Suprise Butt Sex

“Uuuhn,” Sabrina groaned in her chest and throat. “Uuu-huuuu-huunnn.”

She was sitting straight up, her posture completely erect. Her face and chest were flushed a rosy pink and her little tits were jostling and wiggling as her body shook. You had a straight sightline to her pussy, her labia a warm hue from the fucking you’d been doing and her inner lips spread apart like they wanted you back inside them.

But you weren’t inside them. You were inside her ass.

“You’ve got this, baby,” Gemma coached Sabrina gently. “You’ve got this. Just a little at a time. Go slow, baby.”

“Holy fuck,” you groaned, letting your head fall back against the mattress and closing your eyes. Sabrina had a tight pussy. Gemma’s ass was tighter still. But Sabrina’s ass felt like you were going to lose your cock to loss of blood flow her little anal ring was constricting so hard despite the lube that Gemma had fingered into her.

“A little bit more now,” Gemma said. She was kneeling behind Sabrina, her hands on the brunette’s hips to help steady her.

“Eeeeeehhhmmm,” Sabrina groaned.

“That’s half, baby!” Gemma cheered softly. “You’re doing so fucking good.”

“How?” you asked.

“Numbing lube,” Gemma explained. “As soon as she saw it at the sex shop and the gay guy at the counter explained what it was, Sabrina had to try it.”

Sabrina babbled something behind her gag.

“Is it working?” you asked her.

Sabrina’s face was scrunched up, but you couldn’t tell if it was from pain or concentration because of the sex tape. She nodded quickly though.

“OK,” you exhaled.

The coaching continued, which was a little silly in retrospect considering Gemma had only started doing anal with you in the last month herself.

Part of you wanted to see what your cock in her ass looked like. It wouldn’t be a big deal to either of them if you asked Gemma to snap a quick picture, but you decided against it. You’d save that fun for another time. After the debacle that Sabrina’s first attempt at anal had been, on camera no less, you didn’t want to jinx anything.

“OK, stop there,” Gemma told Sabrina, who halted her descent onto your cock. “You’ve got about six inches of him in you now, the last bit is the hardest for me. I think you shouldn’t push yourself this time and just work with this. OK?”

“Mmmhmm,” Sabrina nodded in agreement.

Gemma smiled and leaned in to kiss Sabrina on the shoulder. “Just take it slow. You’re in charge of this part. John will fuck up at you when you’re ready.”

It took a lot of deep breathing on both of your parts, but Sabrina did start to ride your cock. She ended up leaning forward more and you raised your hands to cup her face and give her some more leverage since she couldn’t brace herself, and in that position she slowly started to raise up and down on about three inches of cock until she was in a slow rhythm.

“You’re doing so good, baby,” you told her. “God, your ass feels amazing. I’m so fucking lucky to have you. You have both of you.”

Sabrina babbled something, and Gemma eased her way down to sit more beside the two of you, no longer holding Sabrina’s hips and instead just rubbing her back. “She says she loves you.”

“I say I love her too,” you said and leaned up to give her a kiss where her lips were behind the sex tape.

“Mmmph-mmm,” Sabrina mumbled, and you didn’t get it so you looked to Gemma.

“I don’t know what that was,” Gemma shook her head.

“Mmph!” Sabrina hummed, then patted your hip and went down on your cock a little firmer.

“Fuuuuuck,” you groaned, and on her next in-stroke while riding you thrust up into her.

“Hmmmmmmuh!” Sabrina moaned.

“More like that, love,” Gemma encouraged you.

You fucked Sabrina’s ass. It wasn’t particularly hard, or even particularly rough and dirty like she liked regular sex, but you did manage to get a good clip going as she rolled her body. Gemma’s hands wandered, stroking Sabrina’s ass or your balls, then reaching between you to tease Sabrina’s clit, then up to pinch at her nipples.

Sabrina babbled again, and you didn’t need a translation. You could tell by the way she was tensing, and the goosebumps on her skin, that she was getting close.

“Choke her, love,” Gemma said and gave Sabrina a spank on the ass.

You wrapped your fingers around Sabrina’s throat again, squeezing the way she liked, and your other hand trailed down her body to palm her booty and squeeze her cheek. Gemma spanked her other cheek again with a solid clap, and Sabrina started keening a soft whine in her chest as she pressed down to you more until her chest was pressed to yours and her hips were only able to hump up and down a little. That left you to be the one to thrust, and you fucked up at her with an insistent pounding.

“That’s it, my good dirty girl. You’re so fucking pretty when you’re this close to coming, baby. I can see you holding it back already like the perfect little darling you are,” you whispered to her. “Your ass feels so fucking good, Sabrina. You’re squeezing me so hard, as soon as you come I think I’m going to as well. Do you want me to do that? Do you want me to come in your ass while you come on my cock?”

Sabrina nodded loosely, almost delirious.

Gemma spanked her ass again and shoved her other hand between you to maul Sabrina’s tit. Then she pinched the fleshy part of Sabrina’s butt.

“Hm,” Sabrina squeaked, a pitiful little sound as her eyes were watering and her body was tensed all over. ‘Please.’

“Go, baby,” you groaned. “Come for me, love.”

She let go and came.

You let go and came.

You lost coherent thought as it felt like your cock exploded into shrapnel and your mind went bye-bye for a long moment. When you blinked, your back was arched you were thrusting up into Sabrina so insistently and she was fully seated on your cock as she shouted and moaned into her gag, her face pressed into the crook of your neck even while you kept one hand on her throat.

Another blink and you were breathing deeply, Sabrina’s full weight on your chest and your hands fallen to the side. You were covered in sweat and you felt lightheaded. Your cock, still hard, was caught with just the head in Sabrina’s ass. She was busy licking the side of your neck as her body continued to jerk with aftershocks of her orgasm.

“Easy now,” Gemma said softly.

Hands were on your chest, pressing firmly, and when you looked up you saw that Sabrina wasn’t handcuffed anymore and she was slowly dismounting from you.

“I think I died there for a second,” you said roughly.

Sabrina hummed something, smiling behind the tape, as she sat tenderly onto the mattress next to you and then laid down, curling up and snuggling against your side.

“Don’t fall asleep,” Gemma said, patting Sabrina’s hip. “We need to get the tape off of you and you’ll be leaking that giant fucking load John just put in your ass all over the bed.

Sabrina groaned and sat back up, and Gemma unwound the tape from around her mouth and neck. As soon as she could Sabrina spit out the completely soaked, and possibly chewed-on, panties from her mouth and had to work her jaw a few times. Then she turned and almost collapsed on top of you as she planted her lips to yours.

“I did it,” she said, grinning into your kiss and hug as you bundled your arms around her.

“You did it,” you grinned.

Breakthebar erotica is powered by Patreon, where OFG chapters are now releasing 5+ chapters ahead. PM if interested in making a Commission.