She's uncertain and a little scared

Grace whimpers softly as you finger her, her eyes flickering between Valerie's bobbing head and Brian's feral grin, then looking up to you, biting her lip uncertainly.

"I don't know...I'm a little scared..." she says softly. "Will it hurt? It hurt when you...you used my ass last night...for a while, til I got used to it...but both of you? Two of you...I'm not sure..."

"No one's forcing you Grace," you tell her, gently pressing your thumb against her rosebud and making her squirm.

"Yeah, no problem," Brian grunts. "This brat loves to take cocks up her ass, don't you Val?" He gives her rump a resounding smack as he thrusts deep in her cunt, making her give a muffled squeal around your cock. Her eyes roll up, looking at you and Grace, her eyelids flickering as her head bobs.

"It's your call," you say softly, easing your thumb into her anus, feeling her stiffen as you impale her with fingers and thumb.

"Oh God...you're making me crazy...I want to please you sir, Mr. Carter...I want to...oh God my tummy's fluttering...Valerie...she did it? Really?"

The brunette squirms her mouth of your shaft and looks up panting.

"I took both my Daddies...both of their cocks...up my holes...I came...came so fucking hard...so full...so fucking full..."

"She a cock loving anal brat, aren't you Val?" Brian growls, slapping her ass again for emphasis.

"Yes Daddy...your good girl anal brat...oh God Daddy! Daddy! I'm coming again Daddy! Coming on your cock!" she wails, cutting off her own cries as she gobbles your meat down, sucking in a frenzy of need.

"Better decide quick," you groan. "Before she sucks all the seed out of me and I have none left for you."

"Yeah," Brian grunts. "All this talk and I'm hot to DP somebody. Who's it gonna be Red? You or the brat?"