Rules 13 - Pandora's Box

As the night went on, Jeremy did his best to act normal and make small talk. Thirty minutes passed, then an hour, then two. The night was growing later, and guests began to say their goodbyes. Jeremy smiled politely as the numbers dwindled, making up an endless amount of excuses for Sage's absence. Another hour passed. Jeremy said goodbye to the last guests. Left only with his thoughts, Jeremy began to imagine what was happening upstairs. As the last of the guests exited his home, Jeremy sat down on the couch and checked the time.

It was twelve a.m., three hours since Sage went upstairs with Theo. Three fucking hours. Jeremy was having a hard time believing that Theo could have been going that long. At least, Jeremy had to admit to himself he couldn't have gone that long. It made him feel small. Jeremy imagined all the ways Theo was taking Sage. He could see Sage’s back arched as Theo plowed into her, he could hear her moans of ecstasy as Theo came inside her. He wondered how many rounds the two had gone, and how many times Theo had made Sage cum.

He checked his phone again, it was one in the morning. He ran his fingers through his hair, his eyes growing heaving with fatigue. Thoughts and nerves could only satisfy for so long. Jeremy wanted the night to be over, he wanted to sleep in his bed. But most importantly, he wanted to be with Sage. He wanted to hear how much she loved getting fucked, before he got to have her the rest of the night. The thought of punishing Sage after such a long fuck session made Jeremy smirk, and as if he had willed it into existence, Jeremy felt his phone vibrate.

It was one message from Sage, short and to the point.

Sage: Come upstairs.

That was it, no video, no flirtation, just a simple command. Jeremy sat frozen staring at the message, hoping that the longer he looked at it, some sense of what was happening would come to light. Jeremy half hoped some kind of follow-up text would follow, but none came. He heard the door to the master bedroom open and close, and Jeremy stood promptly, looking to the stairs to see if Theo would appear, but when no one did, Jeremy took a breath and made his way over to the stairs. As he ascended to the second floor, surprised to find the door to the bedroom opening once again. Theo stepped into the hallway. He was a sweaty disheveled mess. His hair was matted back with sweat, and his eyes were sunken in with exhaustion. He looked at Jeremy nervously and gave a nod as Jeremy approached him.

“H-hey Jeremy… we’re all wrapped up.” Theo’s overly friendly tone made Jeremy’s skin crawl.

“Uh-huh…” He said through clenched teeth.

Theo swallowed nervously, “Look I just want to say that-”

“Get the fuck out of my house,” Jeremy said coldly, walking past Theo without even a glance. He didn’t care what kind of power trip Theo was having, he didn’t care what he had done with Sage. He just wanted Theo out of his house.

“R-right,” Theo cleared his throat. “But I just wanted to say…”

“Are you fucking deaf?” Jeremy asked, turning to look at the frail-looking fuckboy. “I don’t care what you have to say. The play session is over. As far as I’m concerned, you don’t fucking exist. So take your win while you still can, and get out before I make a few calls to get you fired.”

Whatever courage Theo had over the phone was rapidly evaporating. Jeremy couldn’t help but smile as he saw fear enter his eyes.

“That’s right,” Jeremy said, “Now you’re starting to get it. Playtime is over, you’re back in the real world Theo. Start acting like it.”

“R-right… well, I guess I’ll be seeing you then. And uh… thank you?” Theo gave a short nod as he turned and made his way down the stairway. As soon as he was out of sight, Jeremy made his way to the bedroom door, his hand shaking slightly as he opened it.

The smell of body odor and sex hung in the air. He wasn’t sure what he expected to find on the other side of the door, but when he stepped into the bedroom, it was both exactly what he was expecting and not at all what he could have imagined. He saw Sage laying naked on the bed covered in sweat and cum. Her stomach, her face, her pussy, her entire body was glistening with Theo’s seed. Her hair was matted with sweat, her makeup smeared on her face, mixing with cum as it dripped onto the bedsheets. As Jeremy watched Sage take in slow breaths, a simple thought churned his stomach over. Sage had just been fucked by the man he hated, longer and harder than they had ever fucked each other.

Sage opened her eyes, smiling when she saw Jeremy standing in the bedroom’s entrance.

“Hey…” She said softly.

“Hey,” Jeremy replied, a smile forming over his face. “You ok?” Sage nodded, raising her arm and beckoning him over to her.

“Come here…” She said, Jeremy obeyed at once, hesitating a moment as his hands hovered over Sage’s wet and naked body. He touched her skin, feeling the mixture of sweat and cum stick to his hand.

“You guys fucked for a long time,” Jeremy said. He wasn’t sure if it was the right thing to say, but at this point, he knew it didn't really matter what he said. Sage nodded slowly.

