Sarah vs Natalie

"One more wish?" Tom repeated, furrowing his brow. "What kind of wish now?"

Sarah slinked up to him. Rubbing her body against him, she looked up to his face. "Oh my dear DAD," she smirked, "this is so very different from what we expected. It's one thing to be cast into different lives when it's just you and me - but now you have a wife and me a mother who's a part of our new life."

She pushed Tom down onto the sofa and plopped onto his lap, with her legs stretched out down the length of the sofa. She counted off with her fingers as she made her points. "I really doubt I can fake my way with her around all the time. I barely remember high school. And I definitely don't know anything about cheerleadering. You... well, honestly Tom, everyone knows how absent minded you can be sometimes, so I think you can get by. Though your family has changed, it looks like your life is mostly the same. Me, on the other hand... well, I think I'll need memories of this life."

Tom felt somewhat overwhelmed by all this, but Sarah had a knack for 'logically' pushing him to agree to her plans in unexpected situations. "Okay, I can do that," he agreed as he took the coin from his pocket.

"Whoah...whoah," she said, grabbing his hand with the coin. "It's a little more complicated than that." She gave him a quick kiss. "So agreeable sometimes - I love that about you. But I'm thinking this through."

She went quiet for a moment, and held up her hand when Tom started to speak. So he just sat there holding her on his lap. He began to get distracted the sensations - the warmth of her bottom pressing down on his groin, with her slight shifts in positioning starting to excite him. He stroked her legs and tried to kiss her neck.

She sighed. "Not now Tom! We've got to get this right..."

Rebuffed, he leaned back in disappointment as Sarah moved off his lap to sit beside him.

After a few more minutes she finally spoke up. "Okay, I've got it." She shifted to face Tom. "I have to admit I'm really turned on by this whole father-daughter idea. But I'm afraid that changing or adding to my memories might screw this up. I mean, it's one thing to roleplay - you know how much I like that," she said with a grin. "But if even a part of me saw you as my actual father... well, it would just be too weird."

Tom hadn't really thought of how that might be for her. Frankly he couldn't really imagine it. The coin seemed very powerful but Sarah was really the one directly affected by it - he was just enjoying the benefits. So he would respect her rules.

Sarah continued. "So here's my idea. Wish for me to have two totally separate personalities that only you know about. One ... let's call her Natalie... is your daughter here and she has full memories ONLY of this life. The second - Sarah - is me, with only the memories of my old life but can remember everything that happens to Natalie. That way I can enjoy both aspects of this life. And you can switch us by saying 'Sarah, go to sleep' and 'Sarah, wake up.'"

Tom was befuddled by Sarah's idea. "What?" he said hesitantly. "I... I don't know, this seems complicated," he pointed out.

"No, it will be fine" she said with confidence. "And you can always change things again if there are problems. Come on, this will be fun! This is why we have the coin!" She pushed herself back against him, reaching her hand into his pants to gently squeeze his cock. "Try this for me..." she pleaded.

"Okay..." he said, giving in to her. "I...I can make the wish..." he started.

"Great!" she chirped, sitting back beside him again. "Oh, one thing," she interjected before he could start, "you have to promise to bring me - Sarah - out at least once a day, and only switch to Natalie when I ask - or when you really need to. I want to actively enjoy this and I can't if 'Natalie' is always in control, okay! Natalie is here for school and stuff, to use so I can get by easily. " She added with a suggestive grin "... and to make this all a bit more real for you...."

Tom slowly nodded. "Uh, sure..." he answered, still uncertain of the whole thing. But he made the wish as Sarah directed.