Riley

I answered.

“What’s up, sis?” I asked quietly, slipping out of the bedroom.

“Mom, Natalie, and Katy are about to kill each other. Katy came over looking for you, as did Mom, and now they’re all three arguing.” Riley explained. I sighed.

“I’ll be right there.” I promised. I ducked back into Angelica’s bedroom and grabbed my clothes.

“Whereyougoin?” Angelica mumbled sleepily.

“My sister needs my help.” I apologized. She mumbled something unintelligible and fell back asleep quickly. I got dressed quickly and hurriedly went down to the first floor. I opened the door to Natalie’s apartment to catch an argument halfway through.

“-and for the record, Mikey loved sex with me.” Katy huffed. All three women turned to me when I entered, and Mom looked sheepish.

“Hi, Cole.” Natalie said wryly.

“Let’s settle this debate, then.” Katy said, “Cole, we’re determining which of us is Mikey’s favorite. Who would you say it is?”

I blinked.

“Um... I don’t know. I never heard him talk about anyone else, really. Even Mom.” I shrugged.

Katy pouted.

“But he chose to stay with me.” Mom piped up.

“Oh, not this again.” Natalie rolled her eyes. Katy started arguing back with her, and I sighed a little.

“For God’s sake, who gives a shit?” I exploded. All three women looked at me with different emotions: Mom looked stunned, Katy aroused, and Natalie seemed to have a glint of respect in her eyes.

“You could argue all day as to which of you Dad liked best. News flash, it’s none of you. If Dad cared about you, why would he divorce you?” I said. Mom opened her mouth, but Katy cut in quickly.

“He cheated with me during his marriage to you, so shut up and let Cole talk.” Katy snapped, and turned to me with total adoration and arousal in her eyes. Mom looked horrified, but stayed quiet. So I kept going.

“Yeah, as I was saying. Dad’s a cruel bastard, and quite frankly, I think he only used you three for your magnificent racks. He doesn’t really care about any of you, or he wouldn’t have more wives.” I said firmly.

“Well said.” Natalie spoke up.

“He cheated on me?” Mom asked, her voice full of anguish. Even Katy softened her tone a little.

“Yes, he did. I’m sorry, but he did. Which... is why I have four children with him, not two.” Katy laughed nervously. Mom’s eyes widened.

“Why don’t we take a photo to show Michael how much of a man his son is?” Natalie suggested quickly. Katy smirked.

“Hell yes.” she said. Mom agreed, too. Riley was called from our bedroom to take the photo while Natalie gave directions. I sat on the middle of the couch, while Mom and her flanked me, and Katy stood behind the couch, her melons placed very proactively above my head. Natalie instructed I wrapped an arm around her and Mom’s waists, and both women scored closer than was probably necessary. Katy slid her arms loosely around my neck, and cast a horny look down at me as Mom and Natalie each kissed my cheek and Riley snapped the photo.

“All good.” she grinned. Mom hit send, and surprising the other three women, captured my lips in a fierce, passionate kiss.

“I’m not afraid to tell the truth now. My third child is Cole’s, not Michael’s.” Mom said lovingly. Riley looked stunned, Katy intrigued, and Natalie triumphant. She glanced at Riley.

“You owe me 30 bucks.” she winked at my big sister.

“You knew?” I asked.

“We made a bet. I bet you were sleeping with your mom. Riley bet against it. I won.” Natalie grinned. I laughed and kissed the dark haired beauty.

“Hey, don’t forget your mother-in-law.” Katy huffed. She’d come around the couch and I wasted no time in standing to wrap my arms around her tightly to kiss her, feeling her nice tits against my chest. She looked flushed and dazed when I pulled back.

“So, Dad has a fourth wife, right?” I grinned. Natalie laughed, while Riley walked forwards for her kiss, which I gave her lovingly.

“He responded!” Mom gasped. She showed the phone to everybody so Dad’s words were easy to see.