Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Steven657 Steven657

Where will you head tonight?

The bar

After spending hours exploring Madison's body and resting, you finally rise from the bed as evening settles over campus. Your reflection in the mirror—her reflection—catches you off guard again. Blonde hair tousled from your earlier activities, cheeks still flushed with lingering pleasure.

You rummage through Madison's meticulously organized closet, pushing past modest sundresses and conservative blouses. In the back, you discover a small section that seems out of character—clothes with tags still attached that she apparently purchased but never had the courage to wear.

"Perfect," you murmur, pulling out a cropped black top with a plunging neckline. Paired with her tightest jeans, the outfit will showcase every curve of this borrowed body.

You slip into the ensemble, marveling at how the fabric stretches across Madison's generous chest. The top leaves a strip of midriff exposed, and the jeans hug her ass in a way that makes you turn for a better view in the mirror. You find a pair of hoop earrings and apply makeup from her collection with inexpert but enthusiastic hands—darker eyeshadow, mascara, and ruby-red lipstick that transforms her wholesome appearance into something decidedly more provocative.

"Sorry, church girl," you say to your reflection, "but we're going to have some fun tonight."

You grab Madison's phone, ID, and a small purse, then head out into the cool night air. The campus feels different after dark—shadowy couples tucked into corners, music thumping from distant dorms. You pull up a ride-sharing app and order a car to The Rusty Nail, a dive bar on the edge of campus known for its lax ID checking and cheap drinks.

The driver gives you a curious once-over as you slide into the backseat. "Prescott Hall to The Rusty Nail?" he confirms, eyebrows raised slightly. "Don't see many Prescott girls heading there."

"Trying something new tonight," you reply, still startled by Madison's voice emerging from your lips.

The Rusty Nail lives up to its reputation—dim lighting, sticky floors, and a clientele composed of townies and the edgier segment of Westlake's student population. Heads turn as you enter, Madison's stunning figure drawing immediate attention in an outfit her consciousness would never have chosen.

You approach the bar, sliding onto a stool with practiced confidence that feels foreign in this body. The bartender, a woman with sleeve tattoos and a nose ring, gives you an appraising look.

"What'll it be?" she asks, leaning forward.

"Tequila shot," you order, "and a beer."

A guy two stools down shifts closer. Early twenties, stubbled jaw, dark eyes that don't hide their interest. "Never seen you in here before," he says. "I'm Derek."

"Madison," you reply, accepting the shot glass from the bartender and downing it with a practiced motion. The tequila burns unfamiliarly in Madison's throat, making her eyes water slightly.

"Madison, huh?" Derek leans closer, his cologne mingling with the bar's stale beer smell. "You don't strike me as the Rusty Nail type."

You take a sip of beer and give him your best attempt at a flirtatious smile with Madison's full lips. "Maybe there's a lot about me you don't know." Your eyes scan the dimly lit room, taking inventory of potential hookups.

In a corner booth, a blonde in a tight pink top catches your eye as your gazes meet. You sense a strange wanting. Across the bar, someone who looks oddly familiar catches your attention—a petite woman with olive skin and striking features who seems to be watching you with unusual intensity.

"I'd like to find out," Derek responds, interrupting your survey. He leans forward, lowering his voice. "But first, can I be honest with you?"

Something in his tone shifts, becoming less predatory and more conspiratorial. "Look, I know what's happening here." He gestures vaguely at you. "You're not Madison. I mean, that's her body, but you're someone else, right?"

Your eyes snap back to him, Madison's heart rate accelerating in her chest. "What the fuck are you talking about?"

"Relax," Derek says, glancing around before continuing. "I'm not Madison either. Name's Emma, actually." He—or apparently she—extends a hand. "I'm a hopper. Natural ability, been doing it since puberty. Currently borrowing Derek for the night."

"How did you—"

"Know?" Emma-as-Derek smirks. "Body language. The real Madison Taylor sits like she's balancing a Bible on her head and crosses her arms over those tits like she's ashamed of them. You walk in wearing clothes she bought but never had the guts to wear, throwing back tequila shots? Dead giveaway."

You hesitate, then decide honesty might be the best approach. "Swap class. I'm in for the semester."

"Bold move," Emma nods appreciatively. "Swap class is usually just weekend swaps or monitored sessions. How'd you score a whole semester?"

Before you can answer, someone stumbles against your barstool—a girl with long dark hair and striking features who's clearly had too many drinks. She steadies herself on your shoulder, then does a double-take.

"Madison? What the fuck?" She stares at your outfit, then laughs, the sound distinctly masculine despite coming from her delicate frame. "Holy shit, I almost didn't recognize you! It's me—Trevor! From Swap class!"

"Trevor?" you echo, recognizing the name of another classmate.

"Yeah, I got Gianna for the semester," he explains, gesturing down at the Italian exchange student's petite frame he now inhabits. "Kinda lucked out, huh? Not as much as you though," he adds, eyes lingering on Madison's chest. "Man, when the real Madison saw who she got stuck with, she looked like she was gonna pass out!"

Emma-as-Derek watches this exchange with growing interest. "Sounds like Westlake's swap program is getting more... creative this semester."

"You have no idea," Trevor-as-Gianna slurs, wobbling slightly. "I've spent all day trying out her body. These things are fucking wild," he cups Gianna's small breasts through her top, clearly drunk and inappropriate. "Different wiring down there too, if you know what I mean."

Who do you fuck?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)