Remove Alyssa's butt plug

Moving onto the foot of the bed, you are greeted by a sight you never thought you'd see, much less one caused by another man. Alyssa's asshole is filled with a vibrating butt plug, and her pussy is filled to the brim with another man's dirty cum, leaking by the glob from her pussy down to the bed. Her ass is red from Sid's hips slamming against her, but it's still oily.

Alyssa: "Thanks soooo much for letting me cum, babe....that was amazing."

You: "....did you....like it?"

Alyssa: "It felt so good....sorry...."

You put your fingers on the end of Alyssa's butt plug, and start slowly pulling. Alyssa moans while you slowly pull the plug out, and when you finally do, her asshole is gaping slightly. You turn the butt plug off, and sit down next to her.

You: "I just wish....you didn't just have sex....with Sid...."

Alyssa: "It was an accident, babe.....but it's no big deal....I don't mind being creampied....it actually feels good....so warm and...full...."

You: "But now I can't take your virginity when we get married...."

Alyssa: "I know....but this way, I'll be more experienced with men when we do finally have sex....Sid says it'll be good for us...."

You: "Since you've already had sex.....wanna do it with me now?"

Alyssa: "Of course, baby, I'd love to.....but you're all caged up...."

You: "I'll just get the key from Sid...."

At that moment, Sid enters the room again, his cock swinging ahead of him, and the necklace with the key on it around his neck.

Sid: "What's this I hear?"

You: "I wanna have sex with Alyssa now...."

Sid: "Go ahead...."

You pause: "...give me the key...."

Sid: "Nah, that stays on until the marriage, trust me. You'll just have to grind your cage against her pussy."

You look at Alyssa's pussy, covered in Sid's white sticky cum, and cringe a little. "No way, it's full of your nasty cum...."

Sid: "Damn right it is....you'll just have to make do with her asshole then...."

You sigh and go on your knees behind Alyssa. Although you can't technically fuck her, this feels just like the real thing, you're actually excited to put your naked body against hers. You let yourself flop down onto her back, and place your cage against her asshole. You can feel her warmth through the cage, but none of the good feeling of fucking her arrives. You grind and grind until Alyssa starts complaining about pain.

Alyssa: "The cage hurts me, baby....please stop...."

You: "You'll have to take the cage off, Sid...."

Sid: "You want a cock in your asshole, Alyssa?"

Alyssa: "mhmm.....I'm still horny....."

Sid: "Since your cock is all locked up, Matt, I have one for her right here....." he starts swinging his semi erect cock up and down, taunting you.

You: "No way....!"

Sid: "What? I've already cum in her pussy.....why is this a big deal?"

You: "Because, that was an accident....! This would be....just fucking..."

Sid: "Well, she needs a cock in her ass, and you can't do it right now....I'm willing to do it for you...."

You stand up, to give Alyssa a break from the pain: "Forget it, let's just get dressed...."

Sid lies down on the bed next to Alyssa: "You've gotten her all riled up, bud, can't leave now....get on top of me, girl..."

Alyssa slowly gets up and straddles Sid, some of the cum leaking down on him and his massive cock, now fully erect. She leans down to him and gives him a deep, loving kiss.

Sid: "Now that my cock has already been in her pussy, it's no big deal if it goes in there again, right?"

Alyssa: "...right...."

You: "...no...."

Sid: "So, if Alyssa raises her hips, and my cock just happens to be in the wrong position, and it enters her asshole...." as he says this, Alyssa raises her hips, and Sid pushes his cock up.

Sid: "It would just....." Alyssa lowers her hips down and meets the tip of Sid's cock.

Sid: "be...." Alyssa starts lowering her hips down on Sid's cock, clearly taking him inside of her...somewhere....

Sid: "...an accident...." Alyssa breathes in sharply and stops just before her hips meet Sid's.

You go to the foot of the bed again and look....Sid's cock is lodged firmly in Alyssa's asshole, stretched impossibly in such an obscene manner you never thought you'd see.....

Alyssa: "Oh...my...god.....fuck....so full...."

Sid: "whoops.....but since it happened....is that what you needed, Alyssa? My cock in your asshole?"

Alyssa: "...yes....sorry baby....his cock is so much better than your cage...."

You: "We...could have taken the cage off...."

Sid: "Just let Alyssa enjoy herself, ride that cock, girl...."

Alyssa, balancing herself on Sid's chest, and giving him the best view in the world with her oily, sweaty tits squeezing together, starts raising and lowering her hips down on Sid's cock, slowly until all of it is buried balls deep inside her asshole. You sit back in the chair, and just watch. There's something hypnotic about watching your girlfriend/fiancée have sex, even if it's not you she's having sex with. This was her in her peak sexuality, completely free to enjoy herself on the huge cock lodged deep within her.

Soon she starts riding Sid for all that he's worth, slamming her hips down on his cock, stimulating her asshole as much as she can. A new sheen on sweat forming on her skin as she screams her way through another orgasm.

Alyssa: "Oh my god.....I love sex.....!"

Sid: "That's a good girl, make me cum now...."

Alyssa: "Cum for me, shoot your nasty cum up my asshole....." she says as her hips keep slamming into Sid's.

Sid: "Fuuuuuck.....! Keep going!"

