Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 31 by Darkstar239 Darkstar239

Whose the first pair?

Rarity and Twilight

Twilight had the pleasure of being paired up with her Mistress Rarity in the search for the Roots of Harmony, but with that came the new worries and responsibility of carefully managing her reaction. To ensure she wasn't scared off by the changes, nor did anything that would undermine her own dreams. No small task, not least of all since Rarity was sure to maintain her unnecessary morality, and Spike had made things more complicated revealing the true nature of her power far ahead of schedule.

When she discussed this with Cadence she found her sister in law shared her concerns and so she and Starlight had rushed ahead. To find the other roots, to understand their capabilities and to ensure they wouldn't be able to be used as threats. But still as Cadence had reminded her this could also be a good opportunity to start looking.

The two had walked in silence for some time, well into the Everfree Forest. Yet in a section devoid of aphrodisiac wildlife. Both of them apparently had their mind filled with thoughts and worries that made it difficult to concentrate on their task at hand. Eventually Twilight broke the silence.

“So Rarity assuming we find one of these roots. Which one would you want? And which powers do you think they’ll give?” Twilight asked her friend, glancing back at her as she trailed behind.

“Hmm.” Rarity hummed in agreement to what wasn’t a yes or no question. Twilight noticed she’d didn’t seem to be concentrating, uncharistically she was making no effort to avoid muddy patches and had stained much of her boots and trousers.

“Everything okay?” She asked her friend and Mistress.

“Sure Twilight.” She replied morosely. Causing Twilight to stop in her tracks.

“Rarity what’s the matter?” Twilight asked, breaking her out of the trance. "You haven't been saying anything since we left."

"Oh I'm terribly sorry Twilight. A lot has just fallen on my mind is all darling." Rarity admitted, her voice lacking her usual enthusiasm and energy.

"What is it?" Twilight asked. "Is it about these roots? Are you jealous of Spike?"

"No darling it's not that. It's just that... according to Spike he had this power for some time. I’m just a bit surprised that he didn’t decide to trust me with the truth of this power.” Rarity admitted with a pout. "You don't think it's because of my fantasy do you Twilight? He knows that I would never dream of asking him to use his power like that. It should remain little more than a dream, I know that.”

Twilight couldn’t hide the scowl that adorned her features which was misinterpreted by Rarity.

“Oh dear Twilight you judge me too. I'm so very sorry if I've offended you, I can't help these fantasies you know. I didn't choose them. I thought we were free to talk about this but... oh dear." Rarity whimpered and now tears were falling down her face. Her fear that she had alienated her closest friends coming to the forefront.

Twilight's instincts as a nymphomaniac manipulator fell away, and instead she hugged her friend as a friend. Comforting her as she cried ever so softly into Twilight's shoulder. "No one thinks any less of you Rarity. Spike is just taking his time to get used to his powers is all."

"But I've made a massive mistake Twilight.” She cried, clutching her tightly. "When Spike talked to me about my dream I didn't have the courage to tell him how I really felt. I was too ashamed, too afraid of how he'd judge me for wanting him as a Master of a harem of all my friends. Now he thinks I don’t love him.”

Twilight was torn, and right now she wished Cadence was here to help. Obviously she didn’t want Rarity to be ashamed of her fantasy, quite the opposite of course. She wanted her to embrace her fantasy, and then for her to persuade Spike to embrace it as well. But Twilight knew that she couldn't push Rarity too far too quickly right now.

“Spike doesn’t judge you at all Rarity.” Twilight assured her friend patting her on the back. “You know how Spike is. Always bottling up his emotions like he is, he didn't mean anything by it."

"But you, Cadence, and Starlight have all made love with him.” Rarity cried, and Twilight felt a pang of guilt and fear at the thought that she may have sabotaged her dreams. "He's probably already forgotten about me.”

Twilight knew Rarity was being a tad melodramatic but it was essential that Rarity not be dissuaded from her dream or move on from Spike. “Oh Rarity Spike could never forget about you. Him having sex with us doesn’t mean that he doesn't care about you. It only means he might be a little bit more into your harem fantasy than you think."

"Wouldn't that be something?" Rarity sniffled, clearly feeling a bit better much to Twilight's relief. Truth be told she believed Cadence would be much better at the task than Twilight would be. Rarity pulled away now feeling much better, before her eyes sharpened on something. "And I think I just noticed something."

Rarity rushed ahead with Twilight running behind. Much deeper into the forest where the scents of the forest began to finally affecting the two mares. But nevertheless for now only mildly as they ran through the forest, until Rarity paused at a set of vines. At first Twilight was confused, but when Rarity used her magic to clear away the the vines to reveal the glint of a glimmering cave of crystals.

