Day Five

I awoke in the witch’s guest room, more well rested than I have in days, likely due to the proper bed. After sorting through my belongings and tidying up the room, I headed back downstairs.

“Ah, there you are,” said Minerva. “Your friends should be returning from their bath soon. You should go next.”

“Bath? Where?” I asked, unsure whether there was such thing as indoor plumbing.

“The river, of course. It’s only a short walk away. I was even kind enough to lend them some of my herbal cleansing mixtures,” she said.

“What’s, oh wait, never mind.” I said. It’s just a more complicated way of saying shampoo. “Thanks Minerva. I’ll take you up on that.”

“Have fun,” she smirked, tossing me a towel. Oblivious to the eerie vibes she was giving off, I left her cabin and headed down towards the river. As the water came into view, I realized I hadn’t seen my companions yet, and they were likely still bathing. My pride as a man on the line, I initiated stealth mode. In other words, I hid behind a tree and peeked towards the river.

“What the hell!?” I exclaimed, gawking at the sight before me. My cock instantly hardened at the sight of Sofia and Lucille 69ing on the shore while Flora masturbated off to the side. The trio was going at it with such vigor that everything began to fall into place. The “herbal cleansing mixtures”. The eerie vibes. The smirk. The shampoo must’ve been laced with an aphrodisiac. My hypothesis was quickly confirmed when, after hearing my outburst, Sofia and Lucille immediately charged me, knocking me to the ground and stripping me.

“Need it so bad,” moaned Lucille who played with herself as she pulled my shirt off.

“Me first,” declared Sofia, tossing aside my pants and jumping atop my cock. The second I entered her sopping wet pussy, she cried out in ecstasy. Clearly this aphrodisiac was powerful, and while I was feeling a tad guilty about using this opportunity to have sex with these three busty beauties, there was also the possibility of real harm that could befall them if their urges weren’t satisfied. So, there’s my moral justification as the hero. Time to enjoy myself.

I grabbed onto Sofia’s hips, pulling her down onto my cock as I began to thrust up into her. Lucille couldn’t take the wait anymore and straddled my face, playing with her breasts as I ate her out. Flora drew slightly closer, either too shy to join in, or just quite the voyeur.

Based on audio cues, I learned that Sofia and Lucille had begun making out on top of me. Fuck yeah. The sheer amount of sexiness becoming too much to handle, I sped up my thrusts, knowing my orgasm wasn’t far off. Apparently, neither was Sofia’s, as she came first, setting me off as well. After Sofia came, Lucille greedily shoved her off my cock, taking my cum into her mouth.

“My turn, my turn,” she said, getting on all fours and shaking her round ass at me. Knowing what I’d have to do, I cast steal on my pile of discarded clothes, obtaining the magic item I was looking for. With the cock ring secured, my shaft sprung back to life in record time. So, I gave Lucille what she wanted.

I rammed my dick into her tight snatch at full force, causing her to cry out in pleasure. She was already pushing her hips back into me. I met her thrusts, giving her all the dick she desired. Enchanted by her plump ass, I kneaded it in my hands, giving it a few light smacks for good measure. Turns out, Lucille is really into that, and began begging me to keep smacking her ass.

Not one to leave a lady hanging, I slowly ramped up the intensity of my slaps along with the speed of my hips. Satisfied, but still eager, Sofia came up behind me, whispering in my ear.

“Oh yeah, give it to her. Fuck that slut,” she goaded, planting kisses on my neck. Her dirty talk quickly became too much for me to handle, and I pulled out right as Lucille came, shooting my seed all over her back. I pulled Sofia in for a kiss on the lips as Lucille collapsed onto the ground. Then, I turned to the remaining girl.

“Don’t be shy,” I said, slightly waving my dick at her. “I know you’d rather me help you out. Right?” She nodded nervously, and I went over to her.

“It’s my first time...so,” she said nervously, still masturbating furiously.

“Gotcha,” I said. Looks like she wouldn’t need any prep work, as she was already more than wet enough. “I’ll be careful.”

