Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by 69Anon69 69Anon69

What's next?

Sunday Evening

After finishing some work, I headed over to Emily and Steven's place. They were the couple that I had been a bull for the longest- ever since Steven cheated on Emily more than two years ago. After I started with them, Emily and I found out that he had cheated because he knew he was a beta, but was insecure and afraid of sharing it with her. So our arrangement stuck, Steven ended up being the happiest with it.

I pulled up to their apartment and parked my car out front. I could see Emily out on their second floor balcony, waiting for me. That was unusual. Her long blonde hair was down, and she was wearing a beautiful bright sundress, perfect for late summer. When it caught the breeze, it pulled tight against the front of her body, showing how amazing her tits were. I gave a little extra hustle getting in the building.

When I got to their apartment on the second floor their door was already open, and they were waiting for me. Steven was holding Emily in his arms, but when she saw me she broke away to run and give me a hug. Emily had a really bubbly personality.

"We're engaged!" She screamed at me, excitedly showing me her ring. "Steven proposed at the park today, it was amazing!"

"Wow! Congratulations you two!" They were a great couple, I was happy for them. Steven beamed with pride.

"Come on in," Steven invited me. He turned to re-enter the apartment. Before Emily and I could follow in, she pulled me by my arm, wanting to whisper something in my ear-

"You get to fuck me first. I'm so horny but I made Steven wait."

"Good girl." I smiled back at her.

When we got inside we sat down in the living room, and Steven served wine. We had developed something of a ritual at this point. Emily sat by me on the couch, pawing away at me, while Steven sat in a chair across from us. When they had finished recapping their day, and retelling the story of Steven's proposal, I set down my wine and said, "Let's head to the bedroom." Emily had gotten me quite worked up while we were sitting, kissing my neck and rubbing my cock through my jeans. We all got up, and Steven watched as I pressed my groin against Emily's ass. She giggled when she felt how hard she had gotten me. Steven dutifully followed us into their bedroom.

I threw Emily up on the bed, and followed after her. We made out while tearing off our cloths. Steven got naked as well, and sat on a chair in the corner of the room. He was wearing a dick cage that I had the key for.

I got on top of Emily, pinning her to the bed. I began to rub her pussy, she wasn't lying earlier, she was really horny.

"Take the ring off." I huffed, feeling hot from making out with this beautiful woman. She was shocked, unsure what to say back, or if she should comply. She looked to Steven in the corner.

"Don't look at him, look at me. Look at my cock. He's your fiance, but I'm your man. I want you to take the ring off."

"Wait, please don't make her-"

"Steven," I interrupted him, "if you're a good boy, I'll let you out." I held up the keys to his cage, and dangled them in front of him. He went silent. He would never actually stand up to me. Steven enjoyed being the beta to my alpha. Me shutting him down was what he wanted. Emily wanted to humiliate him too, she smiled and took off the ring, handing it to me.

"It's ok. I was honestly a little embarrassed to show it to you. I don't like it." She told me. A lie, but none of us cared. Part of the game. I took the ring from her, and set it on the night stand.

I then locked eyes with Emily as I slowly thrust my cock into her. She moaned my name as I held her, made love to her. Steven squirmed in his chair. Turned on at being cucked, but unable to touch himself.

Emily wrapped her legs around me as I sped up my pace, just a little bit. I found a steady rhythm that set her off, moaning and screaming, but I was still unable to fit my whole cock inside her. After a few minutes, working to get her really wet, and relaxed, I asked, "You ready for more baby?"

"Yes! Yes! Please! I need more of you dick John!" I slowed back down, and focused on pushing more of my dick into her. I rubbed her tummy and teased her, "How far up am I baby?" I asked.

"So far up, your dick is so big," she responded in pure ecstasy and horniness. Her eyes were watering as she came on my cock. She moaned as I thrusted deeper and deeper. Her pussy relaxed enough that I could finally feel her cervix, almost my whole cock inside of her.

"Right where it belongs." I told her. I began to fuck her harder and faster, doing my best to delay cumming in her tight, sweet pussy. When she came again, I flipped her over and fucked her doggy style. Her head was buried in the pillows, and she moaned and screamed, almost uncontrollably. I had refrained from my usual dirty talk with Emily earlier. It had seemed more appropriate given the occasion to make sweet love to her in front of Steven. Remind him that even engaged, this part of their relationship would always belong to me. But now, fucking her doggy style, I was unleashed. I called her my little cum slut, told her how tight her pussy was, every horny thing that came to my mind. And she muffled her responses back from between the pillows, telling me how much better I was than Steven.

It all sent me over the edge, I buried my dick deep inside Emily, and came. Her pussy began contracting around my dick, and she came with me. After we came down from our orgasmic high, I pulled out of her, and lay down on the bed.

"Stay there," I told her, "just like that." She stayed in the doggy position.

"Here." I told Steven, tossing him the keys to his cage. "Clean her up," I told him.

Steven got on the bed, and put his legs between Emily's knees. She lowered, and sat on his face, while he ate her out, and slurped my cum out of her pussy. Emily moaned in pleasure, though not nearly as loudly as before.

"Good boy!" She told him when he was done.

"Me too." I told him. Steven moved quickly between my legs and eagerly took my cock in hand. He licked my shaft clean of Emily's juices. "Look how eager he is to hold a real cock," I quipped to Emily, as she moved to lay next to me, resting her head on my chest. We laughed together. Steven massaged my balls with one hand, and stroked my shaft with the other, coaxing the remaining cum out of me, and sucking it into his mouth.

When we were done in the bedroom it was time for me to go. I left without putting Steven back in his cage, giving the couple a week to enjoy their engagement before I came back next Sunday to lock him up again.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)