More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 6 by Spidermind Spidermind

How did everything start?

Rachel Origen Part 1

2 months ago...

The girls and I were inseparable; we went to the movies, went shopping, and had all kinds of parties. The five of them were the sisters I'd never had, just as I was to them, and I thought it would be forever.

Or so I thought...

If I could pinpoint the exact beginning of it all, it would be Mike's accident. My annoying brother was experimenting in chemistry class and made some substances explode.

He was **** for a few days, fortunately for him and a relief for my mother, and he was able to recover. The doctors examined him thoroughly and found no significant after-effects, except for one thing.

His eyes, which were naturally dark brown, had transformed into a blue as bright and beautiful as the sea. Although the doctors had no explanation for the change, Mike's vision was not affected.

His sparkling blue eyes became my brother's defining characteristic; everyone from my mother to my friends marveled at them and praised him.

But his new eyes always bothered me. I didn't know how to explain it. On the one hand, I saw them as beautiful, and on the other hand, they gave me a bad feeling. I think it was around then that I started feeling that itch on my neck that I can't identify to this day.

A week after the accident, he was discharged. Of course, he'd missed a few classes, so my mother asked Alicia to fill him in.

Alicia had no particular interest in my brother; their interactions didn't go beyond "hello" and "goodbye," and she had her reasons.

She saw Mike as a weirdo who wasted his time on his strange interests. On the other hand, she'd always been one of the most popular and intelligent girls at the university, standing out for her perfect 90-60-90 figure. Anyway, if it weren't for my brother, Alicia wouldn't even be aware of his existence.

At first, my friend refused to help with his studies, but my mom insisted that my brother not fall so far behind, so I finally agreed. For a few days, Alicia came over to our house and caught him up on various subjects. Although she shared her displeasure with being around Mike, I noticed that with each passing day, she was getting along better with my brother.

Then, one Monday night, when my mom was out of the house, Alicia was here for what would be our last lesson while I watched TV. Out of the corner of my eye, I could see them working without any problems. Oddly enough, my friend seemed more enthusiastic than usual. I got thirsty, so I went to the kitchen for a glass of water.

I think I left them alone for about 20 minutes because I wasted some time scrolling through social media on my phone. When I came back, I was shocked by what I saw.

Alicia and Mike were kissing, and it wasn't just a simple kiss. They were doing it with such frenzy that their heads were swaying from side to side. I watched as Alicia, with her back to me, surrendered unabashedly to my brother's caresses, as he was already inserting his hands inside her blouse.

"Mmm... Mike"

"Alicia... ooh"

For a few seconds, I was disconnected, finding no response or reaction to what my eyes were seeing, trying to believe I was in a bizarre dream. But as they exchanged those fluids, I realized more and more that this was real.

"Ahh...the blouse...hmm...take it off."

When Mike removed that garment that bothered me so much, and when I looked at her beautiful, bare back, it made me realize the madness of what they were doing. I couldn't let this nonsense continue to escalate, so I took a step to interrupt their morbid activity, but at that moment, Mike saw me, kissing my friend's neck.

The moment his flashing blue eyes met mine, I stopped dead in my tracks. A huge pang of remorse flooded my head, and guilty thoughts rushed through like a train.

What was I about to do? My brother recently got out of the hospital; his life was in danger. I think he deserves some happiness, right? Besides, it's normal for young people to be very curious about sex, and Alicia is quite attractive, so it wouldn't be good for me to ruin their moment.

I didn't quite know where those thoughts came from, but they quickly engaged in a struggle with my indignation and anger. Should I leave them or not? Is what they were doing wrong? Is it normal for Alicia to be with Mike?

I stayed like that for a few seconds until I finally turned around and walked away without making a sound. As I walked away, I had a strong feeling that I shouldn't do this, which disappeared in the blink of an eye. In my room, I could clearly hear how the encounter between Mike and Alicia escalated, moving to the first baseman's room and going from second to fourth base in record time.

"OOOH...MIKE, YOU'VE GOT A BIG ONE...AHHHHH...RASH ME!"

"HHMM...OOOH...WONDERFUL...I'VE ALWAYS WANTED TO DO THIS TO YOU!"

"Oh my God... are you really having sex right next to me? What are you thinking, Alicia?" I murmured incredulously.

Part of me still couldn't believe that one of my friends was sleeping with my little brother right under my nose. Even though they were getting along better, it was one thing to have a nice chat and a whole other thing to have sex so quickly.

"AHHHHHHH....AHHHHHHH.....I'M CUMMING.... YOUR BIG COCK IS MAKING ME CUM!....AYYYYYYYYYYY"

"OOOOOH....YES.... SO GOOD...GRRR...MY FIRST TIME!"

"Fuck....What the hell did Alicia get up to? She owes me a good explanation."

The steamy encounter lasted most of the night, something that surprised me given the enormous stamina of a virgin like Mike. At dawn, I opened the door to see Mike heading for the bathroom with a smile the size of a planet. Alicia followed shortly after, and I seized the opportunity to approach her.

I went up to her, took her arm, and quickly led her into my room. I was a little rude, but at that moment, I was in a bad mood from all this madness.

"Oh... oh... you're so rude," Alicia complained once she was inside my room.

"Come on, don't be so long. That's not what you were saying to Mike last night," I said, not denying my anger.

She complained as she stood there, playing with her hair while laughing.

"Oh, he, he, he... you mean THAT... hehe... it was really wild, wasn't it?" she said happily.

"A wild thing? That was absolutely crazy, maybe you've lost your mind? He's my little brother!" I raised my voice.

"Oh my God, Rachel, you're overreacting. What happened was totally normal... Two young guys with raging hormones; the outcome is quite natural. Besides, you're completely wrong about Mike still being your little brother," Alicia said jokingly.

Her smile became even more lax, and she raised an eyebrow, something I'd seen in her before when she reminisced about their sexual adventures, only this time it was more noticeable.

“What are you talking about, Alicia?” she asked, confused.

"Obviously, you haven't seen his… well, you know. He's bigger than any guy I've been with, and when he… well, you know… he wreaked havoc on me."

Honestly, that surprised me even more. I hadn't seen Mike naked since we were kids, so they had no idea how big he was.

“Uh… no… I didn't know… I'm not interested either. We're talking about my brother and how the hell you got into his pants to… you know… all night at my house… if only my mom were here.”

Apparently, my comment put Alicia on the defensive, as she became even more upset.

“Hey, let's get a few things straight. What happened last night was a burst of lust between us. I didn't **** him. Secondly, Mike has every right to use his… well, you know… however he pleases. He's of legal age.” Alicia opened the door and, before closing it, she turned to me. “Finally, if your mother finds out, I'll tell her the same thing I told you. After all, I think Mike and I will be closer after today”

When she closed the door, I was left with more questions than at the beginning. No matter what she said, her new relationship with Mike seemed like it came out of nowhere. Unfortunately, this was only the beginning of the longest week of my life... and the beginning of my brother's new life!

How does the week take place?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)