Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 14

Does he go through with it?

Hell Yes

I felt all notions of right and wrong leave me in that moment, felt all of my thoughts begin to fade in a haze of lust as I drank in David’s lithe form. Sure, I was at a party and there was a very real chance someone could notice we were missing and come looking for us...but really, nothing else mattered beyond me fucking David.

With Amy’s help I rid myself of clothes quickly and moved between David’s open legs, eyeing off his puckered ass. In that moment it looked like the most inviting thing I had ever seen. Slowly I lifted my gaze up and my eyes met David’s. I leaned over him and kissed him with a suddenness that shocked even me. His mouth opened at once and our tongues battled for dominance while he threw his arms around me, clinging to me.

I ground my cock against his, delighting in the little sounds he made before finally taking up position and moving the crown of my dick against his hole. I looked him right in the eye as I entered, and was rewarded with the warmest and tightest sensation I had ever felt.

Almost instinctively his legs wrapped around me, pulling me further in. I started off slow, but the tightness of his ass was just too great and I couldn’t help but increasing the pace and strength of each thrust, sawing in and out of him like a machine.

“Ugghhhh...my ass feels so full,” he moaned, kissing along my shoulder as I rammed away inside of him. The whole time he hadn’t let go of me. “You feel...so amazing ...inside me...Christ Alan!”

We kissed again, his ass pushing back to greet my dick. There was a **** to it, a strange kind of animal passion that I couldn’t describe. I felt as if my brain short circuited.

And all the while, I could feel Amy’s breath against my ear, hear her playing with herself as she watched us. “He’s good, isn’t she?” She whispered, “a perfect little bitch for you to fuck into the ground...”

David held me tight against him, his ass contracting around me aggressively. “Oh fuck,” he groaned as I pounded his prostate, “ohhh, ohhh...OHH FUCK!”

He came, spurting over my abs, but his ass did not let go and he seemed determined to cling to me as I ravaged him.

“Isn’t he perfect?” Amy said, nibbling my ear, “I bet he’s a better fuck than Katie, isn’t he?”

Something about her words had me going. I couldn’t exactly describe it, but a part of me agreed with her. I think I had genuine feelings for Kate, but David was so utterly submissive, so willing. His body seemed to have been made entirely to take my cock.

“Imagine,” she whispered her voice getting more and more erratic as she worked her clit harder, “if David was your girlfriend.”

It was such a strange phrase, but the words did the trick and I found my release. With David holding me so tightly, I had nowhere else to cum but deep in his ass. Beside me, I could feel a splatter as Amy worked herself to completion. We lay there together, we three. Tangled and sweaty, stinking of sex.

David kissed me again, smiled up at me demurely. “I love you so much Alan,”

“And I bet he loved you too,” Amy replied before I had the chance to, “and that’s why you’re going to keep having these little rendezvous.” She turned to me, grinned her cat-like grin, and whispered, “because if you don’t, I’m going to tell the whole thing to everyone.”

What comes next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)