Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by Mr Nice Guy Mr Nice Guy

What's next?

Head of the Table

Evan stared out the passenger window while the city blurred past in streaks of grey pavement and red brake lights.

Stacy drove like she was trying to outrun the concept of gravity itself. Both hands clenched the steering wheel, knuckles pale, jaw locked so tightly he wondered if her teeth hurt. The car lurched once as she changed lanes without signaling, cutting off a delivery van whose horn blasted indignantly behind them.

Evan shifted in his seat.

"Look," he started carefully, "I didn't mean for..."

"Shut up."

The words landed flat and immediate, like a door slamming.

He swallowed and watched a row of storefronts slide by. The silence stretched, thick and suffocating, broken only by the hum of tires against asphalt the sound of Stacy breathing angrily through her nose.

He tried again, quieter.

"I didn't know she'd..."

"I said shut up, Evan."

He pressed his lips together. The city light flickered across her face as they passed under an overpass, briefly illuminating the fury simmering there. Several blocks passed before he made the mistake of speaking again.

"I was just trying to..."

"Your selfish, creepy, idiotic little science experiment has ruined my life!" she shouted, slamming the brakes at a red light hard enough to jolt them both forward against their seatbelts.

A pedestrian halfway through the crosswalk froze and stared at them.

Evan shrank slightly into his seat.

"You could have stopped me from drinking the stupid thing. You could have fixed this," she continued, voice shaking with rage. "You did this. You bought it. You brought it into the house. You let me think that it was harmless!"

"I didn't mean for you to drink it," he said weakly.

"Congratulations," she snapped. "That doesn't make it better."

The light turned green. She hit the gas like she was personally offended by traffic laws. Evan leaned his head back against the seat and closed his eyes. Madame Ruth's words echoed unpleasantly in his skull.

Don't fight it.

Yeah. Easy for her to say.

Soon enough the house came into view. Stacy pulled into the driveway and killed the engine with a violent twist of the key. Neither of them moved for a moment. The porch light glowed warmly, absurdly normal. She shoved her door open and marched toward the house without looking back. Evan followed like he was being led to a disciplinary hearing.

Inside, the television was already on. The living room glowed blue from the evening news, the anchor speaking in calm, practiced tones about municipal budget disputes. Evan's dad sat on the couch, remote in hand, posture relaxed, shoes kicked off. He glanced over his shoulder as they entered.

"Oh, hey," his dad said easily. "You're back."

His gaze flicked to Stacy. "Dinner was great, by the way. Thanks for cooking."

Evan blinked.

His dad gestured lazily toward the kitchen with the remote. "I packed the leftovers into containers. Wasn't sure if you two were having a dinner date or coming back to eat."

Evan's brain stuttered. The normalcy of it all made his brain ache.

He glanced at Stacy. "So... do you want to eat?"

She exhaled slowly through her nose like she was debating whether starvation might be preferable. Then she dropped her purse onto the side table next to the couch with a dull thud.

"Fine," she said stiffly, turning and walking toward the kitchen. "But stay on your side of the table. I don't want anything to do with you."

After a moment, Evan turned to follow. His dad snorted behind them.

"Trouble in paradise?" his dad called without turning around.

Neither of them answered.

"Yeah, I know," his dad added casually, eyes still on the television, "none of my business."

He raised the volume slightly as if punctuating the statement. Then, after a moment, he muted it again and turned halfway toward Evan and Stacy who had almost left the room, looking faintly uncertain.

"Uh... actually," his dad said, rubbing the back of his neck, "before I forget... would it be okay if I borrowed the car later tonight? I just need to run to the store and pick a few things up."

The words hung in the air. Stacy's eyebrows shot upward. Evan felt like someone had quietly swapped the floorboards beneath him for loose sand.

"The car?" Evan repeated.

"Yeah," his dad said, nodding, suddenly looking oddly self-conscious. "Just for an hour or so. I'll fill the tank if it’s low."

Evan stared at him. His dad didn't own the car? What else had changed? He became aware that both of them were waiting for him to answer.

"Uh... yeah," Evan said slowly. "That's fine."

His dad's shoulders relaxed immediately.

"Thanks, son," he said warmly, turning back toward the television and unmuting it like the matter had been formally resolved.

Evan stood frozen for a second, thrown by the tone. There was something subtly different. Not the words. The weight behind them. His dad had sounded deferential in a way Evan had never heard before. Observing from the sidelines instead of occupying the centre.

What was going on with Stacy was bad enough, but this made it worse.

Stacy, however, seemed have shaken it off more quickly. Already in the kitchen, yanking open the fridge, her mind was on the next task, not her former husband.

Once they were reheated, the leftovers smelled incredible. Garlic and herbs and butter filled the air, rich and warm. Stacy plated the food with brisk, efficient movements, sliding his plate across the counter toward him without meeting his eyes.

They sat across from each other at the dining table. Evan took his first bite.

It was honestly amazing. The vegetables were perfectly cooked, the seasoning balanced, the texture crisp without being raw. He hated how much he enjoyed it, how good it made him feel. It was as if she had prepared it perfectly with his tastes in mind.

He chewed slowly, watching her over the rim of his fork.

She looked furious even while eating. Gorgeous and furious. Her hair had come loose slightly during the drive, strands falling across her cheek. The kitchen light caught the curve of her collarbone, the subtle tension in her shoulders, the sharp concentration she applied to stabbing her food like it had personally offended her.

Please log in to view the image

My wife, his brain supplied, unhelpfully.

Resentment flared immediately behind the thought.

Why did it have to be her?

Why did it have to happen like this?

Why couldn't the universe have just left things alone?

He reached for his water glass.

Clink.

The sound was soft but unmistakable. He frowned and looked down. A silver band circled his ring finger.

Across the table, Stacy had gone still. Her gaze had dropped to his hand at the exact same moment.

Slowly, mechanically, Evan rotated his wrist. The ring caught the overhead light, glinting with quiet, undeniable permanence. He looked up. She was staring at it. Then she raised her own hand slightly off the table. A matching band gleamed on her finger.

Their eyes met.

The silence stretched long and brittle between them.

Stacy rolled her eyes with theatrical exhaustion and dropped her hand back to her fork.

"Great," she said flatly.

Evan lowered his hand slowly into his lap, suddenly hyperaware of the weight pressing against his skin.

They finished eating in silence.

The television droned faintly from the living room. Something about international trade agreements. His dad laughed once at something the anchor said, comfortable and distant, like they were guests in their own house.

When they finished, Stacy stood and gathered both plates without asking. She rinsed them briskly and loaded them into the dishwasher with sharp, efficient movements.

Evan hovered awkwardly near the doorway.

"So," he said finally, hating how small his voice sounded, "what do we do now?"

She didn't turn around.

"What happens now is you are sleeping in the spare room," she said, clicking the dishwasher shut. "And I sleep in my bed. Alone."

She finally faced him, expression carved from polished stone.

"And don't even think about arguing," she added, already walking toward the hallway.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)