Slumber Party

Fiora had finally settled down and closed her eyes slowly caressing your arm, meanwhile Lissa was not slowing down on teasing your thin pants. The other girls joined them back in the room and Mary winked, "Building quite a collection. Told you Sarah, it's just how people work."

Sarah gave her a sarcastic laugh and slid down her black dress to her ankles. "Holy shit!" Pete hissed, "Uh, Sarah?"

The blonde was wearing some white nylon lingerie but he could now see her breasts had grown for sure, the bra was much too small and did some amazing things before his eyes. Her new curvier hips and ass were perfectly shaped by her bottoms. She raised an eye brow at him. "We're all sleeping down here, remember? I'm not sleeping in a dress that can suffocate me and I'm not ruining a slumber party because some perv can't keep his eyes to himself! Don't get any weird ideas Harry Potter."

Mary shook her head and did the same tossing her dress over her head, Pete almost thought she was unaware how her actions were making her tits move but when she pulled the dress over her head she was looking right at him. She was wearing red lace panties and a bra with nude stockings and he realized in all the chaos of the day he never realized the new Mary was smoking! Her ass matched Lissa before whatever happened today and her tits rivalled Sarah. She wasn't as athletic or slim but her thick thighs and long hips were mesmerizing not to mention her face almost seemed more sensual than before somehow. Her hair was always perfect as well. No doubt she was thinking the same thing eyeing her reflection and posing before blowing it a kiss and turning off the lights. The house glowed slightly pink from the strange mystic glowing gas that surrounded their house and Pete frowned. Emily seemed like a good thing for him and didn't seem to bothered with hurting anybody. But if what she said was right about these creations, one screwup could be the end of them.

Seeing two half naked women pulling up a blanket together on the floor and tossing their bras aside he made a strange realization. They had come here to see a horror film be made, but everything about this vacation was some weird horror porn. At least instead of dying they just became braindead sex addicts.

The girls on the floor giggled a few minutes later before he could hear Sarah laugh, "Stop..."

"You think mouse is good, I'm just saying..." he heard Mary tease, "Plus maybe it will take your mind off playboy's dick."

There was silence and he closed his eyes, hearing them shuffle and pause. Eventually they shuffled again and Sarah whispered, "Stop bringing that up! It's hard enough as it is!"

"With the four hottest girls in school? I'm surprised if he's ever soft!"

"Stop!"

"Come on, you actually hate him that much? Why?" Mary was serious for once.

There was a long pause. "Have you ever thought how ridiculous this all is?"

"Again with this?"

"No-no! I'm serious! Not the weird ghost, spell whatever. How weird we've been best friends for years...and we all started liking the same guy? And he ends up being the only guy during our vacation? You'd think we'd naturally choose other guys, right?"

"'We all'? Girl...what aren't you saying."

He heard Sarah sigh, "If I tell you this....and you tell anyone. We are done. That's how serious this is." Another pause. "Back in high school I had a crush on Pete...I waited for him to you know...do the thing. Jock tries his shot with the head cheerleader. Year goes by, we barely talk. The party before you started hanging with us I started flirting with him and he blew me off. Tried saying that I was 'probably too drunk'."

"You probably were."

"No! I wasn't. I was my second drink in! But he used that as some lame excuse. I was just out of words you know? So things kind of got awkward for me for a few weeks because word got out I was rejected. So every guy. EVERY GUY. Tries their shot with me, even if I turned them down before. Saying some shit like, maybe I was down on my luck and shit. I worked my ass off at school and extra curriculars, parties! All for him to make some lame ass response in front of everyone. He could have just played dumb but he humiliated me. And I didn't get any peace. School is like the animal kingdom and his rejection put me lower on the food chain."

"I don't wanna piss you off Sarah but so far sounds way too dramatic."

"Imagine trying to date or like anyone again. Oh they're just using you. Or they are just seeing if they have a chance. All of the shit I bitched about didn't start until that party. Eventually I went out and guess who comes and puts the sly moves on me."

"Jay."

"Pete! Comes up barely into the party and asks if I want to chill on the back porch and talk. That's what guys do. They attack your self worth, wait it out, then let you come crawling to them and expect you to thank them. He was his usual flirtatious self and I figured he wanted to go make out and so I dunno I got pissed. I told him to go fuck himself and called him the perv he was, then got absolutely smashed."

"You aren't going to say what I think you're going to say." There was another pause. "Jay was your rebound!"

