Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4

What did the girl say?

She said, "Please don't stop"

Hannah goes on with her story, "That's when I realized she was actually enjoying what was happening. I was so hot. I was so wet. And then in an instant it stopped working for me. I realized that if she was enjoying herself, then I wasn't hurting her enough. And the only way to really make her unhappy was to just quit all of it."

You pull your cock out of Hannah's amazing ass, and she spins around, now positioning herself on top of you, one hand reaching down to grab your cock, the other reaching down to curl into her own slit.

"So I wiped my messy hands off in her hair, then got up and headed for the door. But she was being crazy and she followed me begging, saying 'please don't stop! please! please!'

She starts tugging at your throbbing cock, and starts finger fucking herself intensely. She seems so damn turned on recounting this story. And the way she's going you're pretty sure the story isn't ending even if it seems like it.

"I was at the door and she was right behind me, begging me to stay, being really pathetic and really annoying and I just turned around and said 'Fuck off!' and shoved her and she fell backwards hard into her closet. She grunted in pain. And the fact that I'd hurt her, like really genuinely hurt her, made me horny instantly again.

"I jumped down to the floor, kneeling between her open legs and was ready to go. 'Fine if you need another lesson, we might as well teach you to take a guy in every hole at the same time. You're definitely gonna do lots of that.' I wasn't entirely sure how I was going to do that, but then I saw in her closet, a bunch of shoes came spilling out of the door and I grabbed one with a thick heel and immediately shoved it into her asshole. She winced like a little bitch. I could tell she was really uncomfortable. So I got back to shoving one hand into her pussy and the other into her mouth.

"Her whole body flopped around under me, like a fish, it was so fucking hot. But I was also focused on how much noise she'd made when she fell to the ground. I thought for sure someone was going to come in and discover what I was doing. I wasn't sure what I'd do if that happened. I knew my only real play would be go hope the whole family was perverted and get them to join in, which was absolutely insane, but what else would I do? I figured her parents probably wouldn't be persuaded even though I did think her dad was a filthy old man. But my boyfriend, or rather ex-boyfriend, was always really into fucking me. If I told him that even though we were broken up we could keep fucking, and all he had to do was shut his mouth and hold down his sister, he'd have done it."

Hannah's lips quiver, her body is on fire, her hands work magic on your cock and her clit. You decide to just let her go without repositioning her any more. She's too lost in her story. And so are you.

"It didn't happen though. No one came. Except me. Thinking about it was so hot, I came a fourth time. Then I focused on the girl again. She was gagging a lot beneath me, but I made no attempt to pull my fingers out of her throat or my hand out of her cunt. 'Get used to it!' I said 'Boys are gonna pass you around at parties like your a cheap bottle of booze.' Hell, they may shove cheap bottles of booze inside you too.'

"I could feel her beneath me getting ready to cum, finally. Which was good because my hands were getting really fucking tired. But I knew it would be cruel to deny her so I said, 'You don't have permission to cum!' and I could see desperation in her eyes. 'Not until you apologize' I added.

"She made a noise so I pulled my fingers out of her throat and she said, 'I'm sorry I was so mean to you.'

"'Not for that' I said, I was just making it up as I went along, but I could. In that moment it was like my throbbing clit knew exactly what to do better than my brain did. 'Apologize for being a virgin' I said. 'Why the fuck are you even a virgin? Is it because you're rich and pretty and think you're too good for boys to use like trash?'

"'I don't know' she said.

"'Well you're not. Say it' I felt so mean. It was amazing.

"'I'm not too good'

"'Then fucking apologize!

"'I'm sorry!

"'Good!' I said. 'You'll never see me again after this week. But every time you give your body to some guy who doesn't respect you, you're going to think of the girl who taught you the truth about yourself.' It wasn't even a question. It was just the truth and I could see in her eyes that she knew it.

"She came. I came. And it was over. At least until I went back to my room and rubbed myself off and came a sixth time."

Speaking of cumming, you're about ready. But to the extent that you can focus on anything, you realize something she said doesn't line up.

"I thought you said you came seven times?" You ask.

"Yeah... mmmmm.... I guess the seventh time wasn't until the next day. She was hurt so bad they had to go to the doctor. It wasn't a big deal. She just sprained her ankle in the fall. But when I saw her on crutches with it all wrapped up and knew that I'd legitimately hurt her, I ran into the bathroom and rubbed myself off almost immediately."

Your girlfriend, in addition to being beautiful, and smart, and caring, is a complete freak. You jizz all over her hand.

Hannah, as promised, does not cum. Even though she clearly enjoys reliving the story. You realize what she says is probably true. The only way for her to achieve orgasm is to do it for real. And the revelation brings you back to the insanity of your reality.

"So that's the sort of thing you want me to do with you?" You ask.

"Yes." Hannah answers immediately. "At least that. Maybe worse. Sometimes I think back on that night and feel like I took it too easy on her. But the thing is, it's been so long, and I've come to realize that I can't go the rest of my life without cumming," A very serious, piercing look from Hannah now, "I want you to do this with me because I love you and I want you to be a part of all parts of me. But if it's too much for you, I understand. But I still need to be able to do it by myself. I can come back to you and tell you the stories, and it'd be hot. But I realize that I can't go without it. And if that's a deal breaker, I'm so sorry, but I need it."

So now you have a choice. You can do this with her, which might very well ruin you and put you in jail if things go poorly. You can tell her it's okay for her to do it without you and report back, and that becomes part of your sex life. Or you can break up.

It's hard to contemplate. Especially just moments after learning your entire world is set to become more perverted than you could have ever imagined.

What do you decide?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)