More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by Woodtale Woodtale

What's next?

Prove it!

Leslie held back her reaction, knowing that's what Rick was ultimately looking for. Deep down she was shocked. Shocked that Rick would show her his dick, but even more shocked that Pete would be ok with it. She knew the drooling boys behind her were just waiting for her reaction so she slyly played it off like she didn't believe them.

"Whatever! I bet they're both just AI images and you used a photo in our bathroom as the background to try to trick me," she challenged without looking up. "See! Those veins are too fake!"

The boys' jaws dropped. Their plan hadn't played out with as much shock and awe as they had planned. They thought for sure she would be so embarrassed that she wouldn't even make a guess and they would win the test.

Frustrated, Rick blurted out, "Those are not fake images! We literally just took them in your bathroom!"

"Dude!?" Pete retorted to Rick. "You said you wouldn't say anything!"

"There's no way she thinks those are fake! I mean we literally just took shots of our junk! There's nothing fake about them Leslie!" Rick couldn't let it go. It was almost like he was taking it personally.

Leslie didn't let up, "It looks kind of fake to me. There's no way this is real. Just look how hard both of them are. No way that you two could've gotten that hard in such a short time that you were away."

"Well it took a little bit of stroking, but those are legitimately me and Rick, hun," Pete tried to reason with her as both Rick and Pete walked around her chair so they were standing in front of her.

She looked down at their crotches, and back up at their faces. "Nah! You guys don't even look hard right now. I'm not buying it. But good try!" she said as she tossed the phone over on the couch. "You guys really want me to think that in one minute you both went into the bathroom, got yourselves hard, took photos and decided to show me your willies?! I'm not buying it!"

They both nodded as they stared at her. "That's exactly what we did!" exclaimed Rick.

"Ok, then prove it!" she said as she leaned back in her chair. "You want me to believe those are real, prove it! Let's see 'em!"

The guys looked at each with eyebrows raised. They shrugged their shoulders in approval and without hesitating they each dropped their shorts to their ankles. They stood there a couple feet away from Leslie with their dongs completely out as if they had something important to prove to her.

She didn't let on, but she was definitely impressed. A grin crept across her face as she looked at these two ass-naked men trying to prove to her that their cocks were real. But she wasn't done with them just yet... after all, those dicks weren't nearly as erect as they were in those photos she just saw...

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)