“How did you know?” Twilight asked, at this Rarity smirked.

“Darling a fashionista like myself has an eye for these sorts of gems.” Rarity explained proudly. “Now let’s see which one we’ll find inside. It’s seems to me this cave has a somewhat purple theme Twilight. That could reference either one of us, so perhaps magic or generosity?”

“Yeah I think so.” Twilight admitted as they entered the cave. Truthfully she couldn’t tell whether it was the purple or her magic or Rarity’s mane. But he wasn’t above lying to see her Mistress empowered. “I think it’s more of your purple than my own. Actually I have a spell to check.”

Twilight lit up her horn, but it wasn’t anything more than a simple light show. “Yep this is definitely yours.”

Rarity seemed in awe at the possibility, she stared ahead at the forbidding cave ahead of them. “Are you sure Twilight? I mean if we’re wrong.”

“I’m certain Rarity now go on right ahead.” Twilight said before quite literally pushing her forward. Rarity stumbled then proceeded to head in further into the cave until she found a root of crystal, with Twilight’s cutie mark on it.

“Twilight I think-“ Rarity shouted but it was too late as the Twilight she saw behind her wasn’t a physical but rather a holographic Twilight. “-that I got the wrong one.”

“Wrong one? What you’re upset you’re getting this power Rarity?” The holographic Twilight asked, a hand reached to her chest in mock hurt.

“No of course not darling. I just assumed that it would be best if the Element of Magic got well the Root of Magic.” Rarity explained eyes darting to Twilight as she approached. “So is that how it works? Can I give the power to Twilight?”

“I’m afraid not Rarity. You came here first and therefore the power is yours.” The Element of Magic explained before whispering. “And between you and me, due to the changes Twilight’s endured that might be a good thing.”

“Changes? What changes are those?” Rarity asked, but the Element of Magic was silent.

“So Rarity you’ve found the root of magic and with it the new power among it.” Twilight said running up to her. “Wouldn’t you like to know what that gives you?”

“I suppose so then.” Rarity replied turning to the Element of Magic. “What do I get?”

It was somewhat confusing having the Element of Magic and Twilight standing next to each other, both identical in most ways. There was just a small difference in the way that they held each other, not to mention the Element of Magic word and outfit far too conservative for Twilight to actually wear.

“Right well Rarity as you found the Element of Magic you’ve now become an instant except of magic. From now on you’ll instantly master any magic you see or observe and be able to do it even better than the pony who showed it to you. Even if you as a unicorn shouldn’t be able to use it.”

Rarity was naturally stunned, but Twilight was excited. She had made her Mistress into a Goddess now, one who would easily be able to keep them in line. Rarity however still seemed concerned. “What about the dark magic? Like the book Spike got me? Sombra’s magic? Or Discord’s chaos magic?”

The Element of Magic smiled. “Don’t worry about that. You’ll receive none of the magical consequences that you’d otherwise receive. The only magic you can’t copy is the magic from the elements, including the rainbow power, and the powers from the other roots.”

“Doesn’t that sound incredible Rarity, I could give you a demonstration later, then you’ll be as strong as me.” Twilight said with a grin on her face, as the two began to leave the cave. Her pussy becoming quite aroused with both the plants of the Everfree and the thought of how their Mistress could better control her harem now.”

“That’s- that would be quite a way off Twilight.” Rarity added, nervously struggling to truly come to terms with her new power.

“I wouldn’t be so sure.” Twilight asked as they exited the cave. “So let’s see how well this power of yours works.”

Twilight channeled magic into her wings like a Pegasus and flew into the air.

“Twilight come back.” Rarity yelled after her. “Of course I can’t-“

But as she watched her it was a unique experience. As if it was obvious, with a thought two cyan wings made of light formed from her back. Like that of an alicorn. “Oh my goodness.”

Twilight smiled as Rarity made her way up. Not quite having master the full skills of a flyer like Rainbow Dash who used both magic and skill. Nevertheless she was able to keep herself steady. “What do you think Rarity? You could do anything now.”

“Yes but I still feel a little guilty dear. Mastering skills you took years in a minute feels a little disingenuous darling.” Rarity admitted to Twilight who simply shook her head.

“There’s nothing to worry about. Stop by the castle later.” She said flying up to Rarity. “I know a few spells a Mistress of a harem might find useful, or a sex ****.”

A/N: Sorry if this chapter isn’t my best. Construction at my house has been stressful, especially when you’re autistic like me. Suggestions and feedback is welcome.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)