What advice will you give?

Sometimes the area is more important than the implement

"The paddle certainly looks effective," you say, "but is there some part of Tilly's anatomy that she finds particularly sensitive, perhaps?"

"Oh, I don't actually know, Jack. I mostly concentrate on the traditional areas when I'm punishing a student. I suppose her back causes her a lot of suffering, like most girls, but I wouldn't say it's exceptional."

Dr. Blake's lack of creativity in the chastisement of her charges surprises you, but not everyone can enjoy giving a good hard spanking as much as you do. Her talents as a tutor must lie in other directions.

"Well, Sharon, we could experiment a little, test Tilly all over her body and see what makes her suffer the most."

"We could do that, Jack," she replies in a tone that implies she has no intention of doing so, then she returns to the still-sobbing girl on her table.

"Tilly, is there some part of your anatomy that you find particularly sensitive to a thrashing?"

You're not sure whether this is the most reliable way of gathering the required information, but from the way the young women starts to wail piteously as she nods and sobs out the words yes, miss, you can tell the question distresses her greatly.

"Well?" Dr. Blake asks, impatiently.

"M-my p-p-pudenda, Miss," Tilly blubbers wretchedly.

Her former tutor purses her lips in concentration and leans forward to inspect the area, then straightens and demands a more specific location.

"Just ar-round my c-clitoris and pee-hole. Oh, no," she closes her eyes and weeps, as though she can't quite believe she's shared this unwelcome secret with her chastiser.

"Hmm," Dr. Blake mulls over the options in her spanking rack, considerably less well provisioned than your own. "What do you think, Jack? The paddle's not suitable, obviously."

"I have exactly the implement in my rooms," you reply, thinking of a thin, flexible rubber whip that you've found to be abominably painful, but light enough to use extensively without wearing out your arm, or indeed the supple flesh of the recipient of your attention. Of course, it won't be much use there.