Round two

"Now I want the two of you to change positions," she said with a grin. "It's time for Alan to be the bottom."

I wanted to be shocked or even insulted, but I wasn't. Part of me wanted to make Amy happy. Another part of me just wanted David to fuck me hard and raw. I turned over on my hands and knees with my ass up, locking eyes with her.

David moved into position behind me, and then I felt his hot breath on my ass. He gently parted my cheeks with his hands. Then I felt his warm, wet tongue slide over my asshole. I moaned slightly at the sensation.

"Thats right," Amy said. "Now tell me you aren't a secret little sissy bitch that likes cock. You can't wait for David to slide into your ass, can you?"

"No," I admitted.

David was practically french kissing my asshole now.

"Tell him what you want."

"Oh god, David, please fuck me," I begged. "Fuck me hard."

"Anything for you, baby," he said, and then positioned himself behind me. I felt the pressure of his cock against my ass. "It'll only hurt a little."

I maintain eye contact with Amy as David slowly slid his cock into my ass. Her eyes seemed to twinkle with each grunt and moan that escaped me. My new gay lover was very gentle, taking several minutes to bury himself all the way into my ass.

"Oh shit you feel so good," he moaned. David slowly started to fuck my ass and I was surprised to find myself enjoying it. There was a little pain, but there was a lot more pleasure.

I was trying to process it all; David's profession of love, Amy's **** attempt and the fact that I was enjoying sex with another guy as much as I enjoyed sex with girls. Maybe more. None of it made sense with the images I had in my head for my life. I wasn't gay. I didn't find men, even David, attractive, yet his cock and ass were better than Kate's pussy....

"I'm gonna cum," he moaned, and then his whole body tensed. I felt a rush of warmth deep inside me. He kept thrusting, emptying his balls inside my ass.

When he was spent, he let his cock slip out of my ass, and for just a minute I felt empty.

David slid down next to me and pulled me to him, kissing me hungrily. I couldn't help myself, I kissed him back. That lip lock went on for several minutes, and although I didn't want to admit it, it was the hottest kiss of my life.

"I love you, Alan, I really do," he said when we finally broke apart.