Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by 4incher 4incher

What will he do now?

Shrink himself even more

Nathan’s fingers trembled as he stared at the screen, the possibilities overwhelming. The thrill from before hadn’t left him yet. if anything, it was stronger. He bit his lip, hardly believing what he was about to do. But he couldn’t resist the urge. he tapped the slider again, shrinking his size down by another inch.

Soft size: 1.5 inches

Hard size: 2.8 inches

With his cheeks flushed and heart hammering, he hit "Confirm." Another warm tingle washed over him, and when he looked down, his speedo felt even looser than before. His pulse raced with excitement and a little nervousness. He couldn’t believe it—he’d actually done it.

Beside him, Jane turned, giving him a curious look. "Nate, you’ve been acting weird ever since you opened your phone. Everything okay? You aren’t watching porn are you’’ She Joked in a Jane kinda way.

Nathan swallowed, His nerves made him tremble. “Yeah, totally,” he said, trying to sound casual. But Jane’s eyes lingered on him. She was clearly not buying it.

“Sure," she replied slowly, her gaze drifting down. "You’ve just been… really jumpy.”

Nathan felt his face heat up even more. He tried to think of a way to give her a hint, just to see if she’d notice. He shifted his towel so it slipped off his waist a little, his smaller bulge barely making an impression in his red speedo. He caught Jane’s gaze drop to his lap, and she raised an eyebrow, her lips twitching as if she were holding back a smile.

“Nathan…” she started, barely containing a laugh. “Did you… did you shrink?” Her tone was teasing, but there was genuine confusion in her eyes. "Or are you just... cold?"

Nathan’s heart pounded as he felt his body react to her words, his excitement building despite himself. His cheeks burned as his bulge stirred, becoming hard against the thin fabric. Jane’s eyes went wide as she noticed the change, the tiniest bump now obvious in his speedo. She let out a snort, unable to hold back her laughter.

“Oh my God, Nate,” she laughed, covering her mouth, her face a mix of amusement and confusion. “You’re serious? That’s… wow. But how did you—?”

Nathan’s heart raced as he looked away, both embarrassed and exhilarated. He didn’t answer, just grinned sheepishly, letting her confusion and curiosity hang in the air.

Nathan’s face flushed a deep red, his heart racing as he tried to stamer out a defense. “I-I mean… it’s not like… this is just… how I am,” he muttered with red cheeks. looking away and rubbing the back of his neck, attempting a casual shrug. "I’ve always been… you know, on the smaller side." He was trying to play it cool but in his head he was screaming. His Small penis humiliation fantasies are coming true.

Jane’s laughter softened into a curious smile, and she leaned in closer, her brows knitting in disbelief. “Come on… Nate, don’t try to gaslight me,” she said, clearly intrigued. “You weren’t always… this small, were you?” Her gaze flickered back to his lap, her eyes narrowing in playful skepticism. "Or did I just never notice?"

Nathan’s dick throbed as she inched even closer, her head tilting as she examined him, her face just inches away from the tiny red tent in his baggy speedo. He tried to stay calm, but the heat radiating from her made it impossible. He felt the intensity of her gaze, and, despite the embarrassment, a rush of excitement surged through him, filling him with a strange, uncontrollable urge. He felt ready to explode then and there.

“Are you… for real?” she whispered. She was genuinely shocked, her tone somewhere between astonishment and pity. She shook her head, letting out a small, incredulous laugh. “I mean, no offense, but that’s… like, middle school size. Are you sure you’re eighteen?” she laughed. ‘’If I saw this the first time I would have never let you join the team. Everboy is going to know you are this tiny’’ She says grinning up at you. Her face still inches away from his hard member.

Nathan’s face burned, and he could feel himself throbbing, on the verge of losing control right then and there. Her disbelief mixed with her laughter sent a thrill down his spine. He wanted to explain, to justify, but the words wouldn’t come. Her closeness, the way she couldn’t seem to stop giggling… it was too much.

“Are you okay?” she asked, her voice laced with a teasing concern as she pulled back slightly, giving him a smirk that sent his heart racing. Charlie looked her body up in down. The red swimsuit clinging tightly to her body. She had the right curves in all the right places. Her breasts where big and obvious. The whole ordeal has him feeling incredibly horny. Nathan felt ready to explode.

Does he cum?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)