Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 174 by sexybjgal69 sexybjgal69

What's next?

Thanksgiving Break: Tommy Cums inside Leah's Ass

Tommy was going to explode soon. Maybe it was the deep conscience of being raised right by his parents that made him pull his cock out of Leah's welcoming cunt, maybe it was more fear. Fear that he might impregnate Leah and that it could come back to haunt him. Oh how he wished he could have simply given in and finished deep inside her wet pussy.

But...there was another hole...

She can't get pregnant this way. He thought to himself as he pulled his cock out slowly from Leah's wet slit. He opened her ass cheeks to help him find his goal. He felt in the darkness with his finger, then he slipped his cock's head to Leah's tight asshole. He knew it was risky if he violated her asshole she might wake up. Tommy was too close to the edge to care. His cock was already lubed up with Leah's juices and he eagerly put his cock's head to her tight hole--then he slowly pushed forward. Leah's asshole parted slowly as Tommy's cock began to go deeper inside Leah.

"Guuughhhuugh" Leah let out a groan and put her hand back on Tommy's body "muuhy ASS Jon...a..thann....!" her voice trailed off as the momentary protest was just that--momentary.

Tommy thought he might go soft from her reaction--if she had woken up...who knew what kind of a disaster and scandal all this would be. He soon found himself pumping slowly inside of her ass. He continued his measured thrusts of pleasure until his thrust turned into shaking and quivering with ecstasy. He grabbed Leah's hips as he thrust hard for a few jabs deeper inside Leah's tight ass.

"Ruuuuuuuuururughhhhhhhh" he groaned trying to be silent as he filled Leah's ass with his seed. He hoped this didn't wake her--but she hadn't felt any alertness before. She was so incredibly tight he laid there for a moment quivering with pleasure. His wife never let him try anal but a few times when she was drunk. And that was 20 years ago.

Tommy was quickly loosing his stiffness. He was older after all. He withdrew his cock by shuffling his hips backward ever so slightly.

Please log in to view the image

He didn't want to wake her. He moved his body slowly away from her. A torrent of cum began to flow from Leah's asshole. He hadn't exploded like that in a long time--and in a hot piece of ass like that...not in ages. The entire encounter made him extra giddy. He saw his cum trickling down Leah's soft skin as he put his boxers back on.

Oh how he had dreamed of doing this to his daughter-in-law ever since he saw her picture on Jonathan's Facebook. Seeing her in person he had imagined something just like this occurring.

He crept back down the hallway away from Leah's cum covered body.

In the morning when Leah finally came to she had a pounding headache. Her mouth was dry and she groped for a bottle of water she normally kept at her bedside. She swallowed it all in a few gulps. Her vision came back to her. She had left her contacts in like an idiot. At least it was just one night. She would be okay. She looked around the room and it seemed rather chaotic. Her bra was on the floor not far from the bed.

Her shirt was disheveled, her panties felt awkward. Then she felt a strange crusty sensation between her thighs. She glided her hand across her privates and explored around her ass and felt a crusty peeling sensation like when one has too much sun at the beach...or when cum dries in place. If that wasn't any indication her ass itself hurt.

Jesus. Leah thought to herself Jonathan and I must have had sex? Fuck I was drunk I don't remember any of it. AND he stuck it in my ass. UGH! she shook her head as she moved toward the bathroom to take a hasty shower and a few pain pills for her head. When she had finished cleaning up and headed down stairs she was shocked to see Jonathan still passed out on the couch. Why would he have gone to sleep back on the couch? Maybe she kicked him out of bed for sticking it in her ass. She spent the morning pretending to not be hung over with Tammy and Ashley in the kitchen.

"Did y'all stay up late?" Tammy asked.

"They must have. Luke came in my room at like two or three in the morning." Ashley said with a groan of sleepiness.

"Yeah we stayed up pretty late." Leah nodded.

"Well it is the holiday I suppose." Tammy said before dropping another piece of bacon on Leah's plate. Jonathan began to finally stir as the morning sunlight turned to near mid day and he came to some level of alertness.

Leah followed him upstairs as she began to pack her bag and he made to shower.

"I really can't believe you last night." Leah said as Jonathan emerged from the shower looking almost human now after his post drunken sleep.

"What?" he said shrugging as he grabbed his toothbrush.

"I can't believe we had sex. It was such a mess too, you came a lot. In my ass too." she said as she put the final clothes in her suitcase.

"WhAHT!?" he said as he brushed his teeth.

"Yeah we had sex and you stuck it in my ass." she gave him a sideways grin.

"Damn..." he spit "I don't remember that at all." Leah didn't remember either...and she was thinking about it harder now...why would he have gone back down stairs fully clothed to sleep on the couch...

"Ha ha...yeah I don't either...we umm were very drunk." she said her voice almost quivering.

"Yeah jeeze that is Spirits and Spades. I just don't remember at all. Last thing I recall was falling asleep on the couch." he said before slowly finishing up his dental care.

Leah's mind was soon filled with horror...If it wasn't Jonathan who came inside her...then...who? Leah wanted to throw up at the realization.

"Well I certainly hope we enjoyed it ha ha?" he laughed as she flossed.

"Yeah...I...I'm sure we had a great time..."

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)