Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 3
by
ManRayMansker
What's next?
Shocker
No one drank.
Then I took a slow sip.
The entire room went silent.The most macho guy in the group… and I had just admitted it.Mia’s mouth fell open.
“No fucking way. You? Mr. Tough Guy has worn a butt plug?”
Jake looked stunned. “You are messing with us, right?”
I stood up without saying a word, turned around, and lowered my pants just enough to show them the shiny bejeweled plug already seated between my cheeks. Gasps and shocked laughter filled the room.Mia recovered first and started laughing with pure delight.
“Oh my god. You have one in right now? That is the hottest plot twist ever.”
She stepped closer. “Since you are the only one and you came prepared, you are going to leave that pretty jeweled plug in while you tell us exactly how long you have been wearing it tonight. Then we get to play with the other plugs I brought and see how you handle bigger ones.”Mia held up a larger plug, eyes wide with excitement.“Are you going to keep showing off that sparkly plug in your ass… or let us switch it out for something bigger while everyone watches?”
Your move: Tell them how long you have been wearing it? Let them change the plug?
Try to regain your macho image?
What's next?
- No further chapters
- Add a new chapter
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
A Compilation Tale of Never Have I Ever
Play the game contributions welcome
Each Chapter is begging for you to take the challenge
Updated on Jun 27, 2026
by ManRayMansker
Created on Jun 27, 2026
by ManRayMansker
- 7 Likes
- 568 Views
- 3 Favorites
- 1 Bookmarks
- 26 Chapters
- 3 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.
Comments