“T-thanks, but please hurry, I can’t stand it any more,” she moaned, spreading her legs. I rubbed my tip against her virgin slit. Sofia came up beside Flora, the two making out. Seizing the opportunity, I pushed my way inside, breaking her hymen swiftly but gently. She moaned, shifting in discomfort. I gave her a moment to adjust before beginning to move.

The aphrodisiac was clearly helping her out as it only took a short amount of time for her moans to be ones of pure bliss. I started fucking the merchant even faster in the missionary position. Sofia was suckling on Flora’s modest chest, determined to show the girl a good first time. Deciding to give the redhead a reward, I began to finger her snatch while she played with Flora. Sofia eagerly pushed back against my hand, Flora’s moaning turning her on as well.

Soon enough, the virgin girl started to cum, her tight little pussy spasming violently around my shaft. Sensing my orgasm fast approaching, I pulled out, Sofia spun around to take the load in her mouth, and fingered herself to a second orgasm.

With the party exhausted and satisfied, I removed the magic item, placing it safely back with my belongings.

“You all feeling better now?” I asked the still slightly dazed girls.

“That was a lot of fun,” said Sofia, the first to stand back up. “You’re really good at this sorta stuff Flynn.”

“I must also agree. Though I know not what caused my sudden outburst, it was a rather enjoyable occasion,” said Lucille, formal even while in the nude.

“Um, thank you, Flynn,” said Flora. I shot her a quizzical look. “I always wanted my first time to be with someone nice, strong, and gentle like you...so thanks.”

“Thank you,” I whispered to no one in particular. After all, one of my own dreams had just come true. A bonafide foursome. This world truly was the gift that keeps on giving. Though, I will have to remember to thank Minerva later.

“More importantly,” I said. “I think we’re all going to need another bath.”

“That is true,” said Lucille, heading over to pick up the shampoo again. I snatched it out of her hands, chucking it far away into the forest. Too much power can corrupt any man, after all.

“No more of that,” I said. The four of us hopped into the stream for a quick bath, washing off the sweat and fluids from our bodies. For some reason, the orgy seemed to make everyone care a lot less about keeping their modesty intact, no clue why.

We redressed and headed back to Minerva’s cabin, talking about nothing in particular on the way back. I pulled Minerva off to the side for a bit as the others gathered their things.

“Thank you very much!” I said, bowing down in respect to the benevolent witch of the woods.

“Ara~...looks like someone had a fun time,” she laughed.

“I think we all did,” I admitted. “But, why did you do that? It isn’t as though-”

“Hm? Let’s just say I have my own reasons. I *am* a witch after all...” she cackled. “I do have another gift for you all.”

“Oh? What’s that?” I asked, my curiosity piqued.

“I happen to possess a wagon, but lack a proper steed to pull it. I’ve been thinking about getting rid of it for a while now, and who would come along but a promising young party of adventurers and their trusty mule?” she said.

“Really? You’d just give it to us? Free of charge? It sounds too good to be true,” I said, suspicious.

“I never said free of charge. You’re going to carry a token to Hearthvale for me. Take this to a man named Gideon. On your way back home, stop by and tell me what he said. Then, you can keep the wagon,” she said, handing me a pendant. It was silver with a small onyx stone embedded in the center. A simple, but beautiful design.

“Sounds easy enough,” I said. “It isn’t gonna like, summon a demon and kill everyone there, is it?”

She laughed, “Oh you and your wild little fantasies.”

She didn’t confirm or deny. Ugh.

“Deal,” I said, shaking her hand. Minerva then brought me over to the wagon behind her home, and showed both Flora and I how to set the harness to Hershel for the mule to draw the wagon. After a bit of goodbyes to the witch and the “smart” cyclops, we left aboard our new vehicle.

With Flora as our driver, the three of us rested in the back with her cargo, content in the knowledge we’d actually end up arriving in Hearthvale almost a full day sooner than planned, likely arriving tomorrow evening. The road was calm, and soon enough, we found it time to make camp.