Take Charge

Maybe it was the alcohol that gave it that little extra push. As I felt the thread tighten within me, the world seemed to slow. Her lips. The warmth of her bare skin against mine. The feeling of her breasts pressed against me. That damn perfume. All of it was too much. I loved Kaylee with all my heart. My mind was set that she would be the only woman in my life even if I wasn’t the only guy in hers. No matter how attractive other women were, I had no serious interest in them.

This situation shouldn’t even be happening. It was an artificial construct, built by the woman I loved. I knew I should pull back. To stop this all while I still had the reason to pull back.

But I was a man too, damn it. Kaylee was the only woman in my eye, but how could I resist this woman throwing herself at me when my own girlfriend was pushing me towards her?

The thread snapped, and everything holding me together collapsed. I pushed myself against Kayla, my arms sweeping around her to pull her close. The tepid kiss she gave me was returned by my own. My tongue forced its way into her mouth. Her attitude shifted immediately, meeting my passion with her own.

Breaking the kiss, I didn’t give her time to recover as I pushed her back onto the bed. Crawling over her, I attacked her lips again. I felt her hands against me, pulling me in closer. As she gasped beneath me, I went exploring. Her neck was first. Breathing deeply, my head spun from her fiery scent. Different than the sweet and relaxing scent of Kaylee.

Kaylee.

The intensity began to fade as passion bled from me, yet I didn’t stop. My lips still teased the skin of her neck. Hands roamed her soft form. There was a whisper of familiarity, yet everything was wrong. All wrong. A touch that would elicit a moan from Kaylee was rewarded with silence. An accidental brush here would cause the woman below me to shutter in pleasure. I was an explorer stranded in a new world searching for a way home.

After a slow march down, I finally arrived at her breasts. Here in my hand, they were mountains compared to what I was used to. My lips sucked at her pink nipples. They were darker and more pronounced than Kaylee’s. My hand explored the other. I was shocked with how much there was and didn’t know what to do with so much. Kayla seemed far more sensitive to my touch here. Another difference. I took my time, taking advantage of this opportunity to experience something new. Kayla was a tough woman to read. She was expressive, but in a different way than Kaylee. I could never mistake Kaylee’s signals on what worked and what didn’t. Her cousin was different. Her moans were softer, and she groaned and sighed far more than I was used to. Vocal, but in a subdued way. It made it difficult for me to figure out what she liked and what she didn’t.

I did get the sense that I was lingering a bit too long on her breasts. I don’t think she was going to shoo me off, but the way she began to squirm under me told me it was time to move on.

Kissing her stomach, I pulled her panties down as I went lower. There was nothing here to guide me. Kayla was shaved bald. Taking her panties off, I tossed them over my shoulder as I slid off her. Kneeling at the side of the bed, I grabbed her legs and pulled her towards me. Propping her legs on my shoulder, I looked up to find a surprised face looking down at me.

“Oh my god. Are you going to—”

Leaning forward, I pressed my lips against her slit. If there was one thing I was confident about, it was this. A tragic consequence of my bedroom trouble with Kaylee, I often had to resort to this to get her the rest of the way. I never once hesitated with Kaylee. Here, I was in unfamiliar territory. Everything was there, but different.

I didn’t let this deter me. I put everything I had into this. Every trick I’d learned with Kaylee was put to the test. Not all of them worked on Kayla, not like they would have with Kaylee. It was enough though. The girl subdued girl was gone. Her hand grabbed at my hair, legs crushing my head. I had to reach around with my hands to relieve the pressure she was putting on me. But the sounds she made! I debated slowing my pace down. Poor girl sounded like she was hyperventilating.

“Fuck. Fuck. Fuck! Don’t stop. Don’t fucking stop!” she cried out. Hearing a different voice urge me on conflicted me, but I pushed it aside. She called my name, voice cracking. Body shuddering violently, I was shocked that she had cum already. It felt like I wasn’t even warmed up yet. It certainly wouldn’t have been enough for Kaylee.

