Susie

“I think I’m going to go with the birthday girl again. After all it’s her party. I think she needs to have more fun. Ready for your dare, girlfriend?”

“Sure, how bad can it be,” Susie laughed nervously.

“Not too bad,” she assured her. “Since David’s naked now, I think we need to even things up a little. Take off your shorts.”

“Why me?” Susie asked in surprise.

“Because it’s your dare?” Amy grinned. “Besides, it’s like keeping it all in the family, ok?”

Susie just shrugged her shoulders. “Ok,” she agreed. “I guess what’s good for the gander is good for the goose, right?” She tried a little laugh.

Personally I was happy with this turn of events because I had been wondering all night if she was wearing any panties under those tight gray shorts or not.

She stood up and reached for the waist of her shorts. “Well, here goes nothin’, I guess.” She turned her back to the room and looked over her shoulder. Then she started pushing her shorts down and had to really wiggle to get out of them they were so tight. Ever so slowly it seemed her round ass came into view as bare as the day she was born. I was right, there was no way she could have fit any panties under those shorts. I couldn’t believe I was seeing my sister totally naked for the first time in my life. I had to admit she was pretty damn hot.

Her ass wiggled as she pushed the shorts the rest of the way down her legs and as she bent over to pull them over her feet I got my first view of her pudenda peeking out between her ass cheeks. She stood back up then slowly turned around bringing her totally bare mound and pussy into view. There was nothing I could do to hide my raging hard-on since I was totally nude too.

“So what do you think, bro? Do you like what you see?” she grinned at me running her hands over her body sexily. She appeared to be really getting into it now, no longer embarrassed by the state of nudity in the room. She turned around again and wiggled her ass and bent over and wiggled it some more.

“Wow, sis. I knew you were hot, but that’s one damn beautiful bod, baby. Why you been hiding it from me all these years?”

She just grinned and sat back down. All the eyes in the room were on her. She seemed to be enjoying the attention.

So now my sister and I were totally naked, Amy was only wearing her unzipped white denim shorts, not sure if she wore panties or not, Beth was only wearing panties and Carly had on her skimpy pink bra and panties. I wondered what my sister would do next.