The Wish works (sort of)

Tom opened his eyes and his heart sank. She still had a dick.

"Mmmmm Tom. I'm so wet!" Sarah crooned, her nipples standing out firmly.

His brain was slowly starting back into gear. Wait. Wet? What was wet?

He maneuvered himself around, a little closer to her so as to be able to see her crotch. She noticed, smiling seductively, and spread her legs.

Tom froze as he saw it. She was both. She had a penis and a vagina. She was a hermaphrodite.

What should he do?