Susie

I figured it was time to step things up with some real action. Unfortunately, I wasn’t allowed to make any dares that involved myself. So I figured I’d pick on my sister again.

“Ok, I’ve got it. This is a dare for Susie. I dare you to do 69 with one of your friends. The twist is you have to pick which one you want to do it with. The other twist is you have to do it until one of you cums. The trick is to see who can make the other one cum first.”

“Damn it, David! Now you’re putting me on the spot. No matter who I chose someone will be unhappy. Or maybe the one I pick will be unhappy,” she laughed. She looked over at each of her girlfriends trying to make a decision. “Well, it’s got to be Beth, of course,” she smiled slyly.

I wasn’t sure why it was ‘of course’ but Beth gave her the same smile back.

Susie got up from the sofa and reached for Beth’s hand and led her to the middle of the floor between the sofa and my chair. The two naked girls stood there in front of me for a minute, then Susie pulled Beth to her and they launched into a big wet sloppy kiss. Their hands roamed over each other’s body, feeling their asses and tits. Susie pulled Beth down to the floor and laid her gently on her back. She got down on her knees and squatted over Beth’s face then bent forward and lowered her own face to Beth’s snatch.

Both girls started licking and probing each other’s snatch with their tongue, which soon evoked moaning and groaning from both of them. I could see Susie best since she was on top, her head bent down over Beth’s pussy. She licked her slit back and forth with a flat tongue then alternated with flicking at Beth’s red nub. She progressed from licking her slit to making her tongue more pointy and pushing it between Beth’s soft folds. At the same time she brought her hand down onto her warm mound where she was able to manually stimulate Beth’s swollen clit.

Beth was moaning and writhing on the floor beneath my sister, but I could tell that her efforts were having the same effect on my sister as well. Susie had to lift her head from Beth’s cunt from time to time to let out a long low moan and she seemed unable to keep her hips from moving up and down and side to side.

Even though I had just cum not too long ago when Carly jacked me off into her bra and panties, watching the two girls going at each other had me totally hard again. There was no way I could resist the need to stroke my rigid member as I watched my sister and her friend performing mutual cunnilingus. At the rate things were progressing, it was possible that I was going to be the first to cum, not one of them.

Beth had her hands on my sister’s ass, pulling her pussy down hard on her tongue, giving her a slight advantage. But Susie had her pussy pinned against the floor and she also had no escape from Susie’s ministrations. I looked across at the sofa and both Amy and Carly were massaging their own pussies and their moans joined the chorus coming from the two girls on the floor. The sounds of female excitement were filling the room, making the whole scene even hotter.

Was it possible that all five of us would cum at the same time? Talk about your mutual orgasm! Well, that’s exactly what happened just a few seconds later. It was impossible to actually tell who was first, Susie or Beth. I would have to call it a tie. But their screams as they got each other off were incredibly loud and triggered more screams from Amy and Carly on the sofa. Seeing four hot young girls quivering and spasming and screaming in front of me, triggered my orgasm too as I shot huge jets of hot white cum from my cum hole. It even shot far enough for some to land on my sister’s back as she writhed on the floor in front of me.

It took a short while for everybody to come down from their sexual high and we all just lay there breathing heavily. Susie had rolled onto her back next to Beth and looked over at me with glazed eyes.

“So?” she managed to **** the words out looking at me. “Who won?”

“Well, I guess technically it was a tie, but let’s just say everybody won,” I grinned. I directed my eyes toward the two spent girls on the sofa and Susie followed my look and grinned upon seeing them. She looked back at me and saw the cum dripping off my cock and then reached around and felt her back and realized what was there. She slowly got to her feet and helped Beth off the floor and they slumped back onto the sofa.

“So I guess I get to choose the next ‘victim’ now,” she said breathlessly. “Well, I know that me and Beth need a break, so that means it has to be somebody else.”