Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 44 by GivenUpOnTrying GivenUpOnTrying

What do they do first?

Show and Tell

They say breakfast is the most important meal of the day, it makes sense, gotta get those nutrients in early to sustain you throughout the day. That being said, isn't that true whenever you eat? It's not like breakfast lasts all day, it's only important when combined with other meals. Sort of like people, they're only at their best when surrounded by others.

Or fucking them. I think my analogy's gone off the rails a bit.

"So. I feel like introductions are in order." Sienna decides. We've relocated to the living room, with Sienna and I taking the chairs, and Rosie and Marie taking up the sofa.

"Don't we already know each other?" Poppy asks nervously, as she perches on the arm of my chair. It's a good point, it's a bit late to be running an icebreaker, we've all met before.

Sienna simply smiles at my sister. "Not that kind of introduction, Popsicle." She explains. "I mean, we take turns getting naked, say our best physical asset, and our dirtiest fantasy. It's a game I've played with a few of my exes, it's really hot." Why do I get the feeling she didn't play it with each ex separately?

"Okay, that sounds fun, not that it takes a lot to get me in the mood." Rosie jokes, standing to take the first turn. I've seen my sister's body a lot recently, but I think it gets better each time. She slides off her pyjamas to reveal she hasn't put on underwear this morning, leaving her naked for the spectators. "I'd say my best asset is... Probably my skin, I try to keep it in good condition. My dirtiest fantasy, that I've thought of so far at least, is probably getting gangbanged by Rufus, Marie, and Poppy. I guess I'll add you in as well, Sienna." She concludes with a wink to our cousin.

Rosie returns to her seat, and Marie decides to go next, seems like we're going in a circle, which leaves me last... I suppose I'd better come up with something.

Surprising no one, Marie also seems to have neglected underwear this morning, her gorgeous chestnut skin juxtaposing against Rosie's pale form. "I guess my best asset is my arse, based on someone's obsession with it." Marie begins, giving a side glance to Rosie, who strokes Marie's backside in response. Seems like those two are more flirtatious than ever. "My dirtiest fantasy would be... It'd... Eating out my mother, I want to go down on my mother." She finishes, hurriedly sitting down again.

We're all aware of Marie's attraction to Trish and Rouge, but she still seems awkward about it. It reminds me of Trish's request... I'm sure I'll hear about the next step before long. I'm so lost in thought, I almost don't notice Sienna taking her turn.

Sienna removes her T-shirt and leggings first, revealing her classy lingerie, seems like she was prepared for this little game. She turns around before reaching back to unhook her bra, throwing it over her shoulder to Rosie's lap, who seems entranced with a goofy smile on her face. Our cousin finishes off by bending over and slowly taking down her knickers, revealing her bald pink cunt.

"I would say, my best assets are my tits." Sienna decides, standing back up and turning around, giving us a look at them. I can't deny it, they're gorgeous, definitely larger than any of the other girls, like something out of a high budget porn film. "My dirtiest fantasy is getting tied up, blindfolded, and having a train run on me by anyone, men, women, whatever, whoever wants a turn."

Sienna returns to her seat, leaving us all stupefied by the erotic display we'd just witnessed, it's increasingly obvious that Sienna knows sexuality a lot better than us. Personally, I can't wait for her to teach me more.

Realising it's my turn, I stand up, and pull my top over my head, followed by my boxer shorts, revealing my already hard penis. "I guess my best asset is my muscles, I keep myself in shape. Dirtiest fantasy? Hard to say, but basically... Anything involving Poppy." I state. "Actually... Anything involving her and one of you... Especially." I admit, looking back it my girlfriend, who doesn't seem surprised by the announcement.

I sit back down as Sienna takes the lead again. "Well, with that done, I-"

"Wait, I didn't get a turn." Poppy interrupts Sienna, causing all of us to turn to her in surprise.

"Sorry Pops, we just assumed... Well..." Rosie stutters, unable to put it into words. Marie and Sienna also look too shocked to explain.

"I'm not a little girl." Poppy argues, standing up, before pulling her pyjama top over her head. With defiant purpose, she follows up by sliding her bottoms off too. I half expect her to stop there, but before I know it, she's reaching back and unhooking her bra, letting it fall to the floor.

It's not like I haven't seen Poppy's body before, we grew up together, it happens, but... It's so different now. Her breasts aren't as big as Rosie's, but they seem to fit perfectly into her silhouette, like she was drawn by an artist rather than genetics. They wobble gently as she reaches down and removed her underwear, revealing her messily trimmed pussy. I bet she was too shy to look up how to do it properly, but it just seems to add to her cuteness.

"I think my best asset is... I don't know... I guess my eyes? And my dirtiest fantasy is... Well... I like being told what to do... Being dominated... I suppose." She declares nervously, unable to look any of us in the eye.

I can't help myself, she looks so cute just waiting for a response. I stand and pull her into an embrace, and I can feel her hug me back, her heart's beating at a million miles a minute. "I think your best asset is you." I whisper as we break apart, returning to the chair, where Poppy opts to sit on my lap rather than the arm of the chair.

"Okay, I need to fuck one or all of you before I explode." Sienna decides, reaching into her bag. "I thought we could make it a bit more fun, how about we draw straws?" She continues, revealing a bundle of straws in her hand. "There's two red and two blue straws, red fucks red, blue fucks blue, sound good?" She explains. The rest of us nod as we each reach for our own straw.

Honestly, out of the three of them, I know which one I want to fuck first today.

Who's number one?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)