You have to do it for real.

"Oh, I plan to." You reply loudly to everyone. "I was just getting my member nice and wet first."

"Why? Afraid to hurt her, Adonis?" Darius speaks up quickly and you bite your tongue. Dammit, you shouldn't have said that. Darius apparently is seeing more than you want him to.

"Of course not." You say and slap her ass hard from emphasis. Eudora lets out a loud scream of hopefully faked pain. "But no use ruining something I can get so much more use out of." You grin lecherously with all the evil you can muster. "Am I right?" The crowd cheered in support and you breathe a little easier. Darius' scowl grows deeper.

With a deep breath, you pull out of Eudora's pussy. She lets out a disappointed groan that she tries to hide under her breath. You almost don't catch it and it makes your heart beat even wilder than it already is. Not wanting to show any more hesitation, you put the tip of your throbbing erection against her little asshole. It didn't look like it was going to be able to accommodate your cock and you feel awful for what you are about to do. "Are you ready to have your most secret place violated?"

"No! Not my ass!" She pleads with you. She starts to sob lightly and it's enough to make you lose your hard on. "I can't take you in there!"

"Hey, don't cry." You whisper as a warning out of the corner of your mouth. "I-I can't take that." Eudora lowers her head and nods in acknowledgment. You gulp as you realize you can't keep up this **** facade for much longer. Then you get an idea. You grab her hair and pull her head up. "Tell me you want it."

"W-what?" Eudora asks.

"You heard me, bitch. I want to hear you say you want it." You hear an "Ooo" from the crowd, as if they never thought to do that. Darius' glare narrows and focuses.

"I...I want it." Eudora says in a mock low voice.

"Louder!" You yell.

"I want it!" She screams out. "I want it!"

"What do you want?" You demand. Your member is back harder than ever. Yes, this will work fine. You rub your renewed erection against her asshole to try and transfer some of the juices.

"I want you to fuck my ass!" Eudora replies. "I want you to fuck my ass hard" You press against the tight hole and Eudora grunts and groans. You think she's making it more dramatic for effect, but it may be authentic. It isn't easy going, but you are able to **** the tip of your cock into her ass. You take a deep breath, then thrust full into her, not stopping until the cheeks of her rear press against your pelvis. Eudora screams loudly, even more so than when you took her pussy.

"Oh, that is good!" You yell out, trying very hard to keep your voice steady. "Much tighter! I could stay here all day!" You lick your lips and then slap her ass a few times, trying to draw out fucking Eudora until you can give her a few moments to adjust. Then you feel her wiggle her ass against you, as if giving permission. You then proceed to thrust in and out of her ass. It is so much tighter and warmer than her pussy that you can barely stand it. Eudora is gripping you so tightly, you think she's going to squeeze it off.

"No! It hurts, it hurts, it hurts!" Eudora screams out, her fingernails digging into the wood of the wagon. "Please stop, sir!" Then she bites her lower lip as if trying to stop the voice leaving her throat.

"What happened to you wanting it? I thought you wanted this!" You reply, giving the hint. "You want this, don't you?"

"Y-yes. Yes I do!" She cries out.

"Then show it! Why don't you moan for me? I know you want to!" You pound her ass mercilessly. "No need to keep up appearances for the other girls. Show everyone here what a whore you really are!"

"Yes I am! I'm a whore and I like to be fucked! Fuck me harder!" Eudora replies. Then the moans pour out of her like someone uncorked a faucet. She shudders as your cock penetrates her asshole deeply and quickly.

"Well how about that? She's really getting into it!" Captain Caderos grinned. "I guess he knew what he was doing when he picked that sex ****."

"I want one too!" Another man laughed. You grin as you see it worked as hearing Eudora enjoy you has made it easier to keep this up. It has also made it harder to hold back and you find your climax coming up quicker and try to keep your mind focused on the mission at hand.

"My ass! You're tearing it up! And it feels so good!" Eudora cries out.

"I bet it does, slut." You growl. "What's your name?"

"Eudora, sir." She pants between moans.

"A real whore's name." You reply. "You heard my name, right? Say my name, slutty Eudora."

"A-Adonis!" She cries out. You smirk as an idea gets in your head and you grab her hair again.

"That's Master Adonis, to you." You hiss.

"Fuck my ass, Master Adonis!" Eudora cries out lustfully. That just about puts you over the edge right there. You have fantasized about her saying that just like that for so long. You thrust again and realize there was no going back at this point.

"I-I'm going to come in your ass, you want that, right?"

"Yes! Come inside my ass, Master Adonis!" Eudora replies and she wiggles her ass for you. You let go of her hair and grab her ass as you pump in deeply one last time and begin to release your seed into her. "Oh God!" She groans and pants as you shake and quiver as you fill her up with your semen. "It's so warm..."

You pant as you look down at her. Your cock is still hard and buried inside her, but you can't believe what you just did. You can barely stand up. Suddenly, Eudora looks over her shoulder and you catch her expression as she pants and shudders. The look in her eyes was one of wild wanton desire, like she enjoyed that and wanted more. She could be faking it, of course, but it looks so real...

"Good show, new guy." Darius replied. A malicious grin spread across his face. "Why not further **** her? Make her suck her own dirty juices off you." Your blissful state is interrupted with anger as you fight the urge to kill Darius. But there's no stopping it. You try to build the courage to ask such a horrible thing of poor Eudora.

It turns out you don't have to. Eudora stands up, your slowly limping cock falling out of her ass. She immediately turns around, drops to her knees and takes your dick into her mouth. You gasp in surprise at this new sensation and look down at the beautiful naked girl on her knees in front of you. She pulls your cock from her mouth and licks the entire length of it. She opens her eyes and looks up at you, simultaneously letting you know it's okay and reminding you the game is still on. You straighten and look at Darius. "Seems the whore thinks your idea is a good one. Thanks, Darius." The man grunts in frustration.

"God dammit, Darius!" Caderos snarls angrily. "Let the boy enjoy his first conquest already. Now get over here and spoil one of these women before I sever your manhood and find an actual use for it! That's an order!"

"Yes sir." Darius growls, gives you one last look, then turns and walks to the line of women. You feel the satisfaction of temporary victory and quickly check for any more voyeurs to see if it's safe to try and make for an exit.