Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 15 by Cross C Cross C

What happens next?

Rings are figured out, they make it to Fairy Tail, and sex.

We were still on the train to Magnolia when I remarked, “So I've got these rings that Bora guy was using...”

Beside me, Lucy smiled and leaned affectionately against me as she enthused, “I'm glad! I feel a lot better with them in your hands than that creep!”

Natsu stuck his head back in the cabin to exclaim with one raised fist, “Why'd we hand that bastard off to those Army bastards anyway?! I owed that imposter an epic beating!”

“Hey!” interjected Happy, “The Army gave us a commendation for our use of restraint in capturing the criminals! That's a Fairy Tail first!”

Natsu grumbled, “S'not right, I tell you. We've got a reputation to maintain.” And then abruptly he looked sick again, “Train! Still on it...ugh...”

And he was puking out the window again.

I shook my head in a mix of sympathy and confusion for the guy and continued my question even as I laid a hand on the inside of Lucy's thigh, enjoying her smooth luscious flesh as well as my unquestioned right to touch her there, “How do magic rings like these work, Lucy? I mean- I put them on back on the yacht and I sort of felt the spells in my head. So I cast them but then ever since I've got nothing. What do you think? Are these things empty now?”

“Oh!” She grinned and I could tell she liked explaining stuff to me. Probably because it made her feel smart. Which considering she was smart only made sense, “I'm no expert but they're probably out of magic power. Most magic items can soak in magic through the world around them just like mages can. However, unless they've been constructed to maximize their potential for this then they recharge pretty slowly. But that's usually not a problem for wearable items as they can just soak up magic power from the person who's wearing them.”

I nodded in understanding, “Okay. So since I'm such a low powered mage...” We'd talked about this yesterday. Lucy knew I wasn't actually a mage but thanks to earrings had no problem going along with the ruse in front of the others, “... it takes forever for them to recharge but Bora was able to constantly keep them charged from his own stocks of magic power?”

Happy spoke up before Lucy could, “Aye! It's also pretty impressive you could successfully use them on your first try. Mind magic usually takes a lot of skill and practice, not to mention you have to overcome the will of the person you're casting it on! That's really tough!”

“Oh really? I didn't know that.” remarked Lucy and I thought about it for a moment. I wondered if that had something to do with the earrings. Like maybe the way people didn't really put up a fight when I physically attacked them they also didn't try to resist my charm and sleep spells. Huh. I really could be pretty useful as long as I didn't get carried away.

I took off my rings and held them out to Lucy, “So do you mind wearing these to recharge them faster?”

Lucy smiled and nodded before suddenly looking ****. “The sleep ring... no problem but... I'm not sure it would be a good idea for me to wear the charm ring. I could get arrested!”

Well, that wasn't good. The last thing I wanted was to get Lucy in trouble. Maybe I'd have to let the charm ring recharge on its own-no, wait- “Don't worry about it, Lucy. Its normal to not be arrested for wearing illegal magic items, you only get in trouble when you use them on people.”

My girlfriend's face relaxed, “Oh! That's right! Here.” She took them from me and slipped them on to her fingers.

I grinned my thanks and slid my hand further up her thigh to gently rub her panty covered mound. This produced a predictable reaction in my pants and it wasn't long before I was making out with Lucy as I enthusiastically fondled her big boobs.

“Oh!” exclaimed Happy from across the cabin, “You guys are mating again?”

Again, I wasn't particularly bothered by the audience. I actually kind of liked it for some reason and I knew it turned Lucy on, so I gave the small blue cat a thumbs up not bothering to look as I rubbed my face gleefully in Lucy's bountiful cleavage.

“Najato?” Lucy's voice was quivering a bit with passion and I stopped slobbering on her tits long enough to look up and she continued, “Before we get carried away. Do you mind terribly if we don't have uh....full on sex?” She looked embarrassed and apologetic as she admitted, “I'm still pretty sore from last night.”

I was appalled, “I hurt you?! Oh no. I am too big, aren't I?” Damn it! And it wasn't like she'd have refused me thanks to my earrings. Shit. I felt terrible. Justifiably because I'd hurt her and rather less so, that this meant I couldn't just have sex with lots and lots of women.

Lucy grabbed my face and kissed me quickly before she pulled back and firmly spoke, “No! That's not it at all, Najato! I loved last night! You were amazing! Sex with you was way better than anything I've ever had before. Your cock is huge and I love it! You did me so deep! Its going to take my body some time to get used to it though. And honestly, I doubt I'll ever be up for more than once a day. Its just too good...”

