look up and notice that the big cloud in front of the moon is moving away, allowing it’s rays to illuminate us. I look back over to Kaileigh, expecting to see her in all her natural glory. Instead, it is someone else I see.

This girl in front of me. The girl I just gave my necklace to. The one I fucked and pumped full of my seed. It was not my beautiful big breasted Kaileigh at all. It was Mearna, possibly the ugliest girl in the whole village, instead.

When I realize I fucked the wrong girl, my eyes go wide and mouth falls open from shock. I gasp and say, “Mearna?!”

With her cover now blown, all Mearna does is say, “Sorry.” And then she runs away, disappearing into the forest. I am too shocked to go after her. Besides, it wouldn’t matter if I did catch her. My seed is inside her now, and there is no way for me to get it out. I fucked up.

I feel a bit dizzy and find myself a big flat rock to sit on. Then I start thinking how it could all go so wrong. How come Mearna found me but not Kaileigh? I gave Kaileigh pretty clear instructions, right? I would follow the path, cross the river, and on her side of the bridge, go left. All she had to do was follow the same road. So where is she?

When Mearna showed up, I asked her if she was Kaileigh. She said she was. Why would she lie like that? Probably because nobody would want to have sex with her if she was honest. And I was this year’s fool who fell for it. Fuck!

What now? Mearna gets pregnant with my Samhain child? She has my necklace, so she has evidence that the guy who planted his seed in her was me. And then I will have to marry the ugly girl, while giving up on the woman I am in love with. Fuck, fuck, fuck, this is the worst day of my life.

As I am contemplating my possible future with Mearna, another cloud moves in front of the moon. Almost as if mocking me and letting me know my future is dark and bleak.

Another person then starts approaching me. Carefully, as if they are scared. Then I hear them ask, “Zayden? Is that you?”. This time, I notice the voice is clearly Kaileigh’s. She’s the real one.

“You’re too late.” I say. I add a dramatic pause before I continue, but Kaileigh takes it as me having finished talking and replies.

“What do you mean, too late? Yeah, I took a while. I got my leg stuck in a trap. It was so frustrating trying to get myself out of there. But I’m here now.”

The moon slowly breaks through the clouds again, shining enough light to reveal Kaileigh’s body.

Gods, she looks so beautiful. Such a pretty face, long hair, all the right curves. The exact opposite of Mearna.

I lower my head in shame and say, “Another girl got here first.” Then I leave another dramatic pause.

“What?” Kaileigh asks.

“It was so dark. I couldn’t see who she was. She pretended to be you.”

Kaileigh is quiet for a while. Taking in the meaning of what I just said. Eventually she asks, “Who was it?”

I take the black necklace Mearna gave me and hand it to Kaileigh. She takes a look at it and then says, “Mearna?” She then looks at me astonished and asks, “You fucked waxface?”

“I thought it was you.”

Kaileigh is silent again, probably going through several different thoughts in her brain. Until eventually she asks, “You didn’t leave your seed inside her, did you?”

I find it incredibly hard to simply say, “Yes, I did.” Simply the idea that now my seed is trying to make a baby inside her is filling me with so much despair that it is making me all teary eyed. I lower my head and start wiping the tears out of my eyes, planning to tell her after, but Kaileigh seems to understand already.

“That bitch!” She yells while also stomping her right foot on the ground.

“I’m sorry, Kaileigh.” I apologize. I can understand Kaileigh is angry at me. It must feel to her like I betrayed her. “I’m so sorry. If I knew, I would have kept away from her.”

Kaileigh kneels down to me and places my her on my back. “It’s alright, Zayden. I don’t blame you. I know you wouldn’t do this. It’s all Mearna’s fault.”

“B-but … what if she gets p-pregnant.” I murmur.

“You shouldn’t worry too much about that.” She tells me. “Mearna has tried to get herself fertilized like, every Samhain, and she has never succeeded. I wouldn’t be surprised if she is barren. Now, how about we go back home, get some rest, and we talk about this again tomorrow.”

Kaileigh then gives me Mearna’s necklace back. Yeah, I should hold on to that. But I don’t really feel like putting it on again. I will just hold it in my hand. After that, Kaileigh and I walk back to our village, taking the bridge I can use so we can stay together. When I have confirmation that I didn’t get Mearna pregnant, I am going to ask Kaileigh to marry me. I don’t want to go through another Samhain like this. I don’t need a Samhain child. I just want to be with her.