Something a little different

“Well, aren't you a nasty piece of work, Miss Miller.” I guess I am expecting my tenant to deny this crude assessment, but I soon realize how deeply she is willing to play out the role of the little slut I was going to fuck.

“You like it don't you, Mr. Patterson?” Alison smiles at me coyly, “All you horny old geezers want to get a taste of this hot young body.” Her lips curl into a cute little pout and she wiggles her ass invitingly.

“You can do anything you like, Sir.” Her voice slips almost into a whine, clearly after masturbating like she was Alison is more than ready to get a good fucking and I confess I'm more than a little tempted to oblige her.

“Really, Miss Miller?” I ask as I reach out a single finger and touch the glistening petals of her sex. “I'm not some boy. A real man who gets an invitation like that ... he might do all sorts of nasty things.” Her moan as my finger pushes into her indicates that she is more than ready to accept the consequences of her teasing.

“That's right, Sir. I bet you'd like to fuck this teenaged pussy of mine, wouldn't you?” She's not wrong, but that doesn't mean I'm going to do this on her terms. I switch my finger from her dripping pussy to press against the tight brown hole just below. Alison's eyes open in shock and for the first time in a couple days, I see the sheltered small-town girl that I have grown to know and care for.

“What?!?” Alison's gasp of surprise is fucking hot. I smile wickedly as I very slowly twist my finger until the tip presses into her anus. “Mr. Patterson?”

“Do you still mean 'anything', Miss Miller?” I leave my finger inserted almost up to the knuckle and use my thumb to rub her clit. “Do you want to cum, Alison? Do you want the release a man can give you.”

“Oh, Dear Lord forgive me!” Her hand grips mine with a fierce strength that I've come to expect from this beautiful coed, and she pulls so my thumb presses even harder against her clit. “Yes!” Her eyes roll back in their sockets and her body quivers against me as the muscles of her sphincter squeeze tightly around my finger. “Please Mr. P! Make that naughty little tease squirt all over your fingers. Make that slut climax and then fuck her hard before she even has a chance to recover!”