“He couldn’t stop fucking me,” She said gently. “He fucked me like an animal, he took every hole and made them his. He came in me so much.”

Jeremy felt a familiar flush through his face, his cock becoming hard. “And you liked it?” He asked. Sage nodded.

“I loved it.” She whispered. Jeremy couldn’t contain himself, his hand instinctively went for Sage’s clit, as his fingers touched the thick mixture of cum and juices on her lips, Sage flinched in response. “Oh! Be careful baby… I’m really sore and sensitive right now.”

“Shit, sorry,” Jeremy said, pulling his hand away and bringing it to her chest. Her body was shivering from post-ecstasy.

“You want me too, don’t you?” Sage asked. Jeremy nodded.

“I want you more than anything right now.” Jeremy leaned in for a kiss, and Sage kissed back passionately. He could taste salt, he felt the slick foreign substance of another man on her lips. He pulled away from her cum covered face.

“I’m a bad girl,” Sage said.

“I know,” Jeremy replied.

“I want to keep doing this Jeremy. I want to keep being used like this. But not for them, for you.” Sage said, wrapping her arms around Jeremy’s neck.

“I know Sage.” Jeremy didn't need Sage's confession to know she was hooked on this lifestyle. He knew they had opened Pandora’s box, and there was no putting Sage back inside.

“Do you still want this? Do you still like it when I let other men fuck me? When I let them use me like a fuck toy?” Sage asked.

“You know I do,” Jeremy said. Sage rubbed her finger along her body, collecting an ample amount of cum before putting it into Jeremy’s mouth. He hesitated upon tasting the salty thick substance but swallowed as Sage pushed her finger deeper into his mouth.

“Even when it’s torturing?” Sage asked. Jeremy pulled Sage's finger out of his mouth.

“Yes,” Jeremy said. It was these moments Jeremy lived for. This safe space of coming back to his wife, and knowing that despite everything she did with other men, she was his at the end of the day.

“I don’t tell you everything you know,” Sage said, lining hips up with Jeremy’s and slowly undoing his belt.

“I know, I figured it was bound to start happening,” Jeremy replied.

“I don’t want to tell you everything… I want you to always wonder who it is I’m actually fucking.” Sage pulled Jeremy’s pants down, and he happily lined his throbbing cock with her slick entrance.

“Just promise me one thing, Sage.”

“Anything.”

“Promise me, that no matter what, we will always be in this together. Promise me that so long as we do this as a couple, we stay a couple. Be honest about how you're feeling, because if we do keep doing this. I need to know you love me, that you truly love me. As soon as that changes…”

“That won’t change,” Sage said, wrapping her legs around Jeremy’s waist and squeezing tightly. Jeremy couldn’t contain himself, he pushed himself into Sage slowly, causing her to moan softly before she continued. “I promise, I will always love you. This was always for you, for us. That will never change.”

Jeremy's heart raced as his slow thrusts began to quicken slowly.

“Slowly…” Sage said. “Go slow.”

Jeremy obliged, pumping in and out of Sage with a slow, intimate pace. He could feel Theo's cum coating his cock, he could feel it dripping out of Sage with every thrust. She was already thoroughly used, and Jeremy was only getting the leftovers.

He loved every minute of it.

“You can cum inside if you like,” Sage said, keeping her legs tightly wrapped around Jeremy’s waist. Jeremy imagined if Sage had done the same for Theo. He envisioned Theo fucking her with all his might, pushing his long cock into her until she was delusional. But Jeremy wouldn’t fuck her like that, because what they had was special. What they had was different. He moved gently, wrapping his arms around her as he found himself ready to cum in just a few minutes.

“Fuck Sage, I love you,” Jeremy said breathlessly.

“I love you too baby, now cum for me,” Sage whispered into his ear. Jeremy’s body tensed, and he felt cum erupt deep inside Sage. “That’s it baby, cum in me. Fill me up.”

“Fuck Sage!” Jeremy said as he slammed his cock deep into Sage’s loose pussy.

Sage pet Jeremy’s hair, keeping her legs wrapped around him tightly as his cock slowly pulsed inside her. “I will always love you, Jeremy. Even if that means I need to **** you from time to time… I will always love you.”

“And I will always love you,” Jeremy said, embracing Sage as his cock went soft. He felt his hot cum mixing with Theo’s, a final addition to the aggressive fuck session he only knew a fraction about. The two held each other for a long while after that, enjoying the embrace of two lovers.

Hope you guys have enjoyed the story so far! If you like my work, consider supporting me on Patreon to get early access to stories and chapters. Happy reading!

patreon.com/mrjakobs