Fighting against her powerful legs and contractions, I briefly debated what to do. Should I stop here to let her catch her breath? The convulsions weakened, and I made my decision to press on. I wasn’t tired at all.

The results were unexpected.

It sounded like she was getting murdered the way she was screaming my name. I think I was fighting more with her twisting and trying to pop my head off with her legs than actually pleasuring her. Her second orgasm was even bigger than the first. By the time I called it quits, I was relatively confident I’d given her a third.

Sweating and out of breath, I rubbed at my sore neck. Kayla was wiped out, micro tremors dancing in her legs as she gasped for air.

“‘Passable’ was it?” Kaylee said with a laugh. My skeleton about leapt from my skin. In everything, I’d forgotten she was there. Guilt shot through me as she breezed past. She sat on the bed beside her cousin, grinning down at her.

“Jesus,” Kayla gasped as she wiped sweat from her forehead. “You fucking liar,” she said between heavy gasps of air. “You told me he wasn’t that experienced.”

Unease teased me as I glanced at Kaylee. What else had she told her? She didn’t say anything, wearing a mischievous grin as she turned her head to look at me. “Well? Pants off!” Blinking, I focused on her outstretched hand. I don’t know where she’d kept it, but I instantly recognized the already opened condom sitting in her palm.

“Wait, wait,” Kayla gasped. Sucking in a deep breath, she pushed herself up. “I wanna watch this.”

I stood rooted in my spot as both women stared expectantly at me.

“Um…”

“No need to be shy now,” Kayla said with a breathy laugh. Kaylee was giving me an warm smile, brightening when I looked at her. Was she really unfazed by that? Even as guilt tore through me, I searched those beautiful eyes of hers for any hint of jealousy, envy, or anger. Nothing but a hunger for more. I wasn’t sure how to process that. Watching the woman I loved with another man was a gutting experience, yet Kaylee seemed to feel none of that. How could she not? Did I mean that little to her?

Or was it me that was blowing this all out of proportion?

With those thoughts swarming through me, I kicked off my shoes. Relief flooded me as I took a moment to let them stretch. My belt was next before working at the multi-stage hook, button, zipper system to undo my pants. That was as far as I could get. Standing there in my underwear, I found myself hitting a wall I couldn’t pass.

The only woman who had ever seen me naked was Kaylee—Paige too I guess, but she didn’t count—and it had taken time develop my confidence around her. Standing here, all I could think of was god damn Zoe. Her laugh cut through my mind, freezing me in place. It wasn’t just her though. It was Ellie and the other’s looks when Kaylee let slip my size. Now I stood before two experienced women who were looking at me expecting great things. All the confidence I’d managed to build up until now fizzled away.

Looking at Kaylee, I found nothing but encouragement from her. I still didn’t understand her motivations for this and why she was pushing so hard.

Fuck it. I was over thinking things. The only one here hung up over this situation was me. Kaylee seemed perfectly at ease with how things were progressing, and Kayla was clearly interested in seeing things through. With a quick pull and step, I was completely exposed. Nothing else to do but await judgment.

Both girls took me in. The way Kaylee looked at me never failed to bolster my spirits. The surprise was Kayla, who seemed accepting. Unlike Kaylee, her eyes lingered on my erection. Even after the rocking orgasms I’d given her, she was still hungry for more. It was a good indication that my girlfriend’s insatiable nature ran deeper in the Webb family than just her and her mother.

Kayla pulled her gaze from my cock and gave me a wide smile. Falling backwards onto the bed, she propped herself up with her elbows and seductively dangled her legs over the edge of the bed “I can’t wait to get that lovely thing inside me.”

Kaylee rolled her eyes. Getting off the bed, she approached me. “Here,” she whispered as she slowly rolled the condom over my cock. I didn't even realize I was so hard. When did that happen? The entire time, her eyes never left mine. I had no doubt of her standing on this. Leaning forward, I felt her cheek against mine. “Enjoy,” she breathed against my ear. Her voice and hot breath caused a shiver to run over me.

“Oh wow. Scott’s packing live ammo?” Kayla asked when Kaylee stepped to the side. My back stiffened at her question, wondering how Kaylee was going to spin this.