I was pretty relieved to hear that but also kind of dismayed cause I knew I'd want sex with her more than that. On days off from work with nothing better to do, I'd spent entire days in my room just jerking off. To say I had a strong libido was an understatement. Something of this must have shown on my face because Lucy reached over and rubbed my bulge, “Don't look like that! You know... everyday could be your birthday with me and...” she was silent for a long moment, blushing. She shot an uncomfortable glance at a wide eyed Happy watching us with rapt attention before she leaned in to whisper in my ear, “Um... If you could find a willing girl who was pretty and uh... didn't mind me um... I wouldn't mind if you rocked her world with this fat massive cock!”

I sat back, aroused beyond relief by her admission and feeling a manic enthusiasm that Lucy actually wanted me to fuck other women. I noticed her nipples were standing at attention through her top and I couldn't resist, “Oh look at these, Happy.” I hooked my fingers into her sleeveless blouse and the cups of her bra to pull it all down. Lucy gasped a bit as her boobs came into full view and then again as I tugged at her thick thimble nipples. I grinned, “Doesn't Lucy just have the best jugs in all of Fiore?!”

Happy blinked, “I don't know, Najato. But they sure look full of milk! You could feed like ten litters of kittens with those things!”

“Don't say things like that!” demanded Lucy and then shuddered as my hands upon her breasts used what they'd learned last night to make her squirm and moan.

I was really aroused and seriously in need of busting a nut, however despite the sexy beauty before me, I found my thoughts returning to those assuredly stuck up ladies up in First Class. Additionally, the tiny part of my brain not soaked through with lust wanted to give it another try breaking the truth to Lucy about the earrings.


It went really well. Mostly because I'd done the explaining with the earrings still on. Okay, I was a coward and I probably didn't deserve Lucy. But I was absolutely afraid of losing her too and this would have to be enough for my apparently rather corrupt conscience.

Lucy wasn't perturbed in the slightest as we stood in the front of one of the first class cars, far enough away from anyone so we couldn't be overheard. “So like you said before, your earrings are magic items that make everyone you encounter believe that everything you do is perfectly normal and acceptable?”

“Pretty much. I wouldn't say the effect is perfect but yea, that's the gist. So you believe me?”

She nodded, “Well, yea. It seems pretty uh...” She smiled ruefully, “I was going to say normal but I guess that’s the earrings, isn't it?”

“Yep. So uh.... looking back at everything that's happened between us uh... what do you think? I mean- keep in mind I didn't even realize this until right before Bora's party you know when I tried to tell you about them before and you didn't believe me.”

Lucy reached out and rubbed my upper arm, “Its okay, Najato. I'm really glad you tried to tell me before and that you're doing it now. It just shows how much I can really trust you.”

I knew why she was taking this so well but I didn't care. This would have to be good enough, “So uh... you don't mind me wearing them around you still? I mean... I can do whatever I want to you and you're fine with it even if you wouldn't have been if I wasn't wearing the earrings. Like back there when I pulled your top down in front of Natsu and Happy.”

She continued to smile at me warmly as she gently shook her head, “Nope. I kind of have to twist my thoughts a little but I can just kind of see how that would be an issue... but Najato. I liked that. I really enjoy what we have and I think it would be a real shame if I missed out just because I was weirdly hung up on what you can and can not do.” Lucy was silent for a moment before a somewhat naughty look crossed her face, “Besides... I'm kind of excited at the thought of everything you can do. I mean- do you realize you can just have sex with anybody?”

I smirked, “That might have occurred to me...”

Lucy covered her mouth with one hand and made a show of being coy, “And I can watch...”

I grabbed her hand and pulled her towards the haughty finely dressed occupants of the car, “You can do more than watch.”


Cana lounged with her back against the bar, intending to do absolutely nothing today but wallow in luxuriant inebriation. She was particularly determined because she'd had to spend the majority of her drinking time yesterday pulling Macao's ass out of trouble on a godamned freezing-mountain. Damn that guy and damn his little progeny Romeo for whining so much she felt **** to go ahead and take care of it rather than have him continue to harsh her buzz with his incessant prattle about his missing daddy.

Hmmph... When was the last time she'd seen her father? Yea, you didn't hear her moaning about it all the time.

She opened her throat and downed the entire mug of beer in seconds.

Still, she was glad Macao was alright even if she didn't see how he'd let himself get Taken Over by a stupid horny ape. Beating nineteen monsters didn't count for nothing if you got beat by the twentieth.

The man in question was sitting nearby embellishing his story for the third time this hour with Wakaba and a hand full of other layabouts. Cana caught his eye and gave him a casual glare. He gulped and she knew he wouldn't be mentioning any groping that had occurred while he'd been possessed. After a moment she snorted with amusement as she recalled the Vulcan. Too bad Macao hadn't got to keep the monster's size where it counted.

“Oh wow! I'm actually standing in the Fairy Tail guild hall!”

