Sex and Wanting More

Xander watched as Buffy fingerfucked his girlfriend. It was incredibly hot. Cordelia’s head was rolled back as Buffy used her Slayer powers to thrust her fingers in as fast she could.

Meanwhile, Faith was on her knees giving him a blowjob. It was an ideal situation for any man.

But something was off.

At first it was how aggressive Buffy was with Cordelia. Then it was hearing Buffy telling her that she was going to fuck her cunt so hard that even his dick wouldn’t be good enough. That had got him concerned, but Cordy seemed into it, so he hadn’t said anything.

Then when he was about to cum in Faith’s mouth, Buffy had literally pushed the dark haired Slayer out of the way and took his cock into her mouth.

This had led to the two of them fighting, which led to Buffy pulling out of all things a double headed dildo and the two Slayers fucking back against each other while Xander stroked himself hard.

Whatever rules the two of them had, Buffy apparently won, and Faith said she was headed out on patrol. Meanwhile Buffy laid back on Cordelia’s bed and spread her legs. “Come on Xander, come own my pussy with that freakish dick of yours.”

Xander approached her slowly. It was hard to take his eyes off her shaved cunt displayed for him. She was making begging whimpers of need as he took his time. She didn’t seem to mind that her body was halfway on top of Cordelia’s sleeping form.

Part of him was telling him that he really needed to talk this out, but he couldn’t resist what he was seeing. He moved forward and sank himself inside of her.

“Yes,” Buffy whispered in his ear. “So good, my pussy is perfect for your cock.”

He began to thrust inside of her as she kept whispering, “Cordelia can’t take you this deep. Neither can Faith. I’ll never be able to feel another man, Xander. No one else. Angel couldn’t hope to bring me this pleasure.”

This was the first time she had mentioned Angel since his soul had been restored. Xander knew that Buffy and Angel had a talk, and then the vampire left town. They had gone a few days without any type of sex, but Buffy had announced that she really wanted an orgy and they were happy to oblige.

Buffy tightly wrapped her legs around him, “You’re the only man for me Xander. No other man. You can fuck whoever you want, I don’t care who you use this cock on, but you are mine.”

Her legs began to squeeze him tighter, “Tell me you’re mine, Xander.”

Xander gasped for air, “Buffy, you’re going too tight.”

She loosened her grip, “Then fuck me for being a bad girl.”

“Okay,” Xander agreed, confused. Now that he had room he began to speed up his thrusts.

She closed her eyes as she rode out an orgasm, “Are you close?” she whispered.

“So close,” Xander said back. “Going to cum inside you.”

“Yes, fill my pussy up,” she said as she tightened her legs again. “I stopped taking birth control, Xand. Put a baby inside me.”

“Fuck!” Xander said, the thought simultaneously terrifying and arousing him. He used all his willpower to hold back from cumming while he put all of his strength to push back against Buffy’s legs.

He barely made it in time, his cum spraying out across her belly.

She released him as he collapsed to the floor, “Oh, well, maybe it’s enough,” she said.

-

Xander found Buffy standing out by the pool. Naked, his cum still coating her body.

“We need to talk,” Xander told her, “about consent. About Angel. About us.”

She ran a hand over her belly, “We don’t need to talk. You just need to tell me you love me.”

He walked up and put his hands on her shoulders, “Buffy, I love you. You know that. I always have.”

She looked up at him hopefully, “Tell me you love me more than Cordelia.”

He let his hands drop, “You know I can’t do that.”

“So I’m just used goods then.”

“Buff, you love Angel.”

Buffy laughed, “I do. It’s sad that I do. The problem is I spent the last couple months convincing myself how pathetic he was. I’m addicted to sex, and he is fucking awful at it.”

“We could…” Xander began, but he honestly wasn’t sure what he was going to suggest.

“I want more than the sex,” Buffy explained. “I want a family. A house, white picket fence, all of that. A child. Love. And…I also want the sex. Angel could only give me some of that. You…you could give me everything.”

“You know I’d jump in front of a train for you.”

Buffy shook her head, “That’s what makes it hurt more. You love me. I know that. But you also love Cordelia. What would you do for me that you wouldn’t do for her?”

Xander had no answer for her question.

“I need some time,” Buffy told him as she turned away. “Try and figure out what to do. It hurts Angel too much to be around me, and it hurts me too much to be around you.”

“Okay. I’ll be here, Buff, whenever you need me,” Xander said as she walked away.

He was so stunned by everything that had happened that it took him a few minutes to realize she had left completely naked.