The Peerage is all for it! Though Issei does still have one reservation.

"...so, we have ourselves a guilt free punching bag?" Akeno asked, her eyes sparkling. Issei and Rias had just explained the situation to the Peerage. "One we can heal and fry all over again?" she asked, looking at Asia.

"I'm not going to help you to **** her!" Asia huffed. "Punishment is one thing, outright cruelty is another entirely!"

"Meh, that's fine, we'll just have to be careful not to break her too badly," Koneko shrugged.

"...I'm all for punishing Raynare, and screwing with her, but I'm with Asia," Issei scratched the back of his head.

"Seriously? She already killed you once!" Kiba noted, and Issei shrugged.

"Yeah, I'm still a little resentful over that, but it did turn out pretty well," Issei stated. "And who knows? Maybe there's something redeemable in her. That's not to say I'm letting her off the hook, but let's not go too far in outright torturing her, yeah? Spar with her, yes. Screw with her by making her do some useful, maybe even a few mildly demeaning things, go for it. But I am against cruelty for the sake of it."

"...given that Asia and Issei are the ones she wronged most, they should have the most say in the matter," Rias finally decided. "...and this way, you might actually get to seduce her into your harem, if she has a good enough side to her for you to work with," she noted, and Issei nodded.

"...she did say she was developing some genuine feelings for me," Issei admitted. "Whether she said that just to twist the knife more, or meant it, I am unsure. But we'll just have to see."

Before the conversation could continue, Raynare stormed inside, grumbling as she carried her bag at her side. "I got your stupid colas! You assholes want fries with that?"

...yeah, if she had a good side, she hid it, very, very well. Still, Issei did have the benefit of the insight Rias granted him. So he turned that gaze upon Raynare to see what there was to see.