Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by mr.z mr.z

What Does Happen Next?

A Strange New World

As you went to wash your hands, you looked at the mirror and saw the last person you wanted to see. "Having fun yet? HAHAHA" The old Witch was staring back at you through the window.

"Please." You start begging the old hag. "Please change Sally, turn her normal again. This isn't right."

"I told you how to break the curse. Whence you accept her for how she is now, then everything will go back to normal." The old Witch then pulled up a bucket of popcorn.

"Why are you doing this to me?"

*Crunch*"Because its fun to watch. Oh cheer up, nothings permanent. You just got to try harder." You place your hand over your head in frustration.

"But I am trying. I took her out in public, I'm treating her the same. But I'm not, I'm trying too but I can't help being repulsed. That's not fair to her."

"If only she was normal then things wouldn't be so bad." She says chewing on more buttery popcorn.

"I just want things to be normal. Please make her normal?" You plead with your best sad face.

"Why not, I'll help you out a bit. You want Sally to be normal, then she is normal." The Witch clapped her hands and in a flash of light, you were left looking at your own reflection. You stepped outside of the bathroom, spotting Sally from behind still sitting at your table. You walk over, excited to see her beautiful face only to see she still has that trunk in the middle of her face. Good thing you didn't get your hopes up.

"Oh, Hi there Love. Why do you look sad?" She asks as you sit down in your seat.

"Oh, its nothing. I'm just feeling full from the food."

"Here is your card." The waitress walked over handing Sally back her credit card and the bill. Your eyes froze as you see the waitress has a dangling dong for a nose just like Sally. You looked around and noticed that every woman you see has a trunk hanging where their noses should be. The Witch did make Sally normal but she did it by turning this into the new normal. That sneaky, monkey paw's wish, she got you good now.

"Is something wrong?"

"Oh no, I was just thinking... of an assignment I have to do for Nelson's class when the break ends. Its nothing. So, you wanna go back to your place or do something else?"

"Since we're here. Why don't we go for a little bit of shopping?" You nod yes which put a big smile on your girlfriends face. If only her dick wasn't blocking part of that smile. You two left Luigi's and walked down the block, passing all of the other stores and restaurants in the shopping district. You couldn't believe how everything has changed thanks to that curse. You see every woman walking around as if things were normal while they had flaccid dicks for noses. At least it makes it easier to walk with Sally in public now that she isn't the only one sticking out.

Heading into the clothing store, you see manikins with Pinocchio noses, some wearing socks over it, you guess its a fashionable article of clothing, like scarves or bracelets. At the front desk, you see a grown women picking out a ring from behind the counter and sticking her dick through it to try it on. You start to wonder if Sally owns any cockrings. You wait for your girlfriend as she picks out a couple of outfits to try on, then get dragged to the changing room while you sit on the waiting couch. Looking at your phone you see that you two have already spent over an hour at this store. Time really flies when you're dragged to go shopping. You look on your phone and see pictures of celebrities and actresses and just as your figured, they all have been altered. If you didn't see this stuff in person, you would swear someone just photoshopped dicks on Margot Robbie or Gal Gadot. You continue to look through until your phone starts ringing and its your Mom. "Hello."

"Hi Kiddo. How are things going?"

"Oh, Sally and I are having a good time. We went out to eat and I'm just waiting to for her to finish trying on clothes."

"Oh thats good. I'm just calling because your father got tickets to the big ball game. He's taking Jake to go watch it, the two are having a little boys trip for the weekend. Do you and Sally want to come over for Dinner, I'm making meatloaf?"

"I'll ask her when she gets out. Okay love you Mom." You two exchange goodbyes and hang up. You sit waiting, looking at the time until you notice a cute Asian girl around your age drinking boba tea looking back at you. You couldn't help but notice her flaccid penis had barely any foreskin to cover up her head. Do they do circumcision in this world? You notice you've been staring too long and just smiled and waved. She smiles and waves back. Then you notice her 4 inch nose starting to rise up and straighten out as you were giving her a boner. She stroked her erection once and gave you a wink that caused you to blush and turn away. Just in time to be saved by Sally.

"There you are. What do you think about these." She shows you the dresses and tops she picked out. You nod and then she gave you a big huge but it felt more possessive than affectionate. You look over and see your girlfriend spotted the Asian girl you were accidentally flirting with. The black haired British girl mouthed 'he's mine' then held up her hand and using the too small hand gesture towards the girl. You then noticed something bad. Compared to most of the women you have seen today, none of them compared to Sally in the big nose department. A lump went down your throat as you realized your girlfriend had a huge cock. The thought was broken by her slapping your on the ass and giving you a powerful kiss, her nose pushed roughly against yours. You two go over to buy the clothes, the cashier lady you noticed had studs pierced down the topside of her shaft, so it could be worst if Sally had something similar. You two exit and realized its already late in the afternoon. "So what do you wanna do?"

"My Mom invited us over for dinner."

"Oh thats nice of her. I also got a call from Monica, she invited us over. What do you wanna do?"

What's Your Answer

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)