Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 21 by cphi cphi

What's next?

Saving your nut for your baby girl....

"Oh...fuuuck....Mr. S.... mmmm...." Leah moans, neglecting Riley's pussy as you pound her.
"It's James, Leah my dear. And don't stop..." you push her head down onto Riley's cunt. Riley squeals as Leah eats her out, and you rub Riley's knee as you drill deep into her friend's hole. Riley smiles. She's starting to get over her annoyance. You pull her leg up over Leah's shoulder, and suck on her toes as you fuck. Riley moans so lewdly.
"Daddy...how did you knoooooowww......" she squeezes her eyes shut.
"I know...my...baby...girl...." you punctuate each word with a thrust. Leah's becoming incoherent between you, and you have to admit, she's basically just a fleshlight right now. You and Riley are staring into each other's eyes. This is your baby angel. There's no one in the world you love more, not even her mother, and now... now you're love truly knows no boundaries. It's so fucked up. And you find that you can't get enough of it.
"Fuck...James....I'm....ahhhhh!!!!!" Leah stars panting frenziedly. Her cunt tightens and quivers and you pound her faster and faster as your own nut approaches.
"I'm...I'm getting close..."
"You can...inside...I don't mind..." she's panting, eyes closed, and cheek flat on the mattress.
Riley shoots you a worried look, but you smile at her, and roll Leah out of the way. "I'm sorry Leah... but this is for my baby girl..."
Riley looks like she's going to cry from joy as you plunge your cock inside her, locking lips on hers and kissing her with all the love you have.
"Mmmmm...." when you break away, you can feel it coming.
"Give it to me daddy..."
Leah appears at your shoulder, stroking Riley's cheek and rubbing your back.
"Here it comes, angel..." you hilt, and Riley cries as you feel the cum start to pulse into her.
Please log in to view the image
"Dadddyyy......!!!!!!" She arches her back and bucks against you, trying to milk your cock as is spurts your cum into her.
You collapse next to her, panting. You feel Leah's lips lock around your cock, cleaning and draining you as your orgasm washes away. Riley's crying, her face pressed into you shoulder.
"Baby? Are you okay?" You stroke her hair.
"I never...I never dreamed...." she sniffles. "Every day...feeling like there was something wrong with me. Ashamed of my fantasy..." she looks into your eyes. "But...you love me... just the way I needed to be... even though it's.... "wrong," I knew you loved me more than anything. I'm so happy daddy. Your cum is actually filling me up with warmth. I can't believe it..and I couldn't be happier..." she hugs your arm, snuggling against it like she's 12. "I'm the luckiest girl in the world."
"I love you baby. No matter what. This is really weird...but I love you."
"Awww...." Leah is shaking her hair out, pulling on a pair of panties. "You two are so cute. I guess I'm fucked up, too." She smiles. "Take your time. And...if you ever need a love nest... just text me." she winks as she leaves the room.
"Hmmm....." Riley hums thoughtfully. You sigh. Damn it. This... isn't going to be a one-time thing, huh?
You clean up, and head out first, telling Riley you'll see her at home. You roll into the driveway at 2:35 PM.

Anyone home?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)