Suggest they throw her into the pit

Recognizing an opportunity, you start the chant.

"Into the pit! Into the pit! Into the pit!" Without any coaxing, the rest of them join in.

Her eyes widen in utter horror. "NOOOO!" she squeals.

Richard grabs her arms, and his sailor friend grab her legs. Her large tits point up at the air and bounce from side to side as she struggles to get away, squealing with humiliation. Her long skirt still covers her lower body. As they carry her closer to the pit, members of the crowd grope Merry. She screams in-depth threats at each man who touches her, but they just laugh more at her anger.

You can tell from some of the interactions that many of people in this crowd know her, and for some reason it's making them revel even more in her humiliation.

With the crowd completely distracted, Evellyn has finally managed to make it out of the pit. You see her making a break for the mansion's entrance. You laugh as you see she's forgotten you dumped her clothing out of the window. She could have easily grabbed them, not that they would rid her of the muck covering her body, nor the scent of it.

At the edge of the pungent pit, the two sailors swing her back and forth chanting "Heave-ho" and swaying her with more **** each time. She shrieks threats as her huge breasts swing back and forth. Then she results to different tactics.

"I beg you don't throw me in there! I'll suck both of your cocks if you let me go! I'll suck every man here!" she pleads desperately.

They only laugh at her offer, letting go and laughing even harder as she screams while flying through the air. She does a belly flop, going all the way under as the muck splashes all around her. The crowd goes wild.