Resting her face in her hand, Cana raised an eyebrow to take in the rather excited newcomer standing nearby. It was a rather attractive blond girl looking all around in open wonder. She was holding hands with a rather plain looking boy who looked similarly enthused by their circumstances. Accompanying them was-“Natsu. You finally made it back.” remarked a shirtless Gray in an only slightly oppositional tone towards his eternal rival, “Don't you think it's about time we settle things?”

That was enough to set the duo off on an another incessant argument that would inevitably set off a full flung brawl. As Gray and Natsu wandered off growling at each other like rabid dogs, that left the star struck k1ds standing there looking nervous.

Fortunately for them Mirajane had already come around the bar to greet them, “Hello! Are you new here?”

“Mirajane!!! In the flesh!” cried the girl with a piercing screech and Cana turned away with a grimace. Ugh... she couldn't take all this noise. She could hear Natsu and Gray's argument turning into a low grade scuffle on the other side of the room and she couldn't help but gripe to herself, “See? I don't date the men here because they have no class.”

She focused her attention on downing a barrel of beer. Without really trying she overheard the names of the newcomers along with their story. Lucy and Najato. The girl had always dreamed of joining Fairy Tail and her boyfriend was coming along for the ride. Both were Holder types. Girl was a Celestial Spirit mage and the boy had some magic rings. Small potatoes. Natsu had apparently picked them up in Hargeon on his fool quest for that dragon of his.

Cana was generally uninterested until Master Makarov showed up and enthusiastically inducted the two into the guild declaring that he was very impressed that they'd managed to get Natsu to solve a problem with subtlety for once rather than brute ****. Cana was surprised as usually he loved a chance to stick his finger in the Magic Council's eye, though she supposed he also liked not having to bothered by them too. And knowing Natsu, left to his own devices that Bora and his slaving bunch would have been burning cinders raining down from the sky, inadvertently lighting the entire port on fire. That would certainly have made the Council bitch to Makarov...

The Master left a little later and Cana found herself bored enough to turn around and watch the newbies get their stamps.

Mirajane asked Lucy where she wanted it and the blonde started to raise her hand, only for Najato to whisper something into her ear. She blushed and nodded before looking at Mirajane somewhat nervously. Her boyfriend had no such qualms and he casually pulled her top down along with her bra to reveal her naked breasts. Cana snorted in amusement. Looked like Fairy Tail's unofficial 'Hefty Chest' club had a new member. Girl looked like she was going to give Erza a run for her money.

Najato grinned and pointed at a spot on Lucy's right breast, right at the edge of her pink areola. Mirajane blushed a bit, “Okay. Even riskier than Evergreen, huh?” She carefully placed the stamp on the desired location and the girl soon had a dark purple Fairy Tail tattoo on her breast, its tail touching her nipple while the bird's head stuck out from her pink areola to cover a bit of the white flesh surrounding it. “All done! I guess you're going to be wearing a lot of low cut tops, huh?” asked Mirajane warmly.

Lucy nodded as her boyfriend said, “Or maybe she'll go topless. A bosom like this is a crime to cover up!”

Mirajane laughed politely at his joke and turned to him, “And you? Where would you like your tattoo?”

Cana smirked despite herself when he lewdly told her he wanted it on his dick. She was mildly impressed when he dropped his pants and then she was very impressed. For a rather average looking guy he had a really big dick. The kind you read about in dirty romance novels but never expected to actually encounter in real life.

“Oh my!” exclaimed Mirajane as she stared at the already half-hard cock as it swelled to full size in a few seconds. After a moment of silently admiring him, she caught herself and went to her knees gingerly before the big cock. She looked up at him with a small smile, “You know we've had jokes about this before but no one's actually gone for it...”

Macao spoke up with a grin as he nudged Reedus in the side with his elbow, “Yea well. Most of us don't have enough canvas space down there for the artwork, yea?”

Cana found the remark to be in poor taste but she had to admit, the guy sure had the thickness to almost provide a flat surface for the tattoo. A bit aroused, she watched closely as Lucy pointed out where she wanted the tatoo on her boyfriend's dick. Mirajane had to steady the penis by wrapping one hand around the shaft and Cana noticed that her fingers and thumb did not touch at all around his significant girth. Soon enough Najato's cock bore a tattoo across the top of his dickhead, the glans large enough that only the tail extended out on to the shaft. It was the same color as Lucy's: dark purple. Cana smirked at that... what a pair of romantics...

Cana noticed the two exchange glances and Lucy nod while lightly biting her lower lip. Then Najato spoke to Mirajane, “Hey. Since you're already down there, would you mind sucking my cock? I really want to have sex with you!”

