Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 31 by FlatCap90210 FlatCap90210

How is dinner going to go?

Quite well - and Sarah has a proposition.

"You know, as heavy as they are, once I got used to them--aw, crud!" Pulling one of her right nipples free from the sheet she was wearing, Sarah aimed it at a glass and tugged a few times, thick streams of milk shooting from her teat. "Okay, I'll admit that the... productiveness is a bit high for my taste, but at least it's tasty."

"Uh-huh..." Nicholas was still staring at Sarah's exposed nipple as she emptied the glass, licking off the milk moustache with twinkling eyes as she looked at the pastor amusedly. "Uh, I mean... What about tonight? Do you think you'll be alright with not milking yourself for about eight hours?"

"Iii... don't know. Seriously, they're probably going to be as large as beachballs and super-leaky once I wake up. And... maybe I'll wake up next to you?" Sarah batted her eyes at Nicholas, playfully coy as she pushed her enormous chest together with both arms, only for four dark spots to appear over both of her giant boobs. "Oh, c'mon!"

Nicholas' brain basically shut down as Sarah bared both of her breasts, methodically tugging each of her nipples in turn until she was satisfied with her work, hot cream splashing into her glass to be gulped down quickly.

"Okay, let me try that again, without any of the roundabout stuff: I want to sleep in your bed tonight." As Sarah covered herself again, Nicholas felt his mental faculties return.

"And where am I gonna slee--" They returned rather slowly. "Uhm. I mean... Of course! Sounds great!"

Sarah giggled at how flustered Nicholas was - and the pastor blushed. By all accounts, it didn't make sense for him to feel this way - he had Sarah drink from his tits, he'd had sex with her, so why was Nicholas getting red and fidgety at the thought of sharing his bed with Sarah?

"You're cute, you know that?" Sarah's smile was full of warmth, but she definitely enjoyed teasing Nicholas a little too much. Maybe.

But Nicholas didn't mind. He enjoyed getting to know Sarah better just as much as he enjoyed both their breasts.


"You know, we should have thought about how big we are now..."

"I don't know what you mean. It's nice and cuddly. Mmmfh." Burying her face between Nicholas' pajama-clad boobs, Sarah hugged him close, her naked, oversized breasts pushing against Nicholas' stomach. Voice muffled, she continued: "I don't mind at all."

Neither did Nicholas, but his bed was technically designed for one person, not two people and four big, milky titties. Room was thus a little scarce, but it was nice and warm under the covers, Sarah's breath on Nicholas' boobs tingled pleasantly, and he could feel six of her erect nipples poke into his belly, the other two brushing against his waist.

"Mhmm~..." Kissing the top of Sarah's forehead, Nicholas took a deep breath, drawing in her scent. "It's nice..."

"Agh!" Sarah twitched and lifted her head to look at Nicholas with widening eyes. "One thing isn't nice - I think I'm about to leak again! I hugged you too tight..."

"That's not a problem, that's an opportunity." Smiling as he thought back to the exquisite taste of his own milk, Nicholas scooted back just enough to grab one of Sarah's voluminous, sloshing breasts with both hands, pulling it towards his face. Sarah hummed in understanding and appreciation, pushing herself towards the headrest and throwing back the covers to allow Nicholas better access. "Allow me-mmh~..."

Wrapping his lips around one thick teat gently, the others brushing against his face and beading with milk as he began sucking, Nicholas was surprised how large it felt in his mouth. It had to be longer and thicker than one of his thumbs, thrumming with Sarah's excited heartbeat. And Nicholas had been right - the first tiny droplets of milk forming at the tip of Sarah's nipple were enough to make him salivate, rich, warm sweetness beginning to fill his mouth.

"Aannh~..." Moaning softly, Sarah caressed Nicholas' hair and arched her back, pushing her pillowy boob further into his face. He could feel himself grow harder, his girthy length sliding between Sarah's soft, silky thighs. "Feelsh sho good..."

Sarah had taken her right tit and popped one of its nipples into her own mouth, draining the thick cream with deep gulps. The small beads of milk dribbling into Nicholas mouth hat turned into rivulets and then a gushing stream within seconds, his cheeks bulging before he swallowed the sweet bounty, closing his eyes as he relished the taste. Nicholas had never much cared for milk before this week, actually; but now, he couldn't live without it anymore. At least if it came from Sarah's tits - or his.

Speaking of Nicholas' spectacular breasts: They practically pulsed with pleasure, nipples tenting the fabric of his pajamas - and tiny dark spots beginning to spread through the fabric, even though Nicholas had taken care to milk himself thoroughly before going to bed. It seemed that the sympathetic reaction between Sarah and him was rather strong if it could make him leaky again so soon. Although it couldn't explain why Sarah's tits had grown so much so quickly - and gained three additional nipples each. Not that Nicholas actually cared; his life had taken a strange, lustful turn, but he loved it. Every minute of it.

Especially with Sarah's fat nipple crammed in his mouth, the other three pressing against his neck and cheek, stiff and leaking as if in sympathy with the one Nicholas was sucking on. Sarah, too, had milked herself before she'd joined him in the bed, and yet her huge tits seemed to have a never ending supply of creamy, sweet milk for Nicholas to gulp down as his hips pumped slowly, his veiny rod sliding over Sarah's moistening lower lips, making her mewl softly around her own nipple, eyes rolling up in her head in the **** of sensations. It felt so different compared to their thryst in the kitchen, less frenzied and **** for release, but much more sensual, intimate... and no less lustful.

