The aftermath of Joey being the father

{if gamemode=true}Joey just shakes his head in confusion as you tell him he got your wife pregnant. “That can’t be,” he says. “I came in her while standing up. You can’t get pregnant standing up. You must be the father.”

“Of course you can,” you tell him trying to be polite about his ignorance.

“No you really can’t. The sperm just falls out. They can’t swim upward against gravity. They aren’t that strong,” Joey tries to convince you.

“Well maybe you have super swimmers,” you say as you get frustrated with his ignorance. He keeps arguing and insisting he can’t be the father. Eventually you just give up. It’s not so much his ignorance but his insistence that he is right that really gets to you.

Once the baby is born, a girl, you make Joey take a DNA to prove he is the father. He was so confidant that he was not going to be it, but when it comes back showing he is, he just shrugs and says “I guess I got another kid. I don’t know how, but I guess I do.”

Joey ends up coming over you house almost every day to spend time with his daughter. He is actually a pretty good dad and does a lot to help take care of her, especially considering he has a couple other kids he takes good care of too.

One day your wife, Veronica, asks if you would be interested in spicing up your sex life. You had noticed it getting a bit dull lately so you quickly agree and asks what she has in mind. “Well...” she says a bit hesitantly. “I’ve always had this one fantasy...” She seems a bit **** to say.

“Go ahead, whatever you want, I will happily do it,” you assure her.

“Well I have always wanted to try a threesome,” she tells you as her face goes red with embarrassment.

“Oh hell yeah!” you almost yell. “Why didn’t you tell me earlier. I always wanted to try that. Did you have anyone in mind?” She nods. “It’s that sexy blonde girl you work with isn’t it?” You start to get hard just at the thought.

“Actually it’s Joey,” she says.

Your excitement quickly fades and your dick deflates. “You mean a threesome with two guys?” you say in disgust.

“Yes of course. You said you would do a threesome with me.”

“I did say that,” as you think that is not what you thought she was talking about. “But with Joey?”

“Yes, just look at how good of a dad he is. That’s so sexy. Not to mention his body is quite nice and the thickness of that di...”

“Ok, ok,” you say cutting her off. You try to block out the memory of that night but the image of Joey’s thick dick fucking Veronica keeps coming back into your mind. “I guess we can try it.”

Joey jumps at the opportunity when you tell him and within minutes the baby is put down for a nap and the three of you are in the bedroom. You thought this was supposed to be a threesome, but the way Veronica and Joey are all over each other, you feel more like a voyeur. They peel off each other clothes as they make out.

After what seems like forever, Veronica finally motions you over to join them. She tells you to strip down and then eat her out. As you eat her out you can see her giving Joey a blowjob out of the corner of your eye. His soft dick was already pretty massive but it doesn’t get too much bigger as your wife gets him hard. Once hard, he has a pretty normal length dick, but it is very girthy. You get really hard watching your wife service another man. You never thought you would but this is actually turning you on.

After getting your wife good and ready you climb on top of her but she quickly stops you. “Joey should go first as he is our guest, don’t you think?” Veronica tells you. You begrudgingly agree.

As Joey starts to mount your wife you hand him a condom. You don’t want a repeat of last time.

“Nah man. I figured three kids is enough for me. I recently took care of it so now I am infertile and can’t have anymore kids. See,” he says pointing to his pair of tighty whities on the floor.

You put two and two together and realize what is is talking about. “You mean a vasectomy?”, you ask as you know you must wear supportive underwear afterwards.

“Is that what it’s called? Yup. I can’t have any more kids now,” Joey says.

“Well good for you for being responsible. Go for it then. Give her a nice big creampie,” you say as you watch him attempt to penetrate your wife. His dick is so wide that at first his head doesn’t want to go in, but with some pushing it gradually opens your wife up as she accepts his manhood.

You are surprised at how much you enjoy watching Joey fuck your wife. He gives her a good hard pounding and eventually with a loud grunt blows his load deep inside of your wife.

As soon as he gets off your wife, you are there to take his place. His wide cock has stretched her pussy and you have no trouble entering. It is warmer and wetter than you have ever felt and you actually love the looseness. You are so aroused from watching them that if it were any tighter you would have blown immediately. You slowly fuck your wife as Joey watches you, cheering you on. You look down and you can see Joey’s cum coating your dick which you are shocked to find arouses you. It doesn’t take long for you to add your cum and mix it with Joey’s.

“We have to do that again, soon,” says Joey and Veronica quickly agrees.

“Yeah,” you add, surprised at how much you actually enjoyed that. You thought this was going to be a one time thing but now you are actually craving more.

Over the next several months, these threesomes become very regular and it is not long until Veronica comes up pregnant again. This time you are sure it is yours as Joey has had a vasectomy. You are glad to have finally sired a child. This one ends up being another girl, and you want to keep trying for a boy.

Another child does not slow down your threesomes and Veronica soon gets pregnant again. This time she does indeed give birth to a boy, and Veronica ends up getting her tubes tied while in the hospital as you guys are done with children. But as the days pass there is something off. He just doesn’t really look much like you. He really looks like Joey, but that can’t be because he has had a vasectomy.

On a whim you get a home DNA test and you are devastated when it comes back that you are not his father. You confront Joey but he insists it can’t be his, but you still make him take one anyways. Somehow it comes back that Joey is the father.

You confront Joey and say, “when you had your vasectomy, did the doctor do a follow up test to ensure you were completely infertile.”

“What doctor?” Joey answers you back stupidly.

“The doctor who did your vasectomy,” you say starting to get frustrated.

“Oh I didn’t need to go to a doctor, I did it all on my own,” Joey proudly says.

“What? You did surgery on yourself?” you say as you start to wonder what stupid thing he has done now.

“No surgery. I just switched to briefs. They lower your sperm count so you can’t have children. That’s what a vasectomy is,” Joey said with confidence like he was the smartest person in the world.

“Jesus Christ you are so god damn stupid Joey,” you say holding your face in the palm of your hand. “That is not what a vasectomy is. Just switching to briefs doesn’t make you infertile. You know I wear briefs and I fathered a child, how do you think that happened?”

“I don’t know. I thought maybe you stopped wearing them for a day or something?” Joey says in genuine ignorance.

“Stopped wearing them FOR A DAY?,” you shout in exasperation. “You are so stu...” you start to say as you stop in mid sentence as a thought just occurred to you. You rush out of the house to get another DNA test.

The wait is agonizing and you can’t believe it when the test comes back showing Joey is the father of all three of Veronica’s kids. You break down and cry. You had thought you had two kids, but turns out you had none. Joey’s sperm beat yours every single time. And Veronica’s tubes have been tied so you will never get to father any. You cry as you think back about your decisions and what your life could have been like if it weren’t for that one fateful day.{else}Game Mode must be enabled to play. Turn it on in the menu. You can also give custom names to the characters in there.{endif}