Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 19 by remysloane remysloane

What's next?

Ramya: Fingers In, Virginity on the Edge

I save the best for last, turning slowly to give him the full view of my ass, my pride and joy, sculpted from endless squats and sweat in the gym. His low moan of approval sends a shiver up my spine, emboldening me. I bend at the waist, hands sliding back to spread my cheeks wide, exposing my smooth, shaved pussy and the tight pucker above it. Cool air hits my wetness, making me clench involuntarily. God, I'm acting like a porn star, but the thrill of his hungry gaze on my most intimate parts makes my clit throb. I've never done this for any other guy, so why this male virgin I thought I wasn't attracted to? My mind races, but my body doesn't care.

I adjust my grip lower, tugging the soft flesh apart to reveal my inner lips, parting them just enough for a teasing gape. My virgin hole winks at him, tight and untouched, hymen intact but ready to shatter. He won't notice the barrier, won't understand the sacrifice I'd have to make to take him into my body.

"That's where your cock goes, virgin," I purr, my voice husky with tease. Payback for his earlier comment about my blowjob skills.

"Oh my God, you're so fucking sexy," he groans, voice thick with need. "Give me that second date, Ramya."

"You'll need it," I shoot back, straightening and sliding onto the bed beside him, facing him sideways. "Because you're not getting that lucky tonight." But even as I say it, my pulse hammers, my nipples hardening against the sheets. "Kiss me again."

He leans in eagerly, and I press closer, my bare breasts brushing his chest, my thigh draping over his hip until my slick pussy grazes his skin. The heat of him seeps into me, his clean, earthy musk mixing with my own arousal, filling the air like an aphrodisiac.

"Whoa," he moans into my mouth, his breath hot and ragged.

I smile against his lips. "You can touch. Explore me." I guide his hand to my breast, and he squeezes gently, thumb circling my nipple. His palm is warm, rough, wandering down to cup my ass, tracing the curve of my back. Goosebumps erupt everywhere he touches.

His kisses are still messy. Too much tongue, too forceful, but he's learning. When he pinches my nipple too hard, I gasp "Ouch," and he softens instantly. I murmur encouragements. "Softer, like this," without making it a lesson. He catches on fast, and it turns me on, being his guide.

I'm a virgin too, but you'll never know. Not until you claim it. Not until I spread my legs and bleed for you.

I grind closer, craving friction, but his belly blocks the way in this position. Frustrated, I hook my leg higher over him, spreading myself wide, my wetness smearing against his thigh. Bad move. His hand on my lower back slips down, cups my ass, then dips between my cheeks to press against my vulva. When his finger traces my slick slit, hovering at my entrance, I grab his wrist... and hesitate.

I rarely let guys finger me. Always one finger only, and I feel guilty after. I worry about my hymen tearing, since I need to stay sealed up down there until my hubby opens me properly on my wedding bed. Matt's fingers are thick and pudgy. Dangerous.

But replaying that in my head? It sounds so childish now. My body's screaming for more. "Well... okay, just a little," I whisper, releasing his hand.

What the hell, Ramya?

His middle finger shifts, presses firmly against my asshole. I giggle, the unexpected touch making me squirm. "Hold on, that's my butt. That's definitely not first date territory. A little lower, find the wetness. There's my pussy. Gentle... I'm tight."

He slides the finger in slowly, and oh God, it stretches me just right. Biggest thing I've taken in my pussy, but it goes in no problem and feels great. I moan, low and throaty, my walls clenching around him. He pauses, buried inside, his timidity making him a gentle giant. I break the kiss, staring into his eyes, my breath mingling with his as he starts to rock it in and out.

"Yes... slow like that. Feels so good."

Surprisingly good. My pussy's so wet, so ready, it welcomes him like it's been waiting. No snug resistance, just slick, eager heat. I know my body; I know the hole in my hymen is smaller than his pudgy finger. The barrier is flexible, stretching and thinning instead of tearing. But this is a dangerous game. How much further can I take this before I pop and ruin everything I've saved for my wedding bed? He's already changing me, opening me, preparing me for sex too soon. My hips tilt instinctively, chasing more anyway.

He's grinning, eyes wide with wonder. "Thanks for letting me finger you."

I laugh softly, touched by his intuition. "You're welcome. I don't usually allow any form of penetration on a first date. You're... persuasive." My voice cracks with nervous heat.

"Yeah, I definitely want that second date!"

"I'll think about it," I tease, though I know there won't be one. "I'd enjoy making a man out of you." But the lie hangs heavy, and my body craves him now.

The finger isn't much, but it's everything. I've been fingered before, yet this feels different. My muscles relax around him, craving deeper, fuller. It's not just the act—it's him. Amid all the smooth, hot guys who've tried to seduce me, this sweet, awkward virgin has my pussy aching for his cock the most.

I let go completely, no more hovering hand, and dive back into his kiss. Our tongues tangle, hot and wet, as he speeds up, a full-on finger-fucking now, the obscene squelch of my arousal echoing in the room. The angle's off, grazing toward my ass instead of my G-spot, but it doesn't matter. I slide my knee higher, spreading wider, my clit begging for contact. Then a second finger joins, wiggling at my entrance, stretching me further.

It slips in a fraction, and panic flares. I've never taken two. My eyes snap open. This is too much. I'm losing control.

I clasp his hand, shaking my head with a **** smile. "No... that's enough." He pulls out slowly, and I whimper at the emptiness, my pussy clenching around nothing. Fuck, I miss it already. He's cracked open a door I want to fling wide.

We kiss again, de-escalating, but my mind's racing. That insertion? One more barrier down. I'm inches from begging for the real thing. I know I'll never truly be satisfied until his thick black cock slides into my virgin hole.

Matt shifts, angling his body so his belly moves aside, pulling my hips flush against his. Finally! His throbbing erection presses right against my slick crease. I grin wickedly, grinding slow and deliberate, coating the sensitive underside of it in my wetness.

"You like that? My tight little pussy sliding over your dick?"

Enjoy the ****, Matt. You’re not getting inside me tonight. No way a clumsy virgin is claiming my pussy. I’m in charge here. I'm untouchable.

"Oh yeah," he groans, thrusting back instinctively.

"You're doing so good, Matt. You've got me so fucking horny."

Talk me into it. You're so close. Stretch me open with that monster. Take what's yours.

I'm on fire now, completely lost in the tease. I can't remember the last time getting this close to the line only my husband will cross felt this raw, this fun. This rush of being the experienced one, the one calling the shots while he worships every move I make? It's fucking intoxicating. My willpower is crumbling because my ego screams for the trophy. I'm dying to take his virginity, but I have to break my own seal to do it.

Choose how Ramya breaks. She can be helpless beneath him in missionary position, or you can read from her lover's POV for a twist followed by a doggie style tease that goes too far.

What's next?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)