“Nah,” Kaylee said with a laugh. “I always make him wear one with other girls.”

Her cousin giggled. “Such a cruel bitch. Are you that afraid another pussy is going to lure him away?”

“You wish.”

Kayla gave her a fake pout. “Let the poor guy go free.”

“You just want a creampie.”

“Guilty.”

“Tough shit,” Kaylee said as she crossed her arms. “Either he wears the condom, or you miss out on adding another one to your Profile.”

Clicking her tongue, Kayla rolled her eyes but nodded in agreement. What got me wasn’t her flippant attitude, but that she spread her legs before fixing me a welcoming smile. My heart hammered as my legs refused to move. I probably never would have moved again until Kaylee gave me a slight push towards her waiting cousin. I focused on keeping my breathing steady as I found myself between her legs. Below me, Kayla’s eyes met mine. Her lower lip rolled into her mouth as desire burned behind her eyes. The only thing that kept me from locking up again was that look in her eye. Even if they were different than Kaylee’s, the way she looked at me reminded me of how my girlfriend looked at me. She wanted me.

Peeling my eyes away from hers, I looked down to see my erection at full mast, ready and willing to get started. With the bright pink condom on, it looked like a damn glow stick. I jumped slightly as I felt fingers trail over my shoulders as Kaylee moved around me to sit on the bed beside her cousin. Once more, I found both girls watching me, waiting for me to make the move.

Swallowing the lump in my throat, I guided my cock to the unfamiliar entrance. Her soaked lips separated as the head of my cock pressed against them. I gave one last look at Kaylee, expecting her to stop me. She wasn’t looking at me anymore, her eyes on that bright pink condom. I think she was holding her breath.

Unable to stop, I pushed forward. Kayla made a satisfied cooing noise as my cock disappeared into her. I stopped once there was nothing more for me to give. Her legs pressed against me, tightening the walls around my cock in the process. Kaylee was a tighter, but this was equally good in other ways. It hit me then that this was happening. I was currently balls deep in another girl while my girlfriend watched. Nervously, I glanced over at Kaylee.

“How is it?” she asked. It wasn’t directed to me however. Kaylee’s attention was on Kayla.

“Off to a good start,” she breathed. Her attention turned to me and I understood what she wanted. Wordlessly, I pulled mostly out before slowly pushing back in. I was rewarded with a pleasant moan. Slowly drawing out, I rammed my cock into her. She let out a surprised squeal, eyes going wide. Since she seemed to like that, I did it again and was rewarded with another lovely noise. A quick thrust in, long draw out. She might have been enjoying it, but that wasn’t my reason for continuing it for so long. The entire time, my eyes had locked onto her breasts. Each big thrust caused the wonderful things to move atop her chest. Being larger than Kaylee’s, there was a lot more reaction to them. Kaylee’s breasts were firm and pert, so it took a bit to get them to move. These though… every little movement was mesmerizing.

Without realizing it, I had sped up my thrusts. Kayla was panting as my hips pistoned against hers. My eyes never left the wondrous dance her breasts were making. I was lost in a daze.

“Right there,” she gasped. “Right there!” Her hands grabbed at my ass, pulling at me in time with my thrusts. Her legs had locked around me. Tightening her hold on me, it was getting increasingly difficult to maintain my pace. Acting on instinct, I reached down to hook my arms under her legs. Pausing, I took a moment to pull them up to my shoulders. Leaning forward, I met Kayla’s eyes as I began pounding myself into her. The reaction was everything I’d hoped for. She practically screamed my name as I hammered myself into her.

Even then, the call of her breasts was overwhelming. Dropping her legs off my shoulder, I spread them apart as I leaned forward. Cupping one of the flesh mountains in my hand, I gently massaged it as I sucked on the nipple of the other one. At the same time, I did my best to continue pumping my cock into her.

Lost in the pleasure of it all, I knew that this wasn’t Kaylee. Everything was wrong, from the feel of the hot wetness clamped around my cock to the feel of her skin against mine. I knew it wasn’t Kaylee and yet I couldn’t stop myself. It wasn’t about which one was better, because there was no comparison. This was different though, and no less enjoyable.