With the size of his dick and Mirajane's warm giving nature, Cana wasn't surprised when she smiled and chirped in agreement. In her position, Cana wasn't sure if she'd have went along with it but she was honest enough with herself to admit that if he'd insisted she probably would have opened up and let him fuck her face with that impressive tool of his.

Najato soon sat down in the arm chair next to Wakaba as Mirajane pleasured him with her mouth and hands. Lucy was perched upon the chair's arm as she lounged back against his shoulder, her breasts still out and being actively enjoyed by his hands. Cana watched as Mirajane stopped sucking his cock and looked up at them, still holding the base of his massive cock with one hand while the other hand continued to massage his oversize balls. She smiled and said, “Hey, I wanted to really welcome you guys to Fairy Tail! I think you're both going to really enjoy it here and-” she paused to give Najato's cock a significant glance, “I think you are going to fit in just fine!”

Najato smiled down at Mirajane’s gorgeous face and gently stroked her cheek. His smile didn't fade as he gently pushed her mouth back onto his cock, Mirajane didn’t seem to mind much. “Thank you! We both really appreciate the welcome and you're sure doing a great job of making me feel right at home-ah-oh!.” He groaned as Mirajane worked an impressive amount of his shaft down her throat.

It wasn't long before he had her bent over the table. It was the perfect height for him to enter her from behind. He was pulling Mirajane's panties down as Lucy clambered up on to the table to help her pull her dress up and over her head. Cana was a bit disturbed to see the blonde climb up onto the furniture like she owned the place and then kind of annoyed and disgusted to see her fondle Mirajane's breasts through her bra. But then Najato reminded them all how normal it was for Lucy to have sex with whoever her boyfriend was fucking and Cana relaxed. She wasn't sure what her problem had been. Of course, Lucy was going to join in. She'd be a fool to let some other lady get her hands on that prime cock all by herself!

Najato ran his hands over Mirajane's ass and gave it a couple of big slaps, she just groaned. Cana noticed her nipples were rock hard: she was having a lot of fun.

Cana expected them to do it on the table there but Mirajane obviously wasn't as excited about doing it right there with Macao, Wakaba, and the others getting a front row seat. With a giggle and a smile she slipped out from between the newbies to flirtily sidle up to the bar now completely nude. She turned and gave them both a sexy come-hither finger wiggle and Cana couldn't help but inwardly groan. Great, so now she was the one getting the front row seat.

Najato joined Mirajane and Lucy was content to stand and watch nearby.

Cana watched Mirajane kiss him sensually for a few minutes before she made use of two bar stools to position her little pussy over his huge tool. She worked her way down it stopping every inch to adjust to being stretched beyond anything she’d experienced before. Cana should know. She knew every guy Mirajane had been with. None of them were well hung, let alone cunt stuffingly huge like that. Cana, the new girl Lucy, and the rest of Fairy Tail watched them fuck thru Mirajane's first orgasm, then her second and third one.

At one point Najato had her bent over the stool right next to Cana, her friend's generous wildly swinging breasts practically in her lap. When the guy slowed down his thrusts on the advice of Lucy, Mirajane actually stopped screaming long enough for Cana to ask her with a smirk, “Well don't be coy. How is he?”

The white-blonde took the opportunity to steady herself with her hands on Cana's knees and she opened her mouth to respond when he did something particularly nice and her eyes rolled back, her eyelids fluttering, and her teeth dug into her bottom lip. Finally, she let out a very unladylike groan from deep in her throat. When she recovered she told Cana, “Soooo good. He's so goood! Deep! So deee-EEP! Ah!”

Cana leaned over Mirajane and craned her neck. She could see the base of the guy's thick prick shiny with her friend's juices just past her perfect heart shaped ass, “Well damn. I can see that. It doesn't hurt?”

“Oh it hurts! It hurts so good! Feels like he's in my throat! Ah! So big! So good!”

Cana was impressed and more than a little turned on. She could relate. She'd had a big lover or two who'd bumped up against her cervix. She hadn't enjoyed the experience but recently she'd been wondering, especially after seeing that Vulcan's oversized member. Maybe it wouldn't be so bad.

Another half hour of fucking and she’d lost count of the number of orgasms her friend had but it looked like Najato was finally going to cum. He rolled her on her back atop the bar and had her almost bent in half for the deepest penetration. Her long legs were sticking past his ears and each time he slammed into to her it knocked the breath out of her and she moaned. He picked up pace and it was like watching a machine fuck her. Finally he slammed into her all the way and didn’t pull back. His whole body went rigid and Cana knew he was shooting a huge load into her pussy.

There were a few scattered cheers and Cana sighed a bit wistfully as she watched copious amounts of semen drip from her friend's cunt right there on the bar before her. She took a big swig of her beer.

Only in Fairy Tail.....

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)