She's uncertain

It takes almost a minute for her orgasm to subside. I've always been surprised at how completely my pretty tenant lets herself go with each climax, but this is even more **** than most. I have to concentrate on keeping my fingers in place as she jerks and writhes out her climax. Only after she finally collapses onto the counter do I slowly twist my finger free from her tightly clenched ass.

"Wow." The single word slips from her mouth in a tentative whimper. "I can't believe you did that." To be honest, I'm a little surprised myself. Fran and I had only played a little with anal sex, until today I'd never done more than rub or lick the tight ring of my wife as I fingered her pussy so to have a finger deep up inside Alison's ass was a new experience for me too. Certainly, the intensity of her climax caught me by surprise.

"I'm sorry if I went too far, Honey." I start my awkward apology. The last thing I want to do is screw up this strange arrangement we have worked out. To a religiously raised young woman like Alison, sodomy carries a whole extra load of sinfulness in its taboo.

Alison pushes herself off the counter and turns slowly in my arms; as she pulls down her skirt it is hard to read the expression on her face, but she wraps her arms around my neck and pulls your firm body against mine as she rises to her toes so she can whisper in my ear.

"I guess that sassy little tease had it coming to her." I am relieved that Alison has dropped the role-playing for now and return her hug gently before I loosen my grip, so she does not feel trapped.

"We don't have to do anything like that again, Angel. Fran never liked me playing back there, so it's not like something I expect from you."

"I felt so dirty, Mr. P." Alison clearly is as confused by her response to my fingering her ass as she was by her experimentation with the **** fantasies we had been exploring last week. "I don't think I'm ready to have sex that way ... is that OK?" I had to laugh at her sweet hesitation. If nothing else, I'm going to teach this lovely young woman that what she wants to do with her body is always OK. The last thing I want is for her to end up with an asshole like 'Dick' again.

"Of course it's OK, it's what you want." With my easy acceptance of her request, I feel the innocent coed relax against my chest pressing her face against me as I rock her in my arms.

"I came so hard." The whisper is so muffled I almost don't hear it, but then she lifts her face and cups my cheek with her hand. "When you started probing me like that, pretending to search for **** I wanted to hate it, but you made me feel so good." I brush away a single tear that is forming in the corner of her left eye, and the gesture seems to help her relax even more.

"I have to figure out what Miss Miller's reaction to you making her cum like that will be, Mr. P." It seems that while Alison is not ready for me to fill her ass, she is more than willing to continue playing out my fantasy of fucking a sassy tease. "I doubt any of her past lovers pushed her into a climax like that before ... you may be on your way to taming that girl."

"I hope I didn't completely break her spirit." I chuckle softly as I give Alison a final squeeze before stepping back from the counter. "Even as hard as she's made my life this past week, I've kinda grown to like the defiant little tease."

"Oh, don't worry about that," Alison stepped away from the counter and bent over to pick up her red panties from the floor giving me a coy grin as she sees me checking out her ass. "Now that your 'bad girl' knows what a sick bastard you are she just has to be a little more careful in her teasing." With that she flounced from the kitchen with an extra wiggle to her ass that sends her skirt in every direction. It takes all my willpower not to follow the tease right up to her room.