Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by ManRayMansker ManRayMansker

What's next?

The New Normal

The next Saturday, Jordan and Lily got ready for their first threesome. They lit candles, put on some soft jazz music, and Lily put on a lacy pink bra and panty set that showed off her pert breasts and tiny waist.

When Manuel arrived, Jordan was taken aback. The tall, dark and handsome Latino man towered over him at 6'2". And the huge bulge barely constrained by his jeans made Jordan's mouth go dry.

"Hey man," Manuel greeted him with a firm handshake before pulling Lily in for a passionate kiss. Jordan felt his stomach twist with anxious jealousy.

They made their way to the bedroom, where Manuel began undressing Lily slowly, kissing and caressing every inch of her soft skin as it was revealed. Jordan sat on the edge of the bed, trying to will his little cock to stiffen in his briefs. But he remained flaccid and tiny, only 1.75 inches long and 2 inches around.

Manuel pushed Lily onto her back and spread her legs, revealing her wet pink folds. "Damn, you're so fucking sexy," he growled before burying his face between her thighs.

Lily moaned and arched her back as Manuel ate her out masterfully, his skilled tongue and lips driving her wild. Jordan watched, transfixed, as Manuel made his girlfriend writhe and cry out in pleasure like Jordan never could.

When Manuel brought Lily to a powerful orgasm, he sat up and began unzipping his jeans. "Get ready baby, I'm gonna wreck this tight little pussy," he said with a smirk.

Jordan's eyes nearly bugged out of his head as Manuel pulled out his massive cock. It was huge and thick.

Manuel pushed into Lily's soaked entrance and she squealed as he stretched her out immensely. "Oh fuck, you're so big!" she cried out. Jordan winced at that.

Manuel started pumping his hips, fucking into Lily hard and fast. The sounds of skin slapping against skin and Lily's moans filled the room. "Ungh yeah, your pussy feels so good wrapped around my big cock," Manuel grunted.

Jordan shifted uncomfortably, his little penis still completely soft. He watched mesmerized as Manuel pounded Lily into the mattress, his huge cock splitting her open and his heavy balls smacking against her ass with each thrust.

Lily was in ecstasy, tossed around like a ragdoll by Manuel's powerful thrusts. "Yes, yes, fuck me harder! Ruin my little cunt!" she screamed.

Manuel hammered into her wildly, grunting and cursing. "Take it slut, take my big fucking cock! Milk it with this hungry pussy!"

Jordan felt his stomach churn watching the depraved scene. But to his shock, he felt the first stirrings of arousal and his little dick twitch and start to stiffen. Manuel's rough domination of Lily was turning him on.

With a roar, Manuel slammed deep inside Lily and exploded, flooding her womb with his thick seed. Lily wailed as she came hard on his spurting cock.

Manuel pulled out and a river of cum poured out of Lily's abused hole. She looked utterly wrecked and satisfied. Jordan's cock was now fully hard, though still only 3 inches long and 3 inches around.

"Damn, that was hot," Manuel said with a smirk. "You're a great lay, Lily. I've never cum that hard."

Lily giggled. "Mmm you filled me up so good. My little pussy is ruined for Jordan's tiny dick now."

Jordan felt a stab of pain at her words, but he couldn't deny how insanely sexy the entire experience was. Seeing Lily get her brains fucked out by a real man.

"Remember, you're my cuckold now," Lily purred, turning to Jordan. "Your only job is to clean up my creampie with your tongue and make me cum again. Maybe if you're good, I'll let you put your little pee-pee in me after."

Jordan swallowed hard and nodded, his destiny as Lily and Manuel's cuckold sealed. He got on his knees between Lily's thighs and started lapping up the huge load pouring out of her. Manuel laughed and gave his balls a smack in Jordan's face as he lapped away obediently.

And so their new dynamic began, with Manuel using Lily's prime pussy several times a week and Jordan serving as her oral clean-up crew

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)