“I’m going to cum.”

The announcement cut through the lustful haze that drove my movements. Lips moving away from her lush breast, I looked up at her. Face awash with pleasure, it looked like she was barely keeping things together. “Fuck,” she moaned, hips bucking up against mine. “Cumming. I’m cumming! Scott!” she squealed, legs clamping against me as her orgasm rocked her body. Something overtook me at the moment. Seeing her face light up as she climaxed dug at something in me. Without thinking, I pressed my lips against hers as I did my best to hammer against her. Arms locked my neck in place as she met my kiss with her own. I could feel her groaning against me as I gave her no quarter. I only broke our impassioned kissing for air. By the time I let up to gaze down at her, she was already working her way up to a second orgasm.

Stopping myself, I pulled out completely—earning me a betrayed look from the girl. Grabbing her, I rolled onto my back while pulling her atop me. If she wanted that second orgasm, she was going to have to work for it. Kayla wasted no time either, bouncing herself atop my cock. The move was entirely worth it as I was treated to the magical sight of her large breasts bouncing up and down with her. My hand gravitated towards them, gently supporting them as my fingers toyed with her nipples. As sensitive as she was, her eyes lit up as I teased her nipples. I doubt she lasted more than thirty seconds before another orgasm was running through her. Despite panting for breath, she managed to soldier on, though my hands were needed to steady her atop me. Looking down, I was treated to the sight of bright pink being swallowed up only to reappear seconds later.

“Having fun?” Kaylee’s voice caused me to jerk in surprise. I’d lost myself in the moment, forgetting she was sitting next to us. Once more, her attention wasn’t on me but on her cousin.

“Fuck,” she gasped.

“Like my boyfriend’s cock?”

Her answer was an affirmative moan. To my surprise, Kaylee reached over and rested her hand against her cheek. Turning her head, she leaned forward and I watched in stunned silence as the two shared a kiss that made my earlier one look chaste. Kayla’s arms were around Kaylee’s neck, holding her in place as their kiss dragged on. I swear she tightened up around my cock. Between watching the girls make out and her steady up down movements, I was at my limit.

Grunting, my head went back against the bed as my grip tightened around Kayla’s waist. Holding her down, I put everything into that last thrust as I exploded inside her. The orgasm was so powerful, my head spun. It felt endless as my cock throbbed, pumping the condom full of my seed. Exhausted, I flopped back against the bed, eyes closed and gasping hard as I enjoyed the bliss of such a powerful release.

I still couldn’t believe what had happened. Not only had I just fucked another girl, but I came while watching her make out with my girlfriend. My vision was swimming and I didn't know if it was from that intense orgasm or the alcohol from earlier.

“I think you broke him,” Kaylee said with a giggle. I felt a hand run along my chest. I didn’t need to see her to know it was Kaylee.

Even though my cock was softening, Kayla made no effort to lift herself off me. She sounded winded as she spoke. “That was exactly what I needed today.” A deep breath followed by a slow release. “This brings back memories, doesn’t it?”

A chuckle from Kaylee. “Except I’d usually be the one going first.”

“You always were a selfish bitch.”

I managed to open my eyes as Kayla lifted herself off me. Kaylee had her hands around the base of my cock, keeping the condom in place as her cousin towered over me. She pulled off the condom without a word, giving me a wink when our eyes met.

“Should have let me fuck him without it,” Kayla said, watching Kaylee as she removed the condom. “I always loved having you eat it out of me after.”

Kaylee stiffened slightly, giving me a quick glance from the corner of her eye. “That was a long time ago,” she said softly.

“Strip down and we can still do it,” she said with a wiggle of her eyebrows. Kaylee shook her head, causing her cousin to pout. “Boo. You’ve gotten boring in your old age.” I managed to catch sight of Kaylee moving the condom to her mouth when Kayla got my attention with a hand to my chest. She had an all-too-familiar look in her eye as she smiled. “So… How long for a round two?”