Should Have Agreed

I stared at the sleek metal chastity cage swinging from Mia’s fingers, my heart slamming against my ribs. The entire room waited in heavy silence. I could feel sweat forming on the back of my neck.“Wait… hold on,” I said quickly, raising my hands. “I don’t think I can do this. Not in front of everyone. It’s too much. Maybe we can do something else? I’ll drink twice, take a dare, whatever. Just… not locking my dick up right here.”

Mia tilted her head, that dangerous smile never fading. “Aw, look at him trying to weasel out of it. You were so close to being brave.”

Sarah laughed softly. “Come on, it’s just a cage. Are you scared your cock won’t fit? Or are you scared it will?”Jake smirked. “Dude, you can’t back out now. The game’s already going.”I kept talking, trying to negotiate. “Seriously, Mia. I’m not ready for that level. Maybe later, in private? Or just hold the key without me wearing it tonight? I’ll do shots. I’ll streak. Anything else.”

Mia stepped even closer, dangling the cage inches from my face. “You had your chance to be the first. Now you are going to sit right there and watch what happens to boys who do accept the challenge.”

She turned to the rest of the group. “Any guy who puts this on for at least thirty minutes gets rewarded with a threesome. Two girls of his choice. Full access. No condoms. While our shy boy here watches and stays completely denied.”The energy in the room shifted instantly. Jake stood up first.“Fuck it. I’ll do it,” he said.Mia grinned. “Good boy. Pants down.”

Jake dropped his jeans and boxers. His cock was average, maybe five and a half inches hard. Mia easily slid the ring behind his balls and locked his dick into the cage. The click echoed. Jake winced slightly as it settled, but he was already breathing heavier.“Thirty minutes starts now,” Mia announced, hanging the key around her neck. “Sarah and Lena you two are his reward.”

Jake’s face lit up. Sarah and Lena wasted no time. They stripped him fully and pushed him onto the big couch. Sarah straddled his face, grinding her wet pussy against his mouth while Lena took his caged cock between her tits and teased him mercilessly.“Look at how hard he is trying to get hard in that tiny cage,” Lena laughed. She sucked on the bars, tonguing his trapped head while Jake moaned into Sarah’s pussy.

I sat there, fully dressed and untouched, watching my best friend eat pussy and get titfucked while locked. Sarah came on his face, then they switched. Lena rode his face while Sarah sank down on a thick dildo, teasing Jake that this was what a real cock felt like. After twenty-five minutes they finally unlocked him. His cock sprang free, rock hard and leaking. The girls immediately rewarded him.

Sarah mounted him reverse cowgirl so I had a perfect view of his cock stretching her. Lena sat on his face again. Jake fucked Sarah hard, groaning loudly as he thrust up into her. The wet slapping sounds and moans filled the room. He lasted maybe four minutes before he buried himself deep and came hard inside her, groaning like an animal. They kept using him until he came a second time down Lena’s throat.

I watched every second, my own cock throbbing painfully in my jeans, untouched.Next was Tyler. He accepted quickly, clearly turned on by what he had just seen. Mia locked him up. His cock was a little bigger than Jake’s, but still fit easily in the cage. His reward: Mia and Emma.They made him eat Mia’s pussy first while Emma sucked on the cage. Then they unlocked him and took turns riding his face and cock. Mia rode him cowgirl, moaning loudly about how eager he was compared to “the one who chickened out.” Tyler fucked both girls to orgasm before filling Emma’s pussy with a massive load while Mia sat on his face.

I stayed locked out of the fun, forced to watch every thrust, every moan, every creampie.

The third guy, Chris, was more nervous but the promise of a threesome won him over. Once caged, he got Sarah and Emma. They teased him ruthlessly while locked making him watch them 69 each other before unlocking him. Chris fucked Sarah doggy style while she ate Emma’s pussy. The room was filled with the sound of skin slapping skin and loud female orgasms. He came so hard inside Sarah that cum dripped down her thighs when he pulled out.

By the time the fourth guy took his turn, my cock was aching. I had been watching my friends get locked, rewarded, and drained by the girls for nearly two hours. Every time a new guy got unlocked and fucked the girls raw in front of me, the humiliation burned hotter. They kept glancing over at me, teasing.“Still glad you talked your way out?” Mia called over while riding Jake for a second round. “You could have been the first one getting double teamed.”I stayed silent, painfully hard, watching the orgy unfold. The girls made sure I had a front-row seat for every position, every moan, and every load pumped into them. They even made the guys pull out at the end sometimes so I could see the cum dripping from their pussies.

By the end of the night all the other guys had taken their turns in the cage and received their wild threesomes. I remained the only one who had refused — hard, denied, and throbbing with regret and arousal.Mia finally walked over to me, still flushed and leaking cum from multiple guys, and dangled the empty cage.“Still don’t want it?” she asked sweetly. “Or are you ready to finally lock up like the rest of them?”