Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 8 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

Terms of Purchase

Madame Ruth felt them before the bell rang.

It was a faint tug in the air, like a thread tightening between shelves of glass and memory. She paused mid-polish, holding a cloudy crystal orb in one hand and a soft cloth in the other. The shop smelled faintly of sandalwood and citrus peel, the way it always did when a potion had settled into its first rewrite.

She smiled.

"Ah," she murmured to the empty room. "He's back already."

The bell chimed.

She didn't look up immediately. Timing mattered with customers. Especially the angry ones. She finished one slow circle across the orb, set it carefully back onto its velvet stand, and then turned.

The skinny boy she had sold a dose of Love Potion Number 10 to stood in the doorway, pale and tight-jawed. Next to him stood a gorgeous blonde woman, a little older than him, arms crossed, posture radiating hostility so vividly it practically hummed.

Please log in to view the image

Madame Ruth beamed.

"Well, well," she said, leaning her elbows onto the counter. "If it isn't the happy couple."

The blonde's eyes narrowed instantly.

"We are not..." she started.

"Oh, everyone says that when they come back," Madame Ruth said cheerfully, waving a dismissive hand. "Everyone complains about their purchase. Every single time. You would think I sold umbrellas that only worked on sunny days."

Evan stepped forward, voice strained. "Look, I don't think you understand. She drank it by accident. She's my stepmother. It was meant for someone else. We don't even like each other!"

Madame Ruth tilted her head thoughtfully.

"She doesn't look like your stepmother to me," she said gently. "I'm pretty sure she's your wife."

The blonde made a sharp, disbelieving noise in the back of her throat.

"You need to fix this," she snapped. "Right now."

Madame Ruth chuckled, low and warm, like she'd just heard a particularly creative joke.

"Oh, darling," she said, "it doesn't work like that."

The boy gripped the edge of the counter. "You said it was permanent."

"It is permanent," she agreed pleasantly.

"And unpredictable."

"Very."

He swallowed hard. "Then... then what happens now? What are we supposed to do?"

Madame Ruths gold-capped tooth flashed as she smiled wider.

"Oh, it obviously hasn't finished its work yet."

Both of them stared at her.

"The best is still ahead of you," she added, delighted.

"What does that mean?" the boy asked, his voice cracking slightly.

She laughed outright this time, a bright, musical sound that echoed faintly through the shelves of jars and bottles.

"I have absolutely no idea," she said.

The blonde stared at her like she might lunge across the counter.

"The potion does what the potion does," Madame Ruth continued, shrugging lightly. "It has its own sense of balance. Narrative. Justice, sometimes. Humor, often. You'd be amazed how poetic it can get."

"That is not helpful," The blonde said, her voice sharpening to a blade.

Madame Ruth leaned forward slightly, studying them both. Up close, the woman was striking. Symmetrical in that deliberate, curated way. She moved like someone accustomed to being watched, admired, evaluated. There was calculation in her posture, even in her anger.

Beautiful, Madame Ruth thought.

And exhausting.

She shifted her gaze to the boy. Pale. Frightened. Earnest in a way that made him look younger than he was. There was kindness there. And confusion. A softness that would probably bruise easily.

Interesting pairing.

Unlikely ones often worked best. Balance came from friction as much as harmony. She wondered, briefly, if a woman like her might be exactly what the boy needed. Someone sharp enough to **** him into a shape he hadn't grown into yet.

She also suspected the next stretch of his life was going to be deeply unpleasant.

Growth usually was.

"You should listen carefully," Madame Ruth said, her tone softening just slightly. "The worst thing you can do is fight it."

The blonde woman barked a short, incredulous laugh. "Fight it? I am absolutely fighting it."

"Oh, you can try," Madame Ruth said pleasantly. "Most people do, at least at first. But the potion pushes back. The harder you resist, the harder it works. And it always wins."

"That's insane," she snapped.

"It's magic," Madame Ruth corrected.

The boy dragged both hands through his hair. "There has to be something. A counter-potion. A reversal. A... a refund?"

"Sweet boy," Madame Ruth said, almost kindly, "you purchased transformation, not a warranty."

Stacy slammed her palm onto the counter hard enough to rattle a cluster of small glass vials.

"This is your fault, you bitch," she said, leaning forward, her voice trembling with fury. "You gave him whatever it was that he **** me. Without my consent! You stole my life. You are going to fix it or I swear..."

She didn't finish the threat.

Madame Ruth sighed.

"So dramatic," she said.

She reached beneath the counter, pinched a small mound of sparkling powder between her fingers, and flicked it toward them.

The air flashed.


Evan and Stacy stumbled forward onto the sidewalk outside, the bell above the door jingling cheerfully as if they'd just exited normally.

Stacy blinked, disoriented, then grabbed the handle and shoved the door open.

They stepped inside...

...and immediately found themselves stepping back out onto the sidewalk again.

They both froze.

Stacy tried again, faster this time, shoving through the doorway with determination.

Outside.

Again.

The bell chimed politely each time, as if mocking them.

Evan stared at the door like it had personally betrayed him.

"Thanks a lot," he muttered bitterly, glancing at Stacy. "Now we can't even ask for help."


Inside the shop, unseen, Madame Ruth watched through the slightly fogged glass, her expression thoughtful.

She studied them as they argued on the sidewalk. Stacy gesturing sharply, Evan pacing in tight circles, both of them orbiting a center neither of them understood yet.

She smiled slowly.

"Yes," she murmured to herself, turning back toward her shelves of bottles. "That one's going to be very interesting."

She reached up and straightened the bottle of Love Potion Number Ten, already considering what the next customer might need.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)