And Nicholas wasn't faring much better than Sarah - his head was spinning with lust, fat, heavy nuts churning in preparation for another climax that promised to be just as intense as the first one. Which, of course, would leave another mess behind that they would then have to clean up... But luckily, the solution for that particular problem lay right behind Nicholas. Twisting his right arm, he ruffled through the pile of condoms on his nightstand, knocking several to the floor, and grabbed the largest wrapper he could find.

Letting go of Sarah's enormous tit, Nicholas ripped the wrapper open and pulled the ribbed condom out, flinging the plastic wrapper away, and went to wrap his throbbing schlong in latex. Of course, this required Nicholas to push his face deep into Sarah' soft breast to reach his cock with both arms around her waist, but that was the opposite of a problem, really.

Fitting the condom around his swollen girth did prove to be a problem - even a this size, Nicholas barely managed to fit it over his tip. Letting his right hand run over Sarah's ass and then thigh, Nicholas made his lover shudder and groan around her fat nipple and then pushed his hand between Sarah's thighs to pull the condom on properly, both hands wrapping around his twitching pole. The rubber barely made it to two thirds of his length. But the important thing was that now, Nicholas wouldn't make nearly as much of a mess as before. His right hand momentarily returned to Sarah's ass to knead and squeeze the soft, sensitive flesh.

But now he could get back to focusing on Sarah's marvelously milky boob. The creamy flow had diminished somewhat, but with Nicholas suckling again, his cheeks soon bulged with milk once more. Moaning appreciatively between gulps, tongue twirling around the thick nipple between his lips, Nicholas thrust his hips between Sarah's thighs, feeling pre begin to bubble from his swollen glans and into the condom's reservoir, slowly filling the rubber.

Sarah was not idle, of course; rubbing her thighs against Nicholas' cock, she dragged her pussy along its length, lower lips fluttering excitedly as her upper lips kept sucking and slurping the cream from her left breast. Her muffled moans mingled with Nicholas' as her left hand strayed from her tit to his, making him groan around his lover's nipple as her fingers played over his desperately hard nipples under the fabric. The wet blotches had spread a little, having become about quarter-sized now, and still milk was beading on Nicholas' nipples and soaking into the pajama top. It wasn't much, but after the thorough milking barely an hour ago, even these little droplets were impressive.

But not as impressive as the abundance Sarah's breasts provided. Nicholas could literally feel his lover's tit shrink in his hands as he drank and suckled and slurped, and still the flow of Sarah's milk didn't slow down, thick streams gushing from her thick nipple. Nicholas felt so full already, but it was so tasty, so creamy and sweet... It almost made him miss the tell-tale churning of his plump balls and the lurching of his veiny shaft that heralded his climax, hips bucking to drive his cock between Sarah's thighs.

"Mnnnah~!" With a drawn out slurp, Sarah pulled her nipple from her mouth, cooing as a few last drops fell from it and Nicholas kept suckling on her other teat. She knew Nicholas was about to cum and apparently couldn't pass up the opportunity to egg him on. "You like my huuuge udders, Nicholas? Is my milk taaasty~?"

"Mmmgh!" The answer was non-verbal, but oh so enthusiastic. Groaning in between gulps, Nicholas pistoned in and out of Sarah's thighs, cock swelling and pressing against her pussy harder as he passed the point of no return, urethra yawning as Nicholas' balls clenched powerfully. "Mnghg!"

"Mnh yes, your cock's so hot and hard against my pussy~..." Meeting Nicholas' thrusts with her own hips, Sarah dragged her sodden cleft along his length, breath hitching in her throat as she flicked two of the nipples on her left breast, sending tiny droplets flying through the air. "I can feel it puls--"

With an audible squelch, Nicholas exploded into the condom, pulling Sarah tightly against him as his hips twitched. Rearing back as his back arched uncontrollably, Nicholas received a facefull of milk as Sarah's nipple kept squirting hot cream briefly before the flow slowed to a trickle. The cum fountaining from his cock, on the other hand, kept going strong for shot after shot after shot, the heavy duty condom swelling and stretching with Nicholas' load.

"Oh god, Nicholas, there's so much!" Squealing, Sarah rubbed her voluminous, still leaking breasts, squeezing Nicholas' cock with her thighs to keep him going just a bit longer. "It feels so hot against my thighs!"

"Nnghooh~... Sa--rah...!" Barely able to talk through his climax, Nicholas grunted and groaned until finally, his orgasm began to subside and he went slack, Sarah pulling him into a gentle hug and between her breasts.

"We can do that every night, if you ask me..." Squirming, Sarah reached for the well-filled condom resting against the back of her thighs and pulled it off Nicholas' shaft, pinching it closed until she could tie it off. "Could you put that on the floor, please?"

"Nnnfh..." Nicholas could barely stay awake as he set the cum balloon down next to the night stand. As soon as he turned back around, his eyes fell closed and he was asleep before Sarah had even pulled the covers back over them.

What'll happen in the morning?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)