"He was actually nice. He didn't turn me down in front of everyone and pulled me aside, kissed me and got my number. I wanted more because you know, fuck Pete. But he told me he'd rather me sober. When we were alone, like a gentleman. No games. No bullshit. Gentleman. I find out later they are best friends and have to deal with the guy all the time. Up side was I saw how he looked at me the past two years. A proper man got me, Pete lost his chance by being a playboy."

Pete tensed. He had always wondered why Sarah was so unnecessarily mean to him, or antagonistic. He always was curious why it seemed like she was flirty or teasing but invested in the relationship. She thought him not taking advantage of her was some social game to him! Not to mention Jay had said she came on to him and he didn't know who she was at the time. But Jay made the move on her after she said no at the party! Pete had always thought she was out of his league until she approached him and wanted something long term and was afraid of it only being a drunk hook up. Only when he realized she was into him did he try to approach her but she was too in her own head and ended dating his friend who used the opportunity to get the hottest girl in school!

Serves them right for the shit relationship then, he thought glancing at his phone beside the couch. He could ask Emily for revenge. Something to get the dumb blonde back for being so petty. If two sleeping girls weren't in the way making him hesitate he probably would have. He eventually calmed down and accepted the more mature reality, anything he asked could be permanent. Sarah may have been fucked up but she had to live in her own weird fictional hell she described, he just had to put up with her. A rough fuck wasn't out of the question but permanently changing who she was might have been as extreme of a reaction as what she had done to begin with. Point to take was, she liked him. The past three to four years everything she did was to spite him for turning her down.

"So what now then? Pete somehow is behind all this to get back at you for getting back at him? Mary chuckled, "You sure you aren't the one making a movie?"

"I don't care to be honest. I know there's the temptation here, a lot of it. But I know deep down what he's like and he can't fool me. I'm not getting venerable or giving that guy any satisfaction and paying the price. You can, I'm out."

"So all that talk about 'me not knowing him in school' and 'you don't know what he's really like' was just you salty he turned you down one time?" Mary clearly was speaking through gritted teeth.

"No. It was me warning you about his games. He doesn't take anything seriously and obviously doesn't care who he hurts."

Mary scoffed, "Holy shit! It sounds like you got the two guys mixed up. Isn't it weird how Jay swooped in and made you feel good after you drank the pain away of Pete supposedly being an asshole. Isn't it crazy how Jay ended up going for the exact girl his best friend was into? Isn't it crazy how he never defended his best friend whenever you were a bitch or told us to stay away from him behind his back?"

"Well..." Sarah paused, "Jay wasn't like that though, he didn't care about how popular I was or any of that status shit."

"He didn't go to your school! He was banging the hot piece of ass his friends wanted but couldn't have and had you rubbing it in the entire time!" Mary laughed, "God like I'm sure it's hard to see from the inside but I'm realizing how much you have the wires crossed. Jay was playing you the entire time and when you started to have baggage and turn things around on him suddenly he starts barking back and giving up. Pete has put up with all the shit you threw, tried to move on with me while I lead him on unsure with what you were saying, and the guy is still nice to you. He gave you advice on Jay and even admitted Jay was not really feeling it to save you time. He's even taken care of us when we haven't always been that great."

"You girls act like a softcore porn 24/7."

"That's more frustrating than it is a blessing. Look. Do you kind of see what I'm saying though? Jay could have been with Lily to check up on you. He's not dating you but I'd assume he cares. Pete's phone sometimes gets signal and Fio never once mentioned him ever checking in. Try to tell me Pete hasn't been protective over you at some point in this trip."

"When we got back to the pool after the boathouse he got us cleaned up and made an excuse for us to change out of what the camera gave us..." Sarah muttered. "You think he really was being nice with the drunk thing?"

"Guys aren't the most keen with how their actions or words can flow through a group. They hardly can do that with a person. Sounds like you found a guy that just liked you for you earlier than you thought and being petty threw you into something you didn't. To answer your question that started this all, no I don't think it's weird we all are into the same guy. We are grown up to look for a strong, caring, attractive man and our biology looks for fitness, good equipment and protection. The fact that most women's screening just leaves 'is he nice?' He checks all the boxes for most girls. You might not admit this but I have a feeling weird shit or not we all will end up finding ourselves hooking up with him. What I'm worried about is you three aren't sexually mature enough to deal with whatever happens after the vacay."

Pete waited for more but there was pure silence. He risked a glance and saw Sarah eyes open staring out at a window the shadow of her naked body hiding her glory from him. He could see her face was very unsure and tears running down her face.