Alyssa: "Fuck my asshole in front of my fiancée, cum inside me....."

Sid holds her hips and thrusts upwards a few times. "I'm cumming inside your fiancés asshole, Matt!"

Alyssa flops down onto Sid's chest, exhausted from riding him. Sid's cock is still lodged inside Alyssa's asshole, and they're kissing intensely.

Sid: "Damn, Alyssa, you're draining me dry...."

Alyssa slowly pulls herself up, taking Sid's cock out, and letting the cum just seep out onto the bed, while she lays down next to him and cuddles.

Alyssa: "I just....really like sex, I guess...."

You: "Damn it, Sid....what the fuck..."

Sid: "It was just an accident, Matt. A happy accident, but it was no ones fault. Besides, we can all handle it now.....right? You didn't freak out..."

You: "No...I just wish I wasn't caged..."

Sid: "You'll get used to it....it's just a few more months...."

You: "What? I thought you'd let me out now....?"

Sid: "Think about it, you can still uphold your promise to Alyssa, while she gets the pleasure and experience she needs. You'll just stay caged, so you can't have sex, and Alyssa will keep doing her lessons with me, until the marriage..."

Alyssa: "Sounds good to me..."

You: "Not to me!" you sigh....

Sid: "You'll get used to it....let's take a shower while Matt cleans up these sheets..."

Alyssa and Sid stand up to go to the shower, Sid slaps her butt while they walk and she giggles, clearly ecstatic about the situation. Sid's cum now leaking on the floor from both her holes, she doesn't even seem to mind it anymore. You change the sheets while they take a shower together, they're drenched in oil, sweat and cum.

By the time they're done in there, you've gotten dressed. The cage presses tightly up against your pants, creating a ridiculous bulge, and is pretty uncomfortable. The only thing keeping you together right now is the knowledge that you are going to be the one marrying Alyssa. Not Sid. As soon as you're married, he's out of here, so you just have to stick this out for a few more months. The faster you can set the wedding up, the quicker he goes away.

After they get out of the shower, Sid and Alyssa are still naked. "No point in dressing up at home, we've all seen each other naked before. You should be naked too, Matt." Sid says.

You: "I...don't think so...it's embarrassing..."

Alyssa: "Don't be embarrassed, baby...." she give you a kiss on the cheek and smiles

Sid: "Yeah, lots of guys wear chastity cages....nothing to be ashamed of..." he says while his cock swings around obscenely, free of any cage.

You: "Really...?"

Sid: "Sure, for one reason or another. It's normal."

Alyssa: "And if you take your clothes off....I could give you a reward for bein such a good fiancée. I should thank you for letting me cum earlier...."

You: "Will you take the cage off??"

Sid: "No....but I will allow her to suck on your balls until you cum...." He uses the word "allow" like he owns Alyssa's body....what the fuck....

Alyssa: "Doesn't that sound great, baby?"

You are actually still incredibly horny, and your balls hurt after Sid blue balling you earlier. You were so close to fucking Alyssa, before Sid stopped you. Now you would have jerked off, but the cage....

You: "Okay....thanks baby...." you say as you start taking off your clothes, revealing the pathetic cage around your genitals. Although it does allow your balls to hang freely, it makes your cock look so small."

Sid: "Good. From now on, no one wears clothes around here. We have to be more free, sexually, in this house. That way no one has to be surprised when any of use partake in any sexual activity. It should be normal for men and women to explore each others bodies at will. After you get married, I expect you to hold to that rule."

Alyssa leads you to a chair in the living room and plops you down. Then she gives you a kiss on the lips, then one on the chest, then on the stomach, then...on your cage, and another, and another. You groan, as your cock tries its best to get hard, but all it does is fill the cage, then hurting you with the pressure of your arousal. Your naked fiancée is practically giving you your first blowjob.

Alyssa: "Want me to suck your balls, baby...?"

You: "....yes....please..."

Alyssa: "You want me to suck them like I suck on Sid's big balls every morning?"

You: ".....yes...."

Alyssa: "I will....since you've been such a good boy...."

You: "...please..."

Alyssa: "...letting Sid....fuck.....my pussy....and my asshole....." more kisses on your cage, she's teasing you immensely, you feel a fire building up inside of you. After what's happened today, you're in a state of immense arousal, and would say and do almost anything to just cum.

Alyssa: "You're not gonna....freak out.....if it happens....again....." she licks the cage, her tongue just touched the tip of your dick...it feels amazing....

You: "...."

Alyssa: "It's already happened once.....It's okay if one day you...enter the apartment....and Sid is....fucking me....with his big cock...."

You: "ughnn.....why...."

Alyssa: "It feels....soooo...goood.....baby.....today wasn't cheating.....it was an accident...." She puts your whole cage in her mouth, engulfing it with her warm embrace. You thrust upwards, but feel only her warmth and maybe a little bit of saliva on your dick. She's left the balls hanging.

Alyssa: "But....if you give us permission.....then it's never going to be cheating......we could....fuck....and fuck.....as much as we want.....and it wouldn't be cheating......what do you say...?"

She pauses with her mouth just hanging over your balls. Clearly, if the answer is yes, she's going to suck on your balls until you cum. If you say no....you're going to